Wednesday, November 18, 2026

  • Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon


A new paper in Sexuality & Culture, a peer-reviewed Springer Nature journal, offers a remarkable demonstration of how academic research can be made to reach conclusions that have remarkably little to do with the evidence.

The paper, by Izat El Amoor, is titled "Palestinian Intimate Topographies: Mapping Queer Decoloniality Through Familial Marriage Pressure." The author interviewed 53 queer Palestinians about their struggles with family pressure to enter heterosexual marriages.

The abstract is an impressive collection of ideological buzzwords:

Queer Palestinian activists and scholars face a complex challenge: addressing heteronormativity within Palestinian society without reinforcing dehumanizing narratives exploited by Israeli pinkwashing or homonationalist agendas. Drawing on 53 semi-structured interviews with queer Palestinians across Palestine and Israel, this article employs a decolonial queering lens to examine familial pressure to enter heterosexual marriages. I argue that marriage functions as a central site where communal endurance and “moral hygiene” are negotiated under conditions of settler-colonial erasure. Queer Palestinians do not merely experience these pressures as “traditional” oppression, but navigate them through situated practices of relational agency. Utilizing strategies such as professional mobility, strategic silences, and “tacit subjecthood,” participants reconfigure the domestic sphere as an internal arena of resistance. This framework positions the Palestinian family as an adaptive institution in which relational repair makes it possible to negotiate queer life alongside the struggle for national liberation. In doing so, it challenges the settler state’s “rescue” logic by foregrounding the complexity of queer life within the intimate topographies of the home.

The author positions Palestinian family relationships as part of an overarching struggle against Israeli colonialism.

Only one problem: Not a single interviewee quoted in the paper blames Israel for their problems.

Not one mentions Israeli occupation, Zionism, settler colonialism, or anything remotely resembling the author's central explanation for their struggles. Instead, they describe conservative families, pressure to marry, religious expectations, concerns about family honor, and the difficulty of being gay in traditional Arab society.

Every connection between these experiences and Israeli colonialism is supplied solely by the author himself.

Consider Nirmeen, a 24-year-old bisexual woman from East Jerusalem who describes her alienation from her family:

I feel exiled and alienated around all the others in the family, and around everything Arab generally as a matter of fact. When I am at Damascus Gate... I feel foreign to myself... I am alienated to myself in my clothes, in the way I talk, even when they [the family] talk about gay people, I shut up honestly.

Damascus Gate is a major center of Palestinian Arab social life in Jerusalem. Nirmeen is explicitly describing how uncomfortable she feels within Arab society, even down to the way she dresses and speaks.

Here is El Amoor's interpretation:

Nirmeen’s narrative reveals how the demands of the marital contract are compounded by the spatial and political pressures of East Jerusalem, where Palestinians experience colonial state surveillance while also navigating communal standards of social propriety, which may serve both regulatory and protective functions.

Where did Israeli surveillance come from? Certainly not from anything Nirmeen said in the quoted text. She tells the researcher she feels alienated from Arab society, and the researcher decides that Israeli colonialism must somehow be involved.

There's more. Nirmeen considers entering a marriage of convenience with her gay cousin, allowing both to satisfy family expectations while privately living the lives they choose. The author calls this a "queering of empire."

Now compare Nirmeen's experience with research about gay people in Lebanon.

In a 2020 paper in Middle East Critique, Sabiha Allouche examined Lebanese gays and lesbians who entered heterosexual marriages of convenience to escape family pressure while preserving their private lives.

One lesbian participant, Rita, married a gay man and moved to Morocco to get away from her family's constant pressure to marry. Like Nirmeen, she saw a nominally heterosexual marriage as a way to gain freedom from family expectations.

Same family pressure. Same strategy for avoiding it. Same desire to escape a restrictive social environment.

Except Rita is Lebanese, and Israel has absolutely nothing to do with her predicament.

This doesn't prove that Israeli policies can never affect the lives of queer Palestinians. But it does demonstrate that the specific experiences El Amoor documents can occur without Israeli occupation or colonialism playing any role whatsoever.

Where does blaming Israel come from?

And El Amoor's willingness to impose unsupported political interpretations on his interviewees is hardly the only problem with the paper.

In the introduction, he makes this extraordinary claim:

The urgency of this analysis has intensified following the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023, as Palestinian familial narratives have been weaponized in Israeli and Western media to justify the ongoing genocide in Gaza.

That's quite an accusation. Israeli and Western media supposedly used accounts of Palestinian family behavior to justify genocide.

What evidence does he offer?

One of his three citations is a 2024 article in The Baffler criticizing the famous Israeli comedy show Eretz Nehederet for mocking Western Queers for Palestine activists.



The sketch features clueless American college students interviewing a Hamas terrorist who threatens to throw homosexuals from rooftops. One of the students excitedly assumes he is being invited to a rooftop party.

The joke is about the absurdity of Western queer activists supporting Hamas while remaining oblivious to its treatment of homosexuals.

This is supposed to be evidence of justifying genocide?

The other cited articles similarly discuss pinkwashing, Palestinian feminism, and allegations about Israeli policies. Not one establishes the specific accusation that Palestinian family narratives were used to justify genocide.

When gay Palestinians complain about pressure from their families, El Amoor interprets their experiences as evidence of Israeli settler colonialism. When Israeli comedians mock the contradiction between LGBTQ activism and support for Hamas, he cites it as part of an argument about justifying genocide.

In both cases, the political conclusion is supplied by the author, not established by the evidence.

Sexuality & Culture, a peer-reviewed academic journal that claims to publish systematic and rigorous research, accepted this example of poor scholarship.

Apparently, when gay Palestinians describe their problems with Arab society, the one explanation academia cannot accept is that they might actually mean what they say.


(h/t JW)


 

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

From Ian:

The Dawn of Western Palestinianism
The drama is no less artificial than it is effective. Palestine works as a unifying symbol because it is infinitely elastic. Sudan’s catastrophe offers no convenient Western villain. Ukraine ruins the anti-imperialist script because Russia is the invader, and Washington arms the victim. Israel, by contrast, can be cast as America’s outpost and the Western order’s proxy, which is to say that it can embody everything the radical left already opposes. To one activist, Palestine means anti-colonialism; to another, anti-capitalism; to a third, racial justice or resistance to American power. A slogan scrawled on a Paris wall summed up the radicals’ pooled ambitions: “Palestine will save us all.”

The political theorists Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe had a name for this: a “chain of equivalence,” in which separate grievances are welded into a single identity against a common enemy. Mélenchon has drawn openly on their work. A student angry about teacher shortages, a worker squeezed by prices, a climate activist, and a campaigner against Israel need not share the same priorities. Persuade them that their grievances are symptoms of one oppressive system, and they become a movement. That’s what France saw this fall. The students had real grievances; French public education has been failing for years. But on October 17, they marched alongside Yellow Vest veterans, unions, and cost-of-living protesters. The Palestinian flag was the one banner every faction could carry.

The strategic payoff is obvious. A school budget can be negotiated. A crusade can’t. For movements that live on permanent conflict, that’s the point.

