Sunday, November 22, 2026

  • Sunday, November 22, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon





I was researching records from my relatives who survived the Holocaust and saw these pages from a UN refugee agency (PCIRO) that they filled out in a German displaced persons camp.

The form asks:

(a) Do you wish to return to your country of former residence?
If not, why?

(b) Do you wish to remain in Germany?
Have you any relatives, friends or resources in Germany?

(c) Do you wish to emigrate to some other country? If so, complete the following:
Country of first preference.

In these cases, the answers were that they emphatically did not want to go back to their birth country, they didn't want to stay in Germany and they wanted to go to Israel (or Palestine for before 1948.)  

Today's antisemites and antizionists (but I repeat myself) like to characterize Jews who went to Israel as colonialists, or settler colonialists, who wanted to leave their own land and take over someone else's.

No. 

For a great number, they had nowhere else to go. 

These are the real people who had to make real decisions about their future and the future of their families. Going back to the countries that slaughtered them was unthinkable. 

Today's Jew-haters don't want you to think about this. They want to position these Jews who literally lost everything as the oppressors, never the victims. 

This is only one tiny example of how today's antisemites try to whitewash history to demonize Jews. 




 

Saturday, November 21, 2026

From Ian:

Thanksgiving With a Heaping Side of Zionism
Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and like a horde of locusts, a host of tendentious think pieces about how to argue with loved ones about politics will descend. But much like the wedding in Monty Python and the Holy Grail, this family-themed holiday is supposed to be a happy occasion. So instead of bickering and arguing about who killed who, try spending Thanksgiving remembering and celebrating one of the greatest American traditions: Zionism.

Americans have held this holiday in special regard for decades. George Washington and Abraham Lincoln each have a claim for instituting it nationally, but Thanksgiving is significantly older than the United States. Most famously, the Pilgrims thanked the Almighty in 1621 for their first successful harvest. Some Virginians grumble that, since their colonists had a similar service nearly two years earlier, Old Dominion should have pride of place in the Thanksgiving story.

Many Americans are familiar with the origin story of the early Puritans, who reached Plymouth just before the dead of winter and barely made it to the spring. They may also know that the first settlers in Massachusetts had become convinced that there was no place for their religious views in England and so they sought out a new land where they could live and worship as they saw fit. But few know that, thanks to the early Puritans, Zionism is as American as pumpkin pie.

The early Reformation was not very good for Jews. Martin Luther initially criticized the antisemitism that was all too common among Christians at the time, but he became a ferocious critic of the Jewish people once it became clear they would not convert en masse to his church.

The Anglo-American branch of the Reformation grew in a healthier direction. As they read their Bibles, many English reformers became convinced that many of the Old Testament covenants still applied to the descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. They too hoped for large-scale conversions, but they believed Jews still had a special place in the divine plan.

Some took this analysis a step further and concluded that part of God's plan for the children of Israel was to restore their homeland in Israel. Increase Mather stated in 1666 from the pulpit to the largest and oldest congregation in Massachusetts that the Jews would "recover the Possession of their Promised Land." Jonathan Edwards, one of the most significant figures in pre-revolutionary America, wrote, "and it is the more evident, that the Jews will return to their own land again."

Support for Jewish statehood has been a fixture in American public life ever since. John Adams wrote that he wished to see a Jewish acquaintance at the head of an army of coreligionists on their way to the Holy Land. Five years before Theodor Herzl wrote The Jewish State, many of the most prominent Americans signed the Blackstone Memorial asking President Benjamin Harrison to diplomatically assist plans for Jewish statehood. The Lodge-Fish resolution endorsing the Balfour Declaration sailed through Congress. Zionism was one of the few subjects on which liberal icon Eleanor Roosevelt and "Mr. Republican" Robert Taft agreed.

The sources of American Zionism are as diverse as the country itself. For some, their reading of Scripture prodded them to champion Jewish statehood. Others were deeply grateful for the blessings of liberty they enjoyed and wanted to see other peoples taste similar fruits under their own flags. And still more were revolted by the persecutions Jews suffered, even before the Holocaust, and wanted to right this great historical wrong.
The brave Arab Zionist sticking his neck out for Israel
Nael Zoabi didn’t set out looking for fame. Or to be an activist. He certainly never expected to be the face of Arab Israelis standing up for their country on television channels around the world.

