JPost Editorial: Genocide must be proven, not proclaimed, the ICJ ruling on Myanmar shows
Thursday’s judgment underscores why evidence of genocidal intent is indispensable. The court’s finding against Myanmar rested on its assessment of the conduct and circumstances of the campaign, not the number of people killed alone.Seth Mandel: The Holocaust’s Lessons Aren’t For Everyone
Israel, however, should not interpret the judgment as a straightforward vindication of its position.
Myanmar genocide ruling may complicate Israel's defense against South Africa
As The Jerusalem Post’s Yonah Jeremy Bob reported on Thursday, aspects of the decision could complicate Israel’s defense. The court took a broad view of evidence relevant to genocidal acts and intent, while maintaining that negligence, even gross negligence, does not itself establish genocide.
Israel’s legal team must therefore study the judgment carefully, particularly its treatment of political statements and the circumstances surrounding civilian suffering.
The ICJ has not cleared Israel of South Africa’s allegations. That case remains pending, and the court has not issued a final judgment on whether Israel violated the Genocide Convention. The provisional measures ordered earlier in those proceedings did not amount to a judicial finding that genocide had occurred.
Nevertheless, Thursday’s ruling should restore precision to a debate in which accusations of genocide are frequently treated as established conclusions before judicial proceedings have concluded.
South Africa is entitled to bring its case, and Israel is entitled to contest it. The court must assess both sides according to the evidence and the law, without allowing the conflict’s political intensity to substitute for either.
Calling every devastating military campaign genocide obscures the distinctions between atrocities. Equally, invoking legitimate military objectives cannot automatically negate evidence of genocidal intent where such evidence exists.
Court must seriously examine, investigate, and insist on standards for Israel case
The Rohingya deserve recognition of what was done to them, justice for those responsible, and an opportunity to rebuild their lives. Their suffering should not be reduced to a rhetorical instrument in arguments about another conflict.
Their case nevertheless demonstrates the seriousness with which accusations of genocide must be examined. South Africa has asked the ICJ to determine whether Israel committed that crime. Thursday’s ruling shows that the court can reach such a conclusion when it finds the legal requirements satisfied.
The response should be neither to prejudge Israel’s guilt nor to pretend its innocence has already been judicially established. It should be to insist upon the same rigorous standard of evidence, including proof of intent, for every state that stands accused.
The lesson for South Africa, Israel, and the international community is that genocide must be proven, not proclaimed.
The constant search for applicable “lessons” from the rise and rule of the Nazis is understandable but misdirected. Victims, not perpetrators and bystanders, ought to be the primary students of the modern world’s singular genocide.Seth Madnel: Get Your Own
As Clark’s review of Hoyer shows, the central question is how the emerging threats to the targeted community—in this case, as in many cases, Jews—are interpreted without the benefit of hindsight:
“The Nazis lacked a majority but had the leverage to secure the ministries of the interior and education for Wilhelm Frick. Frick made uninhibited use of his powers, sacking left-leaning and Jewish civil servants and replacing them with people loyal to the Nazis… Frick would eventually fall from power, once the parties of the centre recovered their will to act and joined forces against him. But the damage was done: there was no purge of the new appointees, and this brief experiment in Nazi governance revealed how weak the resistance to a more concerted assault on liberal-democratic norms was likely to be.”
Modern audiences tend to respond with something vague that they don’t actually mean about preserving liberal-democratic norms. But when they see a Hitler coming, they will be the first to argue that norms must be suspended in order to prevent the New Hitler from gaining power. The lesson for the Jews then and ever is: No one is coming to save you. So you must save yourself.
To read about the gathering storm clouds of anti-Jewish governance is to understand first and foremost that the Zionists were right and everyone else was wrong. It is to see clearly that the Palestinian Arab sin of preventing Jewish immigration to Jewish communities in the Jewish homeland must be reckoned with and atoned for the same way Vichy France had to be reckoned with and atoned for.
It is to comprehend the power and the glory of sovereignty and agency and self-determination.
And perhaps most of all, it is to know the importance of making everyone else’s “universal” lessons irrelevant.
When you rely on other people learning lessons, you make yourself vulnerable to self-interested partisanship. We just went through a series of elections in which people who rightly sounded the alarm about Trump’s enabling of anti-Semitic forces in 2016 enthusiastically supported Abdul El-Sayed, Zohran Mamdani, Adam Hamawy and Graham Platner. If your lesson from Nazi Germany is to back the guy with the Totenkopf who rants about Jews, I would like you to stop learning lessons altogether and also stay as far away from electoral politics as possible.
What matters most is what the Jews learned from the Holocaust. For that, all we need are the facts. And that is all historians should deliver.
Set aside the discredited “genocide” libel for a moment, which tinpot authoritarian demagogues use solely as a destabilizing provocation. His answer is: He won’t condemn a standalone massacre of innocent Jews because, three weeks later, Israel initiated a ground incursion into Gaza to get back its citizens that Palestinians took hostage.
Why won’t Mamdani let Jews mourn? Because he doesn’t believe they deserve to.
What’s happening here isn’t just rank anti-Semitism—that part’s undeniable. It’s that there’s an extra layer of creepiness to Mamdani’s statement: It’s stalkerish behavior, and it is characteristic of the wider Western “pro-Palestinian” movement.
Anti-Zionists like Mamdani want October 7 for themselves because the Jews have it. It’s the same reason there’s an imperialist dome along with a mosque built atop the Jews’ holy site in Jerusalem. It’s the same reason Palestinians and their advocates believe that only permitting Jews in 3 percent of Hebron—the four thousand year old Jewish city—is unfair to the Palestinians. And it’s the reason that Nakba Day was created the day after Israeli Independence Day. There is no real significance to the date aside from the naked appropriation of a day that was already meaningful to Jews.
That is also what the genocide libel is about. The comparisons of Israel’s military operations in Gaza to the Holocaust are a manifestation of trauma envy. It’s why the Chicago Tribune can print the following sentence last week about the newly renovated Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center: “The renovation did not add permanent museum content about the Hamas-led attack on Oct. 7, 2023, the largest mass killing of Jews since the Holocaust, or Israel’s resulting assault and siege on Gaza, which has been widely considered a genocide.”
Got it? The Holocaust museum did not add an exhibit on Gaza. The Holocaust museum remains a museum about the Holocaust.
Just as Israel remains the Jewish state, despite the desire of so many to confiscate the historic Jewish homeland for other purposes.














