Commentary: The Pincer Attack Against American Jews
If the next president is Vance, these Democrats in Congress will find surprising common ground with a politician they otherwise revile. Vance appears to have been methodically establishing the arguments he will use to reverse the case he made only two years ago for Israel’s status as an American ally. In May 2024, two months before he was announced as Trump’s running mate, Vance gave a major foreign policy address to the isolationist Quincy Institute. There, before an audience of Israel skeptics, Vance explained why he supported Israel but not Ukraine.Jake Wallis Simons: Ed Miliband’s diplomacy is narcissism mixed with progressive ideology
“I certainly admire the Ukrainians who are fighting against Russia, but I do not think that it is in America’s interest to continue to fund an effectively never-ending war in Ukraine,” Vance said. In contrast, allying closely with Israel can “actually give us missile-defense parity. That’s a very important national security objective of the United States of America, and that’s something we’re working with one of the most innovative economies in the world to accomplish.”
The basic question, Vance said, is this: “Do we want clients who depend on us, who can’t do anything without us? Or do we want real allies who can actually advance their interests on their own with America playing a leadership role?”
Vance’s post-midterms statement was a point-by-point refutation of this case for Israel. The war with Iran has apparently demonstrated, to Vance, that Israel can’t and won’t always fight alone. This drains American resources and flies in the face of an “America First” strategy. Therefore, we must “change our relationship to Israel.”
Yet this raises a question: Throughout his career, Vance has been willing to adapt his principles to match whatever has popular support on the right. Polls show a majority of Republican voters still believe that Trump’s level of support for Israel is right where it should be. Why would Vance stake out a position on the other side?
The answer is that Vance chooses policy stances not by their popularity but by their usefulness to his own career advancement. The two are not always the same. Vance envisions a race for the 2028 Republican presidential nomination in which supporters of the U.S.-Israel alliance will already be backing a different candidate. His ambition therefore would naturally lead him to jettison his grudging, utilitarian support for our alliance with Israel. To win the nomination, however, he’ll have to convince enough Republicans to follow suit.
How might he seek to do this? Not only by blaming Israel for decisions his administration made, but by taking a page out of anti-Israel Democrats’ playbook and exacerbating the existing divides within American Jewry.
Vance’s wing of conservatism is populated by NatCons—the National Conservatives. As Naya Lekht writes elsewhere in this issue, the NatCons advocate a form of blood-and-soil nationalism for the American right. They recently held a conference in Jerusalem where several speakers exhorted Israelis to tell U.S. Jews to stop complaining about anti-Semitism. The message: American Jews are ruining it for Israel. This is a right-wing version of the Democrats’ ongoing campaign to convince American Jews that Israelis are to blame for all their woes.
Thus are American Jews presented with the following demand: They need to renounce the parts of Judaism that extremist political demagogues find distasteful and disassociate themselves from the Jews who won’t follow suit.
“Judaism and the Jewish people are not the same as Israel and AIPAC. They’re not the same,” El-Sayed said in August. He’d said the same thing three weeks earlier on Meet the Press: “I love and revere Judaism and the Jewish people…. But they are not the same as AIPAC and Israel.”
AIPAC, of course, isn’t Israel. It is an organization of Americans who support the U.S.-Israel alliance. El-Sayed’s comments are a reminder that Israel’s enemies see American Jews as a direct threat to their agenda. It’s a sentiment shared by numerous progressives, who will now have the wind at their backs—and an unlikely cheerleader in JD Vance who hopes to replicate their success.
This is more than a horseshoe. It’s a pincer attack, and attacks must be foiled or the attackers will simply continue to advance. Many American Jews—the majority in Michigan who voted for el-Sayed, for example—have decided they are not going to fight, or are going to accept some illusory deal whereby they will be left alone if they go along to get along. The Jews throughout history who try to buy off those with deadly intent against them either end up no longer being Jews or learning too late the cost of their appeasement.
The rest of us, unable to retreat into illusion, are going to have to fight the pincer attack for them—not because these contemptible Jews deserve to be fought for, but because it is the battle for our children and grandchildren, who do.