Nor is the coalition an accident of the street. It’s the deliberate product of organizations working in concert. In September, the Association France Palestine Solidarité, BDS France, Stop Arming Israel France, and Urgence Palestine issued a call for a month of action against arms transfers to Israel. The signatories included the CGT, France’s oldest labor confederation; the student union UNEF; Mélenchon’s LFI; the Communist Party; the decolonial Parti des Indigènes de la République; and Perspectives Musulmanes.

This coalition also reached the school protests. Reporting in Le Point, French journalist Nora Bussigny described how Étudiants Musulmans de France (EMF) called on its chapters to join the mobilization and how it had previously worked with RED Jeunes, a prominent youth activist network, in a campaign against what they call “state Islamophobia.” EMF itself urged members to join the October 17 demonstrations. The students’ complaints are real. But other movements were quick to fold those complaints into their own political agendas.

Here was the red-green alliance in miniature: far-left groups and activist networks rooted in political Islam, joining the same mobilization effort despite very different long-term aims. A demand for math teachers was becoming a vehicle for a much broader argument about French institutions.

And then there is Samidoun, also named among the September campaign’s supporters. In 2024, the U.S. Treasury designated it as a fundraising front for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a terrorist organization. Nothing ties the other signatories to its activities, but when a group like that can share space on a list with France’s major unions and parties, it says something about how little the coalition worries about the company it keeps.

None of this escaped the notice of the West’s adversaries. On October 7, France’s foreign ministry said official Iranian accounts had been spreading disinformation about the student movement. Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot has also pointed to Russian and Chinese narratives exploiting the unrest. That doesn’t mean that foreign governments organized the demonstrations. They didn’t need to. The Islamic Republic knows a useful fracture when it sees one. It only needs to persuade Westerners that every grievance proves their own societies illegitimate. The Palestinian cause is useful to Tehran not because it might succeed, but because the arguments around it may never end. It provides the regime with a perpetual source of information warfare.

The greatest irony is that Palestinians themselves vanish from Western Palestinianism. Where are the marches for accountable Palestinian institutions, for elections, or for an alternative to Hamas? There are, in fact, Palestinians calling for these things. There is, for example, Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, who grew up in Gaza and has lost relatives in the war. He condemns the suffering inflicted on Palestinian civilians and holds Hamas responsible for the catastrophe it unleashed on October 7, 2023. But in Western Palestinianism, a Palestinian who wants a negotiated peace, or simply a safe future for his children, is a Palestinian who has forgotten his lines.

This is where Wilf’s point comes home. A politics built chiefly on denying Jewish sovereignty cannot offer Palestinians a future. Exported to the West, it does something else: It turns a distant national conflict into a permanent indictment of the societies its supporters live in and a gift to those who want to bring down the nations of the free world. The condescension at the heart of Western Palestinianism demands that Palestinians play the role of the world’s exemplary victims. Their suffering is useful, as it foots the bill for a form of multigenerational European group therapy. But Palestinian agency is nothing but a terrible inconvenience.
Europe is petting the wolf: How the red-green alliance threatens Western democracy
The Soviets came for communism. The Qataris came for Islamism. And Europe is being devoured along the way.

As early as the 1980s, the Soviet Union understood that it could not defeat the West through military force alone. Instead, according to accounts of Soviet intelligence strategy, it devoted an estimated 85% of the KGB's resources not to traditional espionage, but to subversion and psychological manipulation.

The strategy was to infiltrate Western academia, media and cultural institutions with what might be called "soft agents," individuals capable of gradually undermining Western citizens' confidence in their own values and national institutions.

The collapse of the Soviet Union slowed the process. But the rise of Vladimir Putin, himself a former KGB officer, gave it renewed momentum.

And then, I believe, this Russian campaign of influence found a powerful counterpart in Qatar.

Qatar is a ruthless state wrapped in the seductive glamour of extraordinary wealth. Behind the polished image of desert nobility, I see something very different: barbarians dressed in tailored suits and flowing white robes.

Its ideological bible, in my view, is the manifesto of the Muslim Brotherhood, with its vision of "civilizational jihad" — the gradual conquest of societies in the name of Islam.

Armed with fervent jihadist conviction and hundreds of billions of dollars, Qatar has, I contend, helped normalize what should be unthinkable: the admission of unskilled Muslim immigrants who contribute nothing to the economy, receive generous welfare benefits from their first day and, in the most extreme cases, passionately believe that the very people who welcomed them are infidels whose heads should be severed once they have accumulated sufficient power.

And so we return to Turin.

While police officers brace themselves in the heart of Italy's luxury shopping district, preparing for unrest that authorities already anticipate, Europe's leaders continue to embrace what they see as the purity of their liberal values.

Someone needs to wake them up.

Someone needs to tell them that the creature they are so lovingly stroking is, in fact, the wolf.
From Ian:

‘Genocide’ is being weaponised by the West’s enemies
Genocide is the most heinous of all crimes. But false accusations of genocide have become the deadliest weapon in the modern diplomatic and propaganda war, waged also in the international courts. Fortunately, we have an essential corrective to hand: today, the leading think-tank Policy Exchange publishes Genocide: The Use and Abuse of a Term.

There are many threads to this phenomenon, but one runs through it unbroken: the role of Moscow. While it is South Africa which has brought a case to the International Court of Justice to persuade it to find Israel guilty of genocide, this cannot be understood without appreciating the historic connections between the ANC and the Soviet Union, which had funded that organisation’s armed struggle against the Apartheid regime.

Incidentally, the loyalty this engendered led to the unnecessary deaths of hundreds of thousands of South Africans from Aids: in 1983, Vladimir Putin’s erstwhile employer, the KGB, launched Operation Denver (or Operation INFEKTION), a disinformation campaign which spread the claim that Aids was not a natural virus but a bio-weapon created by the US military. In government, Thabo Mbeki, the Moscow-trained South African president, duly adopted the line that the Western anti-retrovirals were a scam, based on the same conspiracy theories, and blocked the roll-out of these life-saving drugs, with appalling consequences.

It was earlier still that the Russians invented the now globally prevalent mental virus that equates Zionism with Nazism. Although the USSR had supported the creation of the state of Israel in 1948, it took the Arab side in the 1967 war, proclaimed that the military action against those states was “racial genocide”, and launched a state-backed pseudo-academic discipline known as “Zionology”. This is now embedded in Western Left-wing thought.

There, it seems to have been assumed that the ICJ had already declared it “plausible” that Israel had committed genocide in Gaza (in its attempts to defeat Hamas, after that terroristic organisation launched a modern-day anti-Semitic pogrom on Oct 7, 2023).

Broadcasters such as the BBC also followed this line before they were corrected by the ICJ president who’d overseen the case; Judge Joan Donoghue pointed out the court made no such determination, only that the Palestinians in Gaza had rights which could “plausibly” be covered by the 1948 Genocide Convention. This had been the international response to what the actual Nazis had done to the Jewish people of Europe – whose number is now still less than 15 per cent of what it was in 1940. That is the effect of real genocide.

However, the Convention does not deal so much with numbers as with motive. It requires proof of “intent” to “destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group”.