But it’s the passion of this former school headmaster and proud Zionist and it’s propelled him to become one of the loudest and most courageous voices speaking up for Israel, with more than 800 interviews completed since October 7.

Nael, a father of four whose children did community service in Israel, identifies as an Israeli Arab Muslim – in that order. On one of his most recent posts, on October 7, after appearing on yet another Arab channel, he wrote: “October 7 has become a part of me – from my flesh, my soul and who I am. From that morning, I am no longer the same person. Since then, I fight in my own way; telling the world about Hamas’s atrocities and giving voice to the victims.

“As an Israeli, as an Arab and as a Muslim, this is my home. This is my pain and this is my mission.”

He is a rare voice for the two million Arabs who live in Israel, the only Arabs to live in a democracy in the Middle East. With the two main blocs in the Knesset almost tied for votes, Arab Israelis now find themselves in a key position, and it is one Nael wants them to take advantage of – for the country they share with the Jews.

I want to see Arab Knesset members building bridges with the Jewish majority, rather than widening the distance between citizens

“I want to see Arab society truly integrate into Israeli governments, state institutions and decision-making hubs,” he says. “I want to see Arab Knesset members building bridges with the Jewish majority, rather than widening the distance between citizens.”

He worries that in the past some Arab politicians, including former Joint List leader Ayman Odeh, have actually made things worse for Arabs in Israel. “When Odeh used the phrase ‘Gaza won and Gaza will win’, it created severe public controversy. I ask our leaders to consider the impact of their words on trust between Jews and Arabs. They don’t have to give up their identity or their right to criticise the government, but I want to know how they have turned citizenship into partnership, which can influence and create a real improvement for people’s lives.”

Nael has always been a proud Israeli. The Israeli flag flew from the Muslim school, Tamra Ba’Emek, he ran near Nazareth. And when he left, he decided to get political. He began writing as a columnist for Israeli newspapers to encourage more of his fellow Arabs to take an active part in Israeli society.

He also began working with the Israeli Ministry of Education, pushing for greater understanding of the Arab sector. And he started speaking as a commentator on Arab television stations from Dubai to Iraq.

“Some of the Arab politicians act like they don’t want to live here but I wanted to say, ‘I am a proud Arab citizen of Israel.’ I don’t have another country. I don’t have another flag.
Eisenkot’s party to start ‘marathon talks’ with Likud over national unity government
Yashar leader Gadi Eisenkot instructed his party’s negotiating team to invite Likud representatives on Sunday for “marathon talks,” in a bid to reach an agreement over a national unity government, Eisenkot’s faction announced on Saturday night.

Yashar described the decision as a “genuine and sincere effort to form the broadest possible government,” saying it is willing to “turn over every stone” and “enable bold moves.”

Shortly after Yashar’s statement, former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett, leader of the B’Yachad party, pledged in a post on Facebook that he is committed to ensuring that incumbent Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “is not the next prime minister of Israel, and that my party will not join him or his bloc under any circumstances.”

Bennett said that he remains committed to forming, “together with our partners, a government of reform led by Gadi Eisenkot.”

He then mentioned lawmakers Elisha Medan of Likud, who lost his legs in an explosion while fighting in Gaza in 2023, and Yonatan Shalev of B’Yachad, who founded “Shoulder to Shoulder,” an organization representing IDF reservists who advocate for an end to exemptions from military service.

Bennett stressed that if these two men can fight side by side in Gaza, “surely they can sit side by side in the government.”

He continued, “We must turn over every stone to form a Zionist unity government led by Eisenkot. I am not naive. The suspicion of Netanyahu is justified. For years, Netanyahu has deceived his partners and acted against them. That is why, in this case, Eisenkot would be at the helm.”

The former prime minister then laid out three principles for the government he is willing to join: establishing a state commission of inquiry into the Oct. 7, 2023, massacres, limiting prime ministers’ terms to eight years and enacting a “revolution of those who serve,” referring to equalizing the burden of military conscription.

Earlier on Saturday, Yisrael Beiteinu chairman Avigdor Liberman vowed once again not to join a coalition backed by Arab parties’ MKs, calling on his political partners to build a stable coalition with the ultra-Orthodox parties.