In his own mind, Ed Miliband must have been a crusader in shining armour, Palestinian colours fluttering from his lance. “Do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution,” the Foreign Secretary thundered as he slammed his visor on Tuesday and announced fresh sanctions on Israel.NGO Monitor: UK puts its reputation above Israel’s security concerns
After all, this is the man who, back in 2015, left his aides-mémoires lying around in a dressing room until the tabloids found them. “Happy warrior”, he had reminded himself in the notes. “Relish the chance to show who I am.” More than a decade later, the country knows who Miliband is, and knows it good and proper.
Narcissism and ideology do not effective foreign policy make. The new sanctions were slapped upon eight developers involved in construction on the West Bank. The measures were timed to pre-empt the deadline for tenders to build on the E1 area, a 4.6-square-mile section of land hyperbolically described as key to a future Palestinian state.
There is just one problem: nobody is building anything. Israel’s Attorney-General, Gali Baharav-Miara, has frozen the E1 tender process until coalition negotiations have confirmed a new government. Oops! What a bungle. The Foreign Office jumped the gun, sanctioning companies over a process that has been paused and may now never happen at all.
Why didn’t Miliband wait until Israel’s position was clear? Clearly, pulling the trigger was more important than hitting the target. In normal times, Britain’s foreign policy would be based firstly upon making our country more prosperous and secure, and secondly upon fostering stability overseas in a style that is conducive to our interests. But these are not normal times. These are times of performance.
When it comes to the Middle East, neither Miliband nor his Foreign Office apparatchiks appear to care for the facts. If they did, they would surely form policy on the understanding that the Palestinian leadership has repeatedly rejected offers of sovereignty over the years, while whining about it at the same time.
Let’s see. There was 1937, 1947, 2000, oh, and 2008, when Ehud Olmert offered Mahmoud Abbas 94 per cent of the West Bank with extra land to reach 100 per cent, East Jerusalem as a Palestinian capital, and the Old City turned over to international control. Who in their right mind would shun an offer like that? Answer: Mahmoud Abbas, that’s who.
It could not be more obvious. The Palestinian leadership does not want a country alongside Israel, but one in place of it. That is the true obstacle to the two-state solution. Does nobody see through the grift? How have we convinced ourselves that supporting authoritarianism, corruption, mendacity and jihad is virtuous? We are making abject fools of ourselves, with Miliband leading the charge.
In response to the United Kingdom’s statement on Tuesday urging Israel to “allow immediate, rapid and unimpeded humanitarian access throughout Gaza,” NGO Monitor noted that the British government has a history of moral posturing while ignoring the risks to Israel of providing terror groups a way to resupply.
The Jerusalem-based watchdog group posted to X on Tuesday a document it first publicized in May 2025 from the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO), dated November 2022, showing that British officials were aware of Hamas involvement in Gaza cash-assistance programs, but chose to provide funds to the programs anyway, despite the significant risk the money would be diverted to the terror group.
The FCDO document explains that “the cash assistance component will be implemented in coordination with the Gaza Ministry of Social Development MoSD.” MoSD is Hamas-run, something the document acknowledged.
“The MoSD in Gaza is affiliated with the de facto authorities and thus UK Aid can be linked directly or indirectly with supporting the de factor [sic] authority (Hamas) in Gaza which is part of a proscribed group,” it stated.
Under a column titled “risk category,” the document rated the risk “reputational. Risk appetite: receptive.” In others, the FCDO recommended going ahead with the assistance.
“Time and again, the United Kingdom dismisses real security risks, choosing instead to advance an activist foreign policy. NGO Monitor found that British diplomats opted to ignore concerns that Hamas was likely dictating the disbursement of U.K. taxpayer funds, while also reassuring the terrorist organization that U.K. proscription would not change U.K. funding practices,” Anne Herzberg, NGO Monitor’s legal adviser, told JNS.
“The British Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office stated it was more concerned with its ‘reputational risk’ than that of Hamas aid diversion. Despite the Oct. 7 atrocities and the ensuing war, the U.K. government has decided to double down on its reckless and failed policies,” she said, referring to the Hamas-led invasion of southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.