Ireland, which seeks a global leadership role over the Palestinian cause, is also busy at the ICJ in respect of Israel and Gaza: it wants to remove the requirement from the Genocide Convention that “intent” be proved. If that passed, who knows, maybe the British could be retrospectively found guilty of genocide in respect of the famine of 1845-1852, from which horror the Irish population has never fully recovered.
Seth Mandel: Israeli Hostage Families Beat the ICC in (Real) Court
There is something ingenious about the Israeli hostage families’ suit against disgraced ICC prosecutor Karim Khan, which resulted in a default judgment against Khan in Jerusalem yesterday.

Khan was the lead prosecutor at the International Criminal Court during the October 7 war. He was accused of sexual misbehavior against a subordinate and of trying to pressure her to keep quiet. An internal review found him guilty, and he lost his job. One of the wrinkles during the case was that, according to court documents, testimony, and other evidence, Khan appeared to have issued arrest warrants for Israeli leaders as part of his pressure campaign against his alleged victim. Khan also appeared to have circumvented the established legal process, plus the court has no jurisdiction over Israel since Jerusalem never opted in to the court.

With the help of Shurat Hadin, an Israeli legal organization, a group of hostage families sued Khan, alleging that his behavior prolonged the hostages’ captivity by legitimizing Hamas and undermining Israel’s negotiating leverage. Khan didn’t respond to the suit, the deadline passed, and Jerusalem District Court ordered him to pay over $8 million in damages and legal fees.

Shurat Hadin president Nitsana Darshan-Leitner told the Times of Israel that her organization intends to pursue Khan for the money owed. “Thanks to this historic ruling, prosecutors and judges at the International Criminal Court in The Hague now know that if they act unlawfully, they will be held personally liable — paying out of their own pockets,” she said.

That might be too optimistic. For one, the court didn’t find that the plaintiffs’ arguments were correct. Khan’s lack of response to the court allowed the court to order the judgment. It’s unclear how exactly one would establish that Khan’s biased and bogus charges against Benjamin Netanyahu (and then-Defense Minister Yoav Gallant) caused Hamas to hold hostages for a greater amount of time than they otherwise would have.

For another, the ICC insists on its own legal immunity for actions taken in the legitimate pursuit of its court duties. It’s a perfectly reasonable argument if you imagine the ICC as a real court, rather than an NGO-like world body designed to evade basic principles of justice and sovereignty.
Pierre Rehov: The $4 Billion Mirage: What Washington Risks Losing with Israel's Aid
A serious American president is entitled to review every dollar of foreign assistance – as Trump does. What he cannot afford is to let the people who detest Israel write the terms of that review.

Washington also needs to stop pretending that the money is a charitable allowance deposited into Israel's checking account. The annual $3.3 billion -- a tiny one-fifth of 1% of the $7 trillion US federal budget -- overwhelmingly pays for American defense equipment and services... and American manufacturers fill the orders and keep their production lines running.

Israeli engineers designed the Tamir interceptor and now American workers are building it, giving both countries a second production source. A similar process is expected to support SkyHunter, the American adaptation of the Tamir intended for the U.S. Marine Corps. Calling such an arrangement "dependency" would require a rather peculiar dictionary.

The same logic runs through the Arrow and David's Sling missile-defense systems, co-developed and co-produced by Israel with the Pentagon's Missile Defense Agency. Israel has spent decades testing weapons and equipment in conditions that American procurement committees cannot reproduce in PowerPoint slides or testing ranges. The Pentagon cooperates with the Israeli military and defense industry for hard-headed reasons, chief among them intelligence and technology proven against adversaries the two countries share.

In the Middle East, where some American partner countries require an American defense umbrella as well as constant diplomatic reassurance before doing anything useful, Israel has proved willing to bear the human cost of its own and the West's defense.

Intelligence does not come with a publicly audited price tag. Neither do lessons learned in combat or the ability to intercept ballistic missiles that can also target American forces.

Netanyahu had actually proposed something more orderly. In January he said he wanted to taper American military aid to zero within a decade, and in July, at the White House, he repeated the goal while floating a joint weapons research fund worth roughly $16 billion. That is an intelligible strategic ambition: a country obliged to fight for its survival should want the greatest possible control over its own arsenals. A transition negotiated over 10 years would give planners and manufacturers time to adapt, whereas an abrupt cutoff collides with contracts already signed. Israel has roughly $10 billion in American weapons on order beyond what the current agreement covers, including F-35s due from 2028, and its military plans acquisitions around multiyear commitments that no press release can rewrite.

Israel has learned why independence matters. American administrations have used the flow of weapons to steer Israeli operations, as Washington did in 2024 when it held back a shipment of 2,000-pound bombs over a planned offensive in Rafah. Even a friendly administration has domestic constituencies to appease.

A foreign alliance that makes the United States stronger should survive a bad election season. The only test worth applying is whether military cooperation serves America's interests -- a question that slogans devised by candidates who find the Jewish state a convenient punching bag do nothing to answer.

The foreign military financing may yet prove the least consequential part of negotiations. US officials are reportedly seeking the transfer of Israeli expertise to American management, patents included -- a demand Jerusalem regards as an erosion of the technological edge its defense industries hold in world markets. No completed deal has emerged, and the terms remain uncertain.... Congress ought to examine them in daylight, since Israeli patents and specialized engineering could prove far more valuable over time than the annual military aid amount being advertised as a taxpayer saving.

Washington is also weighing deeper industrial cooperation. The fiscal 2027 defense authorization bill carries a U.S.-Israel Defense Technology Cooperation Initiative that would create a standing framework for joint development and co-production, although none of it has yet to become law. The principle is sound: put both countries' inventors and manufacturers to work on tomorrow's defenses. The danger is that "partnership" could become a polite label for an arrangement in which Israel gives up proprietary technology and expertise while Washington retains the leverage to cut Israel off from deliveries of weapons and ammunition.

Above all, anti-Israel campaigners will not stop when the military aid does. Those who accuse Israel of controlling US foreign policy will simply move to the next exhibit.

The transition deserves years of planning and firm guarantees that neither partner is quietly stripping the other of indispensable capabilities, along with congressional scrutiny before a television announcement turns into a security crisis.

Trump has an opportunity to modernize an extraordinarily productive alliance, or to hand Israel's adversaries a symbolic victory while American manufacturers lose orders and both countries lose strategic flexibility. Measured against what Washington draws from Israeli technology, engineering, battlefield experience and intelligence, $4 billion a year is a modest figure, and a policy built on only eliminating that number could cost the United States far more later on.
Senate includes Israel aid in funding bills despite Trump’s call for year-end halt
The Senate Appropriations Committee released its package of fiscal year 2027 funding proposals on Monday that would provide at least $3.8 billion in military aid for Israel, weeks after U.S. President Donald Trump said that the United States would halt aid to the Jewish state by year’s end.

“Congress’s budget is entirely separate from the president’s budget request,” Phoebe Keller, communications director for the Senate panel’s Republican majority, under Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine), told JNS.