Those who truly want to put an end to Netanyahu’s rule in politics must understand that “the only way to do so is by breaking up his bloc,” Liberman tweeted in Hebrew.

“Netanyahu can only be replaced from the right, not from the left. Therefore, the only way to break up Netanyahu’s bloc is to form a coalition with Shas and United Torah Judaism,” Liberman argued.

He said that such a coalition would come with a political price, and he would be the first to pay it, having pledged in his political campaign to enlist Haredi men into the Israel Defense Forces, ending their decades-long draft exemption.

Liberman’s and Bennett’s conditions for joining the next government seem to be at odds, which places significant obstacles to Eisenkot’s effort to build a coalition. His 28-day period for forging the next government ends on Dec. 6. Israeli President Isaac Herzog can then extend his effort by another 14 days.

Friday, November 20, 2026

From Ian:

JPost Editorial: Genocide must be proven, not proclaimed, the ICJ ruling on Myanmar shows
Thursday’s judgment underscores why evidence of genocidal intent is indispensable. The court’s finding against Myanmar rested on its assessment of the conduct and circumstances of the campaign, not the number of people killed alone.

Israel, however, should not interpret the judgment as a straightforward vindication of its position.

Myanmar genocide ruling may complicate Israel's defense against South Africa
As The Jerusalem Post’s Yonah Jeremy Bob reported on Thursday, aspects of the decision could complicate Israel’s defense. The court took a broad view of evidence relevant to genocidal acts and intent, while maintaining that negligence, even gross negligence, does not itself establish genocide.

Israel’s legal team must therefore study the judgment carefully, particularly its treatment of political statements and the circumstances surrounding civilian suffering.

The ICJ has not cleared Israel of South Africa’s allegations. That case remains pending, and the court has not issued a final judgment on whether Israel violated the Genocide Convention. The provisional measures ordered earlier in those proceedings did not amount to a judicial finding that genocide had occurred.

Nevertheless, Thursday’s ruling should restore precision to a debate in which accusations of genocide are frequently treated as established conclusions before judicial proceedings have concluded.

South Africa is entitled to bring its case, and Israel is entitled to contest it. The court must assess both sides according to the evidence and the law, without allowing the conflict’s political intensity to substitute for either.

Calling every devastating military campaign genocide obscures the distinctions between atrocities. Equally, invoking legitimate military objectives cannot automatically negate evidence of genocidal intent where such evidence exists.

Court must seriously examine, investigate, and insist on standards for Israel case
The Rohingya deserve recognition of what was done to them, justice for those responsible, and an opportunity to rebuild their lives. Their suffering should not be reduced to a rhetorical instrument in arguments about another conflict.

Their case nevertheless demonstrates the seriousness with which accusations of genocide must be examined. South Africa has asked the ICJ to determine whether Israel committed that crime. Thursday’s ruling shows that the court can reach such a conclusion when it finds the legal requirements satisfied.

The response should be neither to prejudge Israel’s guilt nor to pretend its innocence has already been judicially established. It should be to insist upon the same rigorous standard of evidence, including proof of intent, for every state that stands accused.

The lesson for South Africa, Israel, and the international community is that genocide must be proven, not proclaimed.
Seth Mandel: The Holocaust’s Lessons Aren’t For Everyone
The constant search for applicable “lessons” from the rise and rule of the Nazis is understandable but misdirected. Victims, not perpetrators and bystanders, ought to be the primary students of the modern world’s singular genocide.

As Clark’s review of Hoyer shows, the central question is how the emerging threats to the targeted community—in this case, as in many cases, Jews—are interpreted without the benefit of hindsight:

“The Nazis lacked a majority but had the leverage to secure the ministries of the interior and education for Wilhelm Frick. Frick made uninhibited use of his powers, sacking left-leaning and Jewish civil servants and replacing them with people loyal to the Nazis… Frick would eventually fall from power, once the parties of the centre recovered their will to act and joined forces against him. But the damage was done: there was no purge of the new appointees, and this brief experiment in Nazi governance revealed how weak the resistance to a more concerted assault on liberal-democratic norms was likely to be.”

