From the Second Intifada to campus front lines: StandWithUs marks 25 years
A delegation of StandWithUs leaders and supporters from the United States and Australia met with Israeli President Isaac Herzog and first lady Michal Herzog at the President’s Residence in Jerusalem on Sunday, near the conclusion of a solidarity mission to Israel.Mahmoud Khalil’s False Martyrdom
For participants, the visit was an opportunity to demonstrate their commitment to Israel at a time of growing international criticism of the Jewish state. For Roz Rothstein, co-founder and CEO of StandWithUs, it also reflected how far the organization has come since its founding 25 years ago.
“We were determined to show solidarity and be really great role models,” Rothstein told the gathering. “We’re elevating every part of our trip just so everybody else can say, hey, maybe it’s okay to go. So, it’s a very, very special group.”
StandWithUs was founded in 2001, during the Second Intifada, when Rothstein, the daughter of Holocaust survivors, became increasingly concerned about international media coverage of Israel and the lack of organized responses to anti-Israel misinformation.
Together with her husband, Jerry Rothstein, she began investigating whether another organization was already addressing the problem. The murders of Israeli teenagers Koby Mandell and Yosef Ishran on May 8, 2001, underscored the urgency of their mission.
“Actually, nothing was going,” she recalled, describing the lack of organizational capacity, funding and resources available at the time.
The Rothsteins were particularly troubled by international media coverage they believed distorted the reality of the conflict. Jerry Rothstein recalled seeing a Los Angeles Times description of Hamas members as “freedom fighters.”
The need to explain Israel’s geography, history and security challenges to audiences abroad became a driving force behind StandWithUs. What began as an effort to fill a gap in public advocacy has grown into an international organization with programs spanning university campuses, high schools, legal advocacy and digital communications.
In his new memoir, the activist portrays himself as a victim, but his story is rife with paranoia, conspiracy theories, and anti-Israel hatred.
That Khalil is a conspiracy theorist isn’t surprising, but the depth and quality of his conspiracy theories are. He laments that the “safety concerns” of pro-Israel students were taken seriously despite not being “by any reasonable measure of the word, actual issues of safety.” Normally, campus claims of being unsafe are overblown, but that might not be the case when a masked anti-Israel demonstrator shows up to a pro-Israel event with a sign reading “Al-Qassam’s Next Target.”
Regardless, what bothers Khalil was a perceived double standard in favor of the pro-Israel side: “To understand why Columbia behaved the way it did, we have to understand who was actually running the institution and what they were protecting.” Unsurprisingly, the culprit is Jewish money. The Columbia board of trustees “are drawn overwhelmingly from finance, real estate, corporate law, and weapons manufacturers . . . some are major donors to pro-Israel causes. Some sit on the boards of Zionist organizations.” They were “profiting from the killing of Palestinians,” he claims.
Khalil shows his depth as a conspiracy theorist in his last-ditch effort to avoid deportation. Between complaints about the slow and grinding “machinery” of the immigration courts—this is due to for-profit prisons, he concludes—he informs us that he “sought asylum” in the United States because he “faced targeting by Israel if deported.” His first example of Israel having engaged in similar perfidy before is Ghassan Kanafani, spokesman for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, who took credit for murdering 26 civilians weeks before his assassination. If Israel were still interested in assassinating spokesmen for terrorist groups, it’s not clear why it would wait until its targets were on Syrian or Algerian soil.
What Khalil imagines as a grand conspiracy is, in the end, his own actions coming back to bite him. To get this far in his con, though, he had to get extremely lucky. Any reasonable person would have expected to die invading Israel, to be expelled from Columbia for violating campus rules, or to be deported swiftly for running a terror PR campaign.
“The living martyr” has been treated with kid gloves at every step of his life, which only baffles him as he expects his enemies’ sympathy to translate into submission. His book is an attempt to curry a bit more favor and cross that threshold. He is free to keep doing so from Syria, Algeria, or the myriad lands where his ideological derangement will be more at home.




