The State, Foreign Operations and Related Programs bill specifies that “not less than $3.3 million shall be available for grants only for Israel” under the U.S. State Department’s foreign military financing program.

A separate defense spending bill, the committee’s fiscal 2027 Department of Defense Appropriations Act, which was also released on Monday, would provide $500 million for joint U.S.-Israeli missile defense programs, including the Arrow 3, Iron Dome and David’s Sling systems.

Trump told Fox News in an Election Day interview on Nov. 3 that “by the end of this year, we won’t be paying Israel.” He also said that the annual aid had become an electoral burden for Republicans.

“Israel is a very thriving country,” Trump said. “They don’t need it.”

The news seemed to catch Israeli officials off guard despite Trump saying that he completed a “deal” with the Israeli government to end the aid “months ago.”
  • Tuesday, November 17, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon


A new paper in Social Sciences, “Political Attacks, Principled Defenses: UNRWA and Humanitarian Rhetoric in the Gaza War,” by Denis Kennedy, offers an interesting finding. As Israel increased pressure on UNRWA, the agency increasingly invoked neutrality and eventually adopted more explicitly political rhetoric. Kennedy interprets this evolution as “principled self-defense.” 


The title itself shows the problem. Kennedy, at the outset, considers Israel’s attacks on UNRWA to be political, and UNRWA’s defense to be principled, a word he uses over twenty times in the paper.  


Yet the paper barely considers a competing explanation: Israel's objections to UNRWA were themselves motivated by concerns that the agency violated the neutrality it claimed to uphold. Kennedy doesn’t need to agree with that explanation, but his content analysis of press releases and reports cannot settle the motives of either side, and his interpretation gives one side the benefit of the doubt.

What is actually being measured?

Kennedy examined 533 public documents issued by UNRWA, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch between January 2023 and January 2025. He shows that UNRWA's neutrality language increased sharply after allegations that its employees participated in the October 7 massacre. When Israeli legislation subsequently threatened its operations, the agency moved toward more confrontational, rights-based public advocacy.


This demonstrates how UNRWA adapted its communications under pressure. It does not show that those communications were truthful, that the response was principled, or that the criticisms were illegitimate. The basic question—whether UNRWA had earned its claims of neutrality—remains unanswered and unexamined.


The comparison with Amnesty and Human Rights Watch, to show that UNRWA was more neutral, muddies the issue. UNRWA is a UN service-delivery agency bound to humanitarian neutrality in its mandate. Amnesty and HRW are advocacy organizations that openly accuse governments of abuses. Of course UNRWA invokes neutrality more frequently than HRW and Amnesty; they don’t even pretend to be neutral. It is a fairly bizarre methodology to compare them. 

What Israel was actually alleging

Israel didn’t try to shut down UNRWA out of a desire to stop all humanitarian aid to Gaza. Its stated objection was that an organization claiming special neutrality had failed to maintain it; that it was in fact aligned with Hamas in deed if not in word. There is evidence relevant to that charge even if not every allegation has been substantiated.


The UN-commissioned Colonna review of April 2024 recognized UNRWA's extensive neutrality procedures. It also identified employees expressing political views, problematic content in some textbooks used in UNRWA schools, and politicized staff unions pressuring management. 


On August 5, 2024, the UN's Office of Internal Oversight Services reported evidence indicating that nine UNRWA employees might have participated in the October 7 attacks; their employment was terminated. Kennedy discusses the initial accusations and the resulting reputational damage without mentioning the subsequent UN investigation, even though its results fell within his study period. That omission is striking.


Israel also continued working with other humanitarian organizations. In November 2024 COGAT described daily coordination-board meetings with organizations operating in Gaza, daily discussions involving Israel, the United States, Egypt and the UN, and other aid-coordination arrangements. This challenges any assumption that Israeli opposition to UNRWA was necessarily opposition to humanitarian assistance itself. 

Who made UNRWA emphasize neutrality?

UNRWA has a long history of tolerating pro-terror and anti-Israel messaging in its schools. I started researching these in 2014, citing UNRWA websites that showed children celebrating terror attacks and UNRWA school websites that included explicit antisemitism not to mention lots of UNRWA teachers who celebrated terrorism on their social media. UN watch has since then documented a great deal more that exposes UNRWA’s lack of neutrality.


UNRWA responded to most of these accusations quietly, silently removing school websites and telling teachers to remove the problematic posts. It didn’t publicly condemn these issues, it didn’t mount a public investigation and report. But it clearly didn’t want to jeopardize its funding.This is not “principled.” This is defending its budget.


There was more pressure from the US. For years, American donor agreements have imposed requirements involving screening, audits and accountability. The 2023–2024 U.S.–UNRWA Framework for Cooperation called for quarterly neutrality assessments of agency installations. These measures did not emerge in a vacuum. Donor scrutiny and funding conditions helped produce the accountability machinery UNRWA cites in its own defense.


The types of pressure Kennedy characterizes as political attacks apparently enforced the very humanitarian and neutrality principles UNRWA professes. Arguably, the attackers were the principled ones, and UNRWA’s responses were political. Treating the agency's defensive language as evidence of principle while marginalizing the evidence behind the criticism reverses the burden of inquiry.

The assumption hidden in the conclusion

Kennedy's research question—how humanitarian institutions change their rhetoric under threat—is entirely legitimate, and his findings are potentially useful. But rhetoric is not reality.An institution accused of misconduct has a powerful incentive to advertise the virtue it is accused of lacking, just as a company accused of fraud might make honesty the centerpiece of its public relations campaign. Counting those declarations cannot determine whether the company is honest.


Kennedy documents UNRWA's language of principle. He does not establish which side was actually acting on principle.



 

Monday, November 16, 2026

From Ian:

From the Second Intifada to campus front lines: StandWithUs marks 25 years
A delegation of StandWithUs leaders and supporters from the United States and Australia met with Israeli President Isaac Herzog and first lady Michal Herzog at the President’s Residence in Jerusalem on Sunday, near the conclusion of a solidarity mission to Israel.

For participants, the visit was an opportunity to demonstrate their commitment to Israel at a time of growing international criticism of the Jewish state. For Roz Rothstein, co-founder and CEO of StandWithUs, it also reflected how far the organization has come since its founding 25 years ago.

“We were determined to show solidarity and be really great role models,” Rothstein told the gathering. “We’re elevating every part of our trip just so everybody else can say, hey, maybe it’s okay to go. So, it’s a very, very special group.”

StandWithUs was founded in 2001, during the Second Intifada, when Rothstein, the daughter of Holocaust survivors, became increasingly concerned about international media coverage of Israel and the lack of organized responses to anti-Israel misinformation.

Together with her husband, Jerry Rothstein, she began investigating whether another organization was already addressing the problem. The murders of Israeli teenagers Koby Mandell and Yosef Ishran on May 8, 2001, underscored the urgency of their mission.

“Actually, nothing was going,” she recalled, describing the lack of organizational capacity, funding and resources available at the time.

The Rothsteins were particularly troubled by international media coverage they believed distorted the reality of the conflict. Jerry Rothstein recalled seeing a Los Angeles Times description of Hamas members as “freedom fighters.”