Modern audiences tend to respond with something vague that they don’t actually mean about preserving liberal-democratic norms. But when they see a Hitler coming, they will be the first to argue that norms must be suspended in order to prevent the New Hitler from gaining power. The lesson for the Jews then and ever is: No one is coming to save you. So you must save yourself.

To read about the gathering storm clouds of anti-Jewish governance is to understand first and foremost that the Zionists were right and everyone else was wrong. It is to see clearly that the Palestinian Arab sin of preventing Jewish immigration to Jewish communities in the Jewish homeland must be reckoned with and atoned for the same way Vichy France had to be reckoned with and atoned for.

It is to comprehend the power and the glory of sovereignty and agency and self-determination.

And perhaps most of all, it is to know the importance of making everyone else’s “universal” lessons irrelevant.

When you rely on other people learning lessons, you make yourself vulnerable to self-interested partisanship. We just went through a series of elections in which people who rightly sounded the alarm about Trump’s enabling of anti-Semitic forces in 2016 enthusiastically supported Abdul El-Sayed, Zohran Mamdani, Adam Hamawy and Graham Platner. If your lesson from Nazi Germany is to back the guy with the Totenkopf who rants about Jews, I would like you to stop learning lessons altogether and also stay as far away from electoral politics as possible.

What matters most is what the Jews learned from the Holocaust. For that, all we need are the facts. And that is all historians should deliver.
Seth Madnel: Get Your Own
Set aside the discredited “genocide” libel for a moment, which tinpot authoritarian demagogues use solely as a destabilizing provocation. His answer is: He won’t condemn a standalone massacre of innocent Jews because, three weeks later, Israel initiated a ground incursion into Gaza to get back its citizens that Palestinians took hostage.

Why won’t Mamdani let Jews mourn? Because he doesn’t believe they deserve to.

What’s happening here isn’t just rank anti-Semitism—that part’s undeniable. It’s that there’s an extra layer of creepiness to Mamdani’s statement: It’s stalkerish behavior, and it is characteristic of the wider Western “pro-Palestinian” movement.

Anti-Zionists like Mamdani want October 7 for themselves because the Jews have it. It’s the same reason there’s an imperialist dome along with a mosque built atop the Jews’ holy site in Jerusalem. It’s the same reason Palestinians and their advocates believe that only permitting Jews in 3 percent of Hebron—the four thousand year old Jewish city—is unfair to the Palestinians. And it’s the reason that Nakba Day was created the day after Israeli Independence Day. There is no real significance to the date aside from the naked appropriation of a day that was already meaningful to Jews.

That is also what the genocide libel is about. The comparisons of Israel’s military operations in Gaza to the Holocaust are a manifestation of trauma envy. It’s why the Chicago Tribune can print the following sentence last week about the newly renovated Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center: “The renovation did not add permanent museum content about the Hamas-led attack on Oct. 7, 2023, the largest mass killing of Jews since the Holocaust, or Israel’s resulting assault and siege on Gaza, which has been widely considered a genocide.”

Got it? The Holocaust museum did not add an exhibit on Gaza. The Holocaust museum remains a museum about the Holocaust.

Just as Israel remains the Jewish state, despite the desire of so many to confiscate the historic Jewish homeland for other purposes.
From Ian:

Anti-Zionism’s next frontier is Western military action against Israel
Over the past few months, we may have caught a glimpse of where the anti-Zionists' insatiable hatred of Israel may be heading.

In September, British Labour MP Tahir Ali, an anti-war politician who called the US-Israel war against Iran "illegal," called for British “military action” against Israel during a House of Commons debate on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, while also arguing that Israel should be required to disarm. He only apologized for his remarks due to pressure from leaders in his party.

Earlier this month, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, a French presidential candidate and leader of the "anti-imperialist" party France Unbowed, which rejects Western military intervention around the world, pledged during a campaign rally to take direct military action regarding Israel if elected, including deploying French Navy ships challenging Israel's blockade of Gaza.

And, only a week ago, the anti-Zionist writer Benjamin Moser, whose book on the history of anti-Zionism received rave reviews at The Guardian, declared – during a podcast interview – that Israel will and should be destroyed "militarily and economically."

