I just
took apart Human Rights Watch's absurd
report on the May Gaza war, but I wanted to step back a little and describe biased, unfounded and ridiculous assumptions that HRW makes in order to reach its conclusions.
1. Gaza eyewitnesses are reliable.
- Even when they say things like "I saw a high speed Israeli missile coming gradually from a great distance and explode one meter above the ground but I didn't run away."
- Even when they would be arrested if they say anything that Hamas doesn't want them to say, like we saw armed militants come into our building all the time.
2. HRW researchers in Gaza are objective.
- Even when they would be arrested if they say anything that Hamas doesn't want them to say.
3. Israeli statements are unreliable.
- Even though they have much more to lose by being proven wrong than anyone else.
4. Israel drops one ton bombs on residential areas without any military reason or targets that HRW "experts" can find.
5. Israel flattens buildings with people inside without warning for no reason - and possibly just because they want to kill civilians out of pure malice and criminal intent.
- The fact that half of those killed in an urban war were militants - a record unmatched in the history of warfare - is utterly irrelevant to HRW.
6. Israel always starts the fighting, somehow. When Hamas shoots rockets from Gaza, it is to defend Palestinians in Jerusalem from Jewish settlers. This reasoning is not questioned.
7. Absence of evidence is evidence of absence. If HRW cannot find any trace of a Hamas presence, then Israel just bombed the building based on no evidence whatsoever.
8. The IDF is not a professional army with multiple layers of approvals for every airstrike, but it acts like a toddler who lashes out indiscriminately at any and everything that upsets it.
9. International law has nothing to say about how an army may make decisions on attacking military targets hidden among civilians.
10. Israeli attacks that kill civilians while targeting terrorists are assumed to be unlawful; Hamas attacks where they brag about directly targeting civilians are just something that needs to be investigated and do not cause any casualties worth mentioning.
11. It is critical to say that the entire conflict between Israel and Palestinians is completely Israel's fault as a state that is guilty of the worst crimes there are, and there is no background information about Gaza terror groups that run the enclave or any intifadas or bus bombings and suicide terror or incitement or anything else that any readers need to know for background information.
- The "larger context" must be taken into consideration by the UN - but only the larger context that damns Israel.
Human Rights Watch's own words show its pattern of hate for Israel as clearly as possible.