The need to explain Israel’s geography, history and security challenges to audiences abroad became a driving force behind StandWithUs. What began as an effort to fill a gap in public advocacy has grown into an international organization with programs spanning university campuses, high schools, legal advocacy and digital communications.
Mahmoud Khalil’s False Martyrdom
In his new memoir, the activist portrays himself as a victim, but his story is rife with paranoia, conspiracy theories, and anti-Israel hatred.

That Khalil is a conspiracy theorist isn’t surprising, but the depth and quality of his conspiracy theories are. He laments that the “safety concerns” of pro-Israel students were taken seriously despite not being “by any reasonable measure of the word, actual issues of safety.” Normally, campus claims of being unsafe are overblown, but that might not be the case when a masked anti-Israel demonstrator shows up to a pro-Israel event with a sign reading “Al-Qassam’s Next Target.”

Regardless, what bothers Khalil was a perceived double standard in favor of the pro-Israel side: “To understand why Columbia behaved the way it did, we have to understand who was actually running the institution and what they were protecting.” Unsurprisingly, the culprit is Jewish money. The Columbia board of trustees “are drawn overwhelmingly from finance, real estate, corporate law, and weapons manufacturers . . . some are major donors to pro-Israel causes. Some sit on the boards of Zionist organizations.” They were “profiting from the killing of Palestinians,” he claims.

Khalil shows his depth as a conspiracy theorist in his last-ditch effort to avoid deportation. Between complaints about the slow and grinding “machinery” of the immigration courts—this is due to for-profit prisons, he concludes—he informs us that he “sought asylum” in the United States because he “faced targeting by Israel if deported.” His first example of Israel having engaged in similar perfidy before is Ghassan Kanafani, spokesman for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, who took credit for murdering 26 civilians weeks before his assassination. If Israel were still interested in assassinating spokesmen for terrorist groups, it’s not clear why it would wait until its targets were on Syrian or Algerian soil.

What Khalil imagines as a grand conspiracy is, in the end, his own actions coming back to bite him. To get this far in his con, though, he had to get extremely lucky. Any reasonable person would have expected to die invading Israel, to be expelled from Columbia for violating campus rules, or to be deported swiftly for running a terror PR campaign.

“The living martyr” has been treated with kid gloves at every step of his life, which only baffles him as he expects his enemies’ sympathy to translate into submission. His book is an attempt to curry a bit more favor and cross that threshold. He is free to keep doing so from Syria, Algeria, or the myriad lands where his ideological derangement will be more at home.
From Ian:

Bassam Tawil: Hamas's Hospitals: Interrogation, Torture, War Crimes and Terror
The documents... clearly show that the exploitation of hospitals did not begin with the Hamas-led October 7, 2023 massacre. Hamas's hospital war crimes and crimes against humanity were already an established practice years earlier.

Even more revealing is the concern expressed that such activities could provide Israel with a justification for targeting medical facilities.....

The Palestinian terrorist organizations understood the danger of turning hospitals into military installations but continued to do so anyway.

In August 2026, the IDF and Shin Bet disclosed intelligence showing that Hamas had been using Nasser Hospital as an interrogation and torture center for Palestinians suspected of opposing its rule.

The evidence demonstrates that Hamas's abuse of hospitals is not confined to its conflict with Israel. Palestinians themselves have been among its victims.

The report described Palestinians being tied in stress positions, beaten with metal pipes and subjected to severe injuries, including broken bones. Some victims were accused of ordinary offenses; others were punished for allegedly expressing support for Israel or the United States.

The IDF and Shin Bet said Hamas was using the hospital for "interrogations, torture, and collecting money." They added that patients and medical personnel had witnessed the permanent presence of Hamas operatives, some of them masked, inside the compound.

The IDF and Shin Bet said they targeted Mohammed Abu Ismail, commander of Hamas's Khan Younis Brigade, who was issuing orders from inside the hospital complex. According to the Israeli security agencies, the hospital's second floor served as a Hamas military headquarters, under strict security, where civilians were prohibited from entering.

What was a senior Hamas military commander doing inside a hospital? Why was a medical facility serving as his headquarters? Why were Israeli hostages being held there?

Even the European Union, which has frequently been reluctant to criticize Hamas, acknowledged these war crimes.

The international community cannot claim that it does not know what is happening.

The Board of Peace was established to help oversee a new reality in Gaza. It cannot accomplish that mission while Hamas retains its armed forces, security apparatus, torture centers and the ability to intimidate the population.

The international community would greatly help the Palestinians if they could stop treating Hamas's continued existence as an unavoidable political reality.

A Gaza in which Hamas retains control of weapons, military infrastructure, and internal security cannot provide genuine security or freedom for its Palestinian residents – as if it even wanted to – let alone peace with Israel.
The Shia Muslim Brotherhood: How Iran’s Islamic Revolution ignited Islamism, global jihad
The antisemitic demonstrations that swept across Europe after October 7, 2023, and the recent riots in France exposed a disturbing convergence between Islamists and the political Left.

This alliance, united by a shared hostility toward Israel and Western values, represents a growing ideological challenge to European societies.

Yet the roots of political Islam lie far beyond Europe’s streets. To understand how Islamist ideology evolved into a transnational revolutionary force, one must return to the Muslim Brotherhood, the intellectual foundations of modern Islamism, and the seismic impact of Iran’s 1979 revolution.

To diagnose the pathological DNA of the Islamic regime in Iran and the psychotic hatred of Israel, one must dissect the foundational doctrine that created it.

The 1979 Islamic Revolution in Iran was not merely a localized regime change; it marked the victory of Islamists, in alliance with the Left, over the shah’s Westernized modernism.

By demonstrating that a secular modern state could be overthrown by religious zealots, the revolution ignited an ideological wildfire across the Muslim world.

The regime in Tehran is not a conventional state. It is a transnational, revolutionary jihadist movement that occupied a state, using Iran’s geography and resources as its command headquarters.

To comprehend how this asymmetric threat reshaped Middle Eastern geopolitics and projected power globally, one must trace the structural blueprint that made it possible: the Muslim Brotherhood.

Birth of Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt
The Muslim Brotherhood, founded in Egypt in 1928 by Hassan al-Banna, pioneered modern Islamism.

Banna sought the ideological domination of Muslim societies and the global order through gradualism: the long-term penetration of educational institutions, the civil service, professional syndicates, the military, the judiciary, and civil society to capture the state.

By the 1950s, this gradualist infrastructure was radicalized into an overtly revolutionary doctrine by Sayyid Qutb. He portrayed secular states as illegitimate entities in a state of pagan ignorance (jahiliyyah) and tyranny (taghut). By rejecting human legislation as a violation of God’s sovereignty (hakimiyyah), he provided the intellectual basis for armed jihad and recast the Brotherhood as a revolutionary vanguard.

Amin al-Husseini: convergence of religious zealotry with totalitarian discipline
Haj Amin al-Husseini bridged Islamism with European totalitarianism. During World War II, he met Hitler and Himmler and collaborated with Nazi Germany against the Jews.

He helped recruit Muslim volunteers into the Waffen-SS, notably the 13th Handschar Division, establishing a template for combining religious zealotry with totalitarian discipline.

The Iranian subversion: Mosaddegh and Navvab Safavi
Although often portrayed in the West as a secular nationalist, Mohammed Mosaddegh established a precedent for using religious rhetoric to advance anti-Western geopolitical objectives.

Mosaddegh maintained communication and alignment with Islamist figures, including Husseini, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, to legitimize his anti-Western struggle within the wider Muslim world.

He framed oil nationalization by asserting that “Iran’s oil does not belong solely to Iran, but to all Islamic nations,” shifting the debate from national sovereignty to an Ummah- centered conception of strategic resources.

His administration also closed Iran’s consulate in Jerusalem, a direct operational precursor to the anti-Israel doctrine later adopted by the Islamic Republic.

The operational link to Sunni Islamism emerged through Navvab Safavi. After meeting Qutb in Egypt, Safavi built one of Iran’s first organized Muslim Brotherhood-inspired movements, Fadayan-e Islam, using violence as a primary divine tool to assassinate secular officials.
Burnham: We will work with a new government in Israel if violence ends and aid flows
Prime Minister Andy Burnham has signalled openness to working with a new government in Israel – but he set strict conditions for engagement.

Making his first major foreign policy speech, Burnham insisted that cooperation will depend on Israel “ceasing the violence, stopping settlements on Palestinian land, and allowing humanitarian aid into Gaza in the volumes that are needed.”

Speaking at the Lord Mayor’s of London’s banquet, Burnham told dignitaries, “I want the world to see Britain once again – in our traditional role as an honest broker and coalition builder.”

Burnham described Monday night’s speech as “a repositioning of British foreign policy, marking a clear break from the mistakes of the last ten years,” and praised Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband “for leading this change.”

He continued:” Shortly after I became Prime Minister, we acted to address the Israeli Government’s actions in Gaza and the West Bank and stop trade with illegal settlements.

On the threat posed by Tehran, the Prime Minister warned, “We cannot allow Iran to have a nuclear weapon, nor to massacre their own people and threaten the region unchecked.

“Nor will we allow them to sponsor attacks on journalists, our Jewish communities here in Britain, and airbases without response.”

Reflecting on the UK’s response to the October 7, 2023, Hamas attacks, Burnham said, “While Britain rightly condemned Hamas and the appalling attacks of October 7th, our response to what followed in Gaza left many questioning our moral compass.

“We created the impression that the Britain the world thought it knew had changed. It hadn’t—the people of this country are still as great and decent as they ever were.

“But the political turbulence of our times created the impression that we had changed, causing confusion. That is why now is the right time to set out our new approach.”
  • Monday, November 16, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon

This Wednesday, Montview Boulevard Presbyterian Church in Denver will host an event entitled "Faith at Times of Crises: Reflections from Palestine and the U.S." The event, co-sponsored by Bright Stars of Bethlehem, brings together five theologians, scholars and faith leaders to discuss faith, justice and the challenges facing our world.

One of the featured speakers is Rev. Dr. Mitri Raheb, a Palestinian Christian theologian, the founder and president of Dar al-Kalima University in Bethlehem and the author of dozens of books. The organizers describe him as someone whose participation is especially meaningful because of his lived experience, theological scholarship and longstanding commitment to education and cultural development.

Here is what this respected theologian wrote on October 7, 2023, while Hamas terrorists were slaughtering Israeli families, massacring young people at a music festival and kidnapping children and Holocaust survivors:

The desire for freedom is stronger than the settler colonial state. The Palestinians keep showing new forms of creative resistance & resilience. Our heart goes to our people in Gaza & especially our staff & students there. Your prayers, advocacy, & support now is much appreciated.

The burning families alive, murder, kidnapping and rapes are "creative resistance"????

Raheb has spent years promoting the concept of creative resistance as a particularly Christian approach to the Palestinian struggle. In his 2014 book, Faith in the Face of Empire: The Bible Through Palestinian Eyes, he describes how Palestinians can use painting, dance, theater and music to advance their cause. His university is dedicated in large part to encouraging this sort of creativity.

In a 2015 letter, he told young Palestinians:

The question is not if we should resist or not, but the most important question is how to resist, and how to resist creatively. We do not want you to die, but to live for Palestine.

So what exactly were the new forms of creative resistance that Mitri Raheb saw on October 7? 

Was it the use of paragliders to reach a music festival? The use of bulldozers to breach the border? The kidnapping of an entire family, including a nine-month-old baby? The livestreaming of murders to the victims' own families?

Whatever one's opinion of Israel, settlements or Palestinian nationalism, the deliberate murder of civilians is a moral abomination. One would think that a Christian theologian, of all people, would recognize the difference between producing a play and murdering dancers. Yet on October 7, Raheb applied the very same morally affirmative language he had developed to describe art and education to the events of that day.

To this theologian, Jewish suffering is so irrelevant, and Palestinian opposition to the Jewish state so inherently righteous, that even the mass murder of Jews can be incorporated into a Christian theology of liberation.

And now a church in Denver wants Americans to learn about faith and justice from this man.

This is a travesty. 

The church says "We love asking the big questions that don’t have easy answers, " OK, here's a question for you: How the hell did you think this was appropriate?

Then again, maybe the answer is that the church also says, "We believe that joy is one of the surest signs of God’s presence." The Hamas butchers certainly exhibited joy as they livestreamed murders, raped women, cut off their breasts, shot them and continued to rape their corpses. It was very creative resistance. Perhaps this is what the church meant?


(h/t Ben Weinthal)



 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

  • Sunday, November 15, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon

Last month Andrew Pessin and engaged in a conversation for the Massachusetts Antisemitism Taskforce. 

It is now available. Enjoy!





 

From Ian:

Former Israeli Hostage: "If Hamas Continues to Live in Gaza, We Will Not Live Here"
Avinatan Or, who was kidnapped on Oct. 7, 2023, and released after more than two years in Hamas captivity, told the Israel Hayom Summit on Nov. 11 about life inside a Gaza tunnel. "In darkness, the brain goes into survival mode. You can no longer see anything, and your other senses become sharper. Smells grow stronger, sounds become more distinct. When you want to survive and you have nothing, you will do anything to find something, something to hold on to, something to believe in, something that gives you hope."

"In captivity, I could see no reality other than what our captors chose to show me. They decided what I would see, what I would hear, what I would smell and what I would know. They took away my freedom in every sense except one: In the darkness of the tunnel, I refused to surrender my freedom to choose. The freedom to choose how to respond to the reality forced upon me. Every morning and every evening, even when I could no longer tell them apart, I held on to that freedom. It was my responsibility to choose how I would live my life each day."

"A few days before I was freed, Abu Hassan, one of the Hamas terrorists, entered my cell and told me, 'As long as the State of Israel exists, this war between Israel and Hamas will never end.' That conversation made it absolutely clear to me who we are facing and what Hamas is really about. They have only one goal: the destruction of the State of Israel."

"I heard their ideology, I saw their plans, I tasted their hatred. I experienced what war really is....That is precisely why this war must end with only one outcome. Our mission is to ensure that an enemy whose entire existence is devoted to spreading death cannot live alongside us. Because if they live there, we will not live here. We must complete the mission and destroy Hamas."
Antisemitism Made a Zionist of Me
Opponents of Israel have turned into a threat to the American ideal of religious pluralism and tolerance. Four Yeshiva school buses in Brooklyn were spray-painted with swastikas and the slogans "Free Palestine," "F--- Israel" and "America First" on Nov. 2. The vandals brought their quarrel with Israel to the school buses of American children simply because they were Jewish.

On Oct. 29, Mohamed Sabry Soliman pleaded guilty to hate crimes after setting Jews on fire in Colorado in June 2025. He attacked Jews who were calling for Hamas to release Israeli captives. He killed an 82-year-old woman and wounded 12 others. He announced after his arrest that he wanted "to kill all Zionist people" and "would do it again."

The incidents are piling up. I am a Zionist because on the ground, activist anti-Zionism is becoming indistinguishable from antisemitism. Cody Allen Balmer claimed anti-Zionism as his motive for setting fire to the Pennsylvania governor's mansion in 2025 when he attacked a Jewish governor and his family.

I've always generally supported Israel, beginning with the strategic reason that Israel is an ally in a region in which the U.S. has national interests. For that matter, I've supported Israel because my Christian faith seems to require it. Jews, as Pope John Paul II noted, are our elder brothers, and the safety of God's covenant people currently requires the existence of a Jewish state.

Does anyone believe that if Israel surrendered today to Hamas, Hizbullah and Iran, the Jews in a new Palestine, running from the river to the sea, wouldn't be slaughtered? Israel is an outpost of Western inheritance, facing enemies who are hostile to the West itself. First the Jews, then the Christians.

From that old support I have come to full-blown Zionism - because that is the most coherent way to oppose the activists who aim at something profoundly antithetical to the American spirit. As long as we have a social politics in which antisemitism wears the cloak of anti-Zionism, the duty of Americans is clear: When Jews are targeted as Jews, the solidarity the moment requires from the rest of us is standing up as Zionists.
How I Chose Sides on Israel
Seven months before October 7, I knew embarrassingly little about Israel. Today, I consider myself one of its most committed defenders.

After watching another American election in which our relationship with Israel became a political liability, it’s important to remind myself that my convictions aren’t determined by election returns. In fact, it’s exactly when my political positions become inconvenient that I must remember why I hold them in the first place.

In February 2023, I was invited on a ten-day trip to Israel through an organization called Passages, whose mission is to “bring a new generation of Christian leaders to Israel to deepen their faith, forge lasting bonds with the Jewish people and return home equipped to strengthen America.” To be transparent: as a Catholic convert of nine years at the time, I was focused on this trip from my own faith’s perspective. We were scheduled to arrive on October 22.

I vowed to learn as much as I could about Israel before my trip. So, I started reading. What began as trip preparation quickly became something much more meaningful. I sought out the land but found its people.

Centuries—millennia—of persecution, exile, and repeated attempts at annihilation, countered by unrelenting endurance and determination to preserve their faith, traditions, and identity, have resulted in a modern people that is the envy of the world: Israel has the highest fertility rate of any OECD country and is a global leader in technological innovation, spending more on R&D per GDP than any OECD country.

I wasn’t studying with blinders on, though. No country is perfect, and I don’t vow blanket support for Israel’s government. But I could say the same about America. Instead, I developed a genuine affection for a people and its story. While my history lesson should have tipped me off, I still couldn’t imagine so many people in my own country (and around the world) developing such a violent hatred toward them.

Then October 7 happened, and my trip was canceled. While I struggled to comprehend the brutality, I was astonished by something else: the reaction. Some Americans were already finding ways to rationalize the murder before many Israeli families had even learned the fate of their loved ones. It wasn’t just the celebration from some of the usual bad actors, but the refusal of others to condemn it that shocked me.

That response began to shape my understanding of a debate that has consumed me for the last three years. With my opinions (and dare I say, morals) intact, I began listening less to what people were saying and more to who was saying it.

I recalled a lesson from my parents: you can tell a lot about a person by the company he keeps. The people we admire, defend, and voluntarily associate with reveal a lot about our values. I began applying this simple childhood lesson to the increasingly bitter Israel debate.

No matter how fast I scrolled between internet personalities, mainstream media voices, and even elected officials, I couldn’t avoid three figures in my algorithm. And they made it easy for me to choose sides.
  • Sunday, November 15, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon
This article I wrote was originally published by Institute for the Critical Study of Antizionism.

Saturday, November 14, 2026

From Ian:

John Spencer: The Evil of NAZA
In the entire film, there is no specific strike documented in enough detail to assess the allegation of Israeli misconduct. The viewer cannot reconstruct any attack mentioned, starting from the intelligence and going through approval to its outcome. There was and is no lack of acknowledged strikes. In numerous cases, the IDF has publicly announced what or who was the target and what the precautions were. Yet, because no strike is documented in that detail, viewers are never able to apply the elements of the allegation to anything but their own imaginations.

NAZA’s filmmakers do not tell their audience that assessing expected civilian harm is a requirement of the law of armed conflict—and that formal collateral damage estimates are a regular practice of militaries across the world. This is a required step in the law of armed conflict’s core principle of proportionality. It requires those planning or deciding on an attack to assess the incidental civilian harm expected from the attack and weigh it against any concrete and direct military advantage anticipated to be gained from the attack. The nation or actor considering the strike must refrain from an attack if the expected incidental harm would be excessive in relation to that advantage. As part of the process, it must also take all feasible precautions to avoid or minimize incidental civilian harm.

The U.S. military calls the process “collateral damage estimates” (CDE) and has long used intelligence and computer tools to conduct those estimates before an attack. U.S. military doctrine, such as the instruction titled “No-Strike and the Collateral Damage Estimation Methodology,” details how analysts are to use imagery and other intelligence to identify military targets and any civilian presence and/or protected facilities. Automated tools support the assessment, while weapons testing and computer models provide estimates of potential weapon effects.

Where casualty estimates are required, analysts consider building dimensions, construction, the area exposed to those effects, and estimated civilian occupancy during the day or night. The doctrine discusses conducting targeted intelligence collection about civilian activity and that it should replace general-population estimates when available. The CDE process also considers ways to reduce harm through weapon selection, timing, and other precautions. The doctrine explicitly recognizes that these assessments contain uncertainty and cannot predict the exact outcome of an attack.

Calculating expected civilian casualties helps a military meet its legal obligations, but the calculation alone cannot establish whether it has met them. It is not by itself evidence of an intention to kill civilians. All attacks should be assessed based on examining the intelligence, anticipated military advantage, precautions, and decisions involved.

The testimony of the anonymous sources in NAZA alleges deliberate killing, but the film does not supply the records and circumstances needed to test those allegations. Nor does it document the anticipated civilian harm, military advantage, and precautions for any strikes so viewers can assess whether an attack was disproportionate. Most of all, two directors and one anonymous soldier calling the war a genocide does not make that repellent and slanderous assertion true.

The film’s use of Holocaust-remembrance footage leads it into its most insidious strategy. By framing IDF service as a modern version of Nazi complicity, NAZA perpetuates Holocaust inversion. The Nazis constructed an industrialized, systematic killing machine to exterminate millions of defenseless, unarmed civilians, many of whom were citizens of their own country, posed no military threat, had no army, and held no hostages. That comparison erases the distinction between the extermination of defenseless civilians and a war against an armed enemy operating among civilians.

NAZA is misleading even in its title. It takes a military term for collateral damage and presents the effort to estimate civilian harm as evidence of an intention to kill civilians. The film’s flashes of destruction, political speeches, and Holocaust imagery carry the audience far beyond the targeting practices it claims to investigate. It is, instead, designed to depict Israel as monstrous and Israelis as Nazi-like villains. That is why the directors are so cavalier about misleading their audience about military terminology, the law of armed conflict, common military practices, and common sense. All they really want is for people who see it to come away from their disgraceful work substituting the letter “I” from “Nazi” for the “A” in NAZA.
Will former Hague prosecutor compensate captivity survivors?
The Jerusalem District Court has ordered Karim Khan, the former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court in The Hague, to pay NIS 25 million in damages to Eitan Mor and the families of Avinatan Or and Omri Miran, who were abducted by Hamas.

Judge Eran Shilo issued the default judgment after Khan failed to file a defense, despite having been duly served with the lawsuit.

The lawsuit was filed in August 2025, while Eitan Mor, Avinatan Or and Omri Miran were still being held captive by Hamas in the Gaza Strip. All three were released about two months after it was filed.

The lawsuit centered on the allegation that Khan's conduct in his role at the court in The Hague contributed to the hostages' continued captivity. The families alleged that he refrained from taking legal action against Hamas and Islamic Jihad figures whom they held responsible for holding the hostages.

According to the lawsuit, Khan waited eight months before seeking arrest warrants for three senior Hamas leaders: Mohammed Deif, Yahya Sinwar and Ismail Haniyeh. It further alleged that he linked those applications to requests for arrest warrants against Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant.

The plaintiffs also noted that Khan refrained from seeking arrest warrants for additional senior Hamas officials and Islamic Jihad leaders, including figures who were outside the Gaza Strip and involved in conducting negotiations with Israel.

The families argued that his failure to act against those figures allowed the terrorist organizations to continue holding the hostages. The lawsuit also alleged that Khan drew an improper moral equivalence between Israel and the terrorist organizations, and that his decisions were influenced by extraneous considerations.

The damages were awarded by default due to Khan's absence, rather than following a full examination of both sides' arguments in evidentiary proceedings.
How an evolutionary biologist is taking the fight to the 'mutating virus' of anti-Zionism
Flipping the script and building the tool-kit
Rather than trying to convert every casual critic into an ardent Zionist, Expose Antizionism Now aims to equip ordinary people with the language, confidence, and conversational strategies needed to challenge anti-Zionist premises in daily life, whether at a PTA meeting, an HR office, or the dinner table.

“From the position of our organization, we do not need you to be a Zionist,” Spielman clarified. “We just need you to be against anti-Zionism. I’m not trying to convert you to Zionism; I’m trying to get you to recognize that there’s something a little bit sick about the anti-Zionist movement, and that that is a problem.

“We have been taking the bait for a long time,” Spielman continued. “Someone levels an accusation against Israel or Zionism, and because we feel passionately, we launch into a defense. That feels really good to us, but it doesn’t move the needle at all, because the person we’re talking to operates in a completely different factual and emotional universe. By accepting the premise that Israel needs to be defended, we validate the accusation.”

Spielman’s approach focuses on shifting the power dynamic of the interaction.

“Instead of launching into a defense, ask them: ‘Where did you get that idea? Do you know what anti-Zionism is? Do you know where that concept comes from?’” she suggested. “All of a sudden, they have to answer something instead of you. You aren’t going to change someone’s mind in one conversation, but you plant a seed. You make a crack in their worldview.”

To operationalize this approach, Spielman is building a comprehensive tool kit with her volunteer team, which includes their academic adviser, Prof. Andrew Pessin, founder of the Institute for the Critical Study of Antizionism. This includes downloadable community discussion kits, local training modules, and an AI-driven educational tool called Azaryah.

Azaryah allows users to chat interactively with an AI trained on the history, rhetoric, and tropes of anti-Zionism.

“It’s a partner for engaging on these issues,” Spielman explains. “You can chat with it about anti-Zionism’s history, how it functions as an ideology, and get feedback on how to have strategic conversations, set boundaries, or determine if you’re in a safe conversation. It democratizes the learning so people can engage with this information at their own schedule.”

Stripping the social permission: A strategic campaign
Operating in the Philadelphia area, a region experiencing acute political friction over anti-Israel activism, Spielman’s effort is scaling up as a grassroots start-up. Currently run by dedicated volunteers, Expose Antizionism Now is seeking seed funding and donor backing to expand its operations and deploy Azaryah at scale.

For Spielman, the battle against anti-Zionism requires walking away from superficial media outrage and focusing on long-term cultural change.

“We have to embark on that process in a very intentional, strategic way,” Spielman emphasized.

“Instead of playing Whack-A-Mole with whatever Ed Sheeran story of the week there is, we need to focus on what anti-Zionism actually gives people today. It feels good to them. It gives them a social community, a sense of righteousness, and access to elite spaces. It takes a long time for that to be beaten back, but we have to start beating it back.”

To those hesitant to confront anti-Zionist activism directly, she offers a stark historical parallel.

“A lot of the pushback that you sometimes get is, ‘Oh, well, I can’t condemn anti-Zionism because the anti-Zionists are proud of it,’” she noted. “Yeah, they are, because they think it’s a moral stance. But we have shown in the past that the Ku Klux Klan is not a moral stance. We can do this, too. We have that ability.”

Removing that social cover remains the ultimate goal.

“We need a reality where there is no more social permission, and certainly no social benefits, to being anti-Zionist,” Spielman concluded.

“Anti-Zionism’s outcomes are not freedom for Palestinians; its outcomes are the decimation of Jewish communities. It’s time we start beating it back in a deliberate, intentional, and strategic way.

AddToAny

Printfriendly

EoZTV Podcast

Podcast URL

Subscribe in podnovaSubscribe with FeedlyAdd to netvibes
addtomyyahoo4Subscribe with SubToMe

search eoz

comments

Speaking

translate

E-Book

For $18 donation








Sample Text

EoZ's Most Popular Posts in recent years

Search2

Hasbys!

Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون



This blog may be a labor of love for me, but it takes a lot of effort, time and money. For 20 years and 40,000 articles I have been providing accurate, original news that would have remained unnoticed. I've written hundreds of scoops and sometimes my reporting ends up making a real difference. I appreciate any donations you can give to keep this blog going.

Donate!

Donate to fight for Israel!

Monthly subscription:
Payment options


One time donation:

Follow EoZ on Twitter!

Interesting Blogs

Blog Archive