While such pronouncements, particularly by Mélenchon and Ali, can be viewed as an obscene kind of "virtue signaling," rather than a serious call for military action against Israel, it is nonetheless disturbing that the idea of invading Israel – a nation they and their ideological fellow travelers already view as lacking moral legitimacy, and which has forfeited its right to exist – has become a populist talking point for segments of the putatively pacifist Left.

How cognitive dissonance fueled anti-Israel radicalization
So, how did we get to this point? Perhaps the best answer comes from Israeli writer Shany Mor, who, in late Oct. 2023, commenting on how many in the West had already turned against Israel, wrote that “many would think that an atrocity like the Hamas-led October 7 massacre in Israel would lead opponents of the Jewish state to temper their attacks.”

Instead, he correctly observed, “from college campuses to mainstream media outlets, elite left-wing circles responded to the terror group’s barbarism by intensifying their denunciations of Israel.”

Mor argued that this behavior is “an example of cognitive-dissonance reduction, the process by which people reconcile new information that contradicts their firmly held priors.”

“Western activists for Palestinians,” he added, “are dedicated to two nearly theological precepts: that Israel is evil, and that no Palestinian action is ever connected to any Palestinian outcome.”

Hamas’s antisemitic savagery, he concluded, “posed a threat to this worldview, and the only way to resolve it was by heightening Israel’s imagined malevolence. The terrorist atrocities didn’t trigger a recoiling from the cause in whose name they were carried out; they led to an even greater revulsion at the victim.”

Anti-Zionists, three years after they decided to double down on their hatred of Israel, have no other path to take than continuing to find more and more incendiary and vilifying rhetoric targeting both Israel and, by extension, if not by design, its millions of Diaspora Jewish supporters around the world.

Calling on Western armies to confront Israel militarily is merely the latest manifestation of a movement consumed by a pathological hatred that requires the total dehumanization of its target to justify its own extremism.
Melanie Phillips: Miliband’s murderous solution
Their core belief is the fantasy of creating the brotherhood of man, in which there are no nations and no religions to divide us and—in the words of John Lennon’s song “Imagine”—nothing to fight or die for.

Every conflict can be solved by negotiation and compromise. In their culture of moral relativism in which there’s no objective good or bad, right or wrong, the only thing that matters is the consequences. Wars must be avoided, as that means dead people. So Israel must negotiate a solution with the Palestinians.

The fact that Palestinian Arab identity is itself constructed around the extinction of the Jewish presence in the land of Israel is simply blanked out. It can’t be allowed to get in the way of the unshakeable liberal belief that everyone in the world only wants a nice job, a nice family and a nice life.

Believing in nothing very much themselves, trapped in their bubble of narcissistic hedonism, such liberals cannot begin to grasp the strength of fanatical Islamic religious belief that seeks the annihilation of Israel and the death of Jews. They say that war solves nothing (World War II, anyone?) and the only solution is through negotiated settlement.

That’s why Miliband is obsessed with the two-state solution, which he described as “the ‘North Star’ of this government’s approach” to Israel and Palestinian Arabs.

The fact that a state of their own has already been offered and rejected by the Palestinian Arabs five times—and that a Palestinian state would put all of central Israel within firing range from the strategic hilltops of Judea and Samaria—means nothing to him at all.

What he so signally fails to grasp is that the unending Middle East impasse that obsesses him beyond all else was actually created by his own country through precisely the strategy he is now demanding Israel accepts.

For Britain pioneered the “two-state solution” twice. First, when Winston Churchill hived off three-quarters of Palestine, which had all been designated for the Jewish homeland, to carve out Jordan for the Hashemite Arabs. And second, when it tried unsuccessfully to palm off to the Arabs much of what was left of Mandate Palestine to stop them from murdering even more Brits and Jews.

This reward to the Palestinian Arabs for genocidal terror, which has remained the strategy of Britain and the West ever since, has incentivized them to continue to try to wipe Israel out in the certainty that Britain and the West will punish the Jews ever more severely for resisting.

Britain is therefore the original creator of this terrible conflict, and has much Israeli and Arab blood on its hands as a result. Burnham and Miliband are merely continuing to perpetuate a truly infernal legacy.
The Muslim Brotherhood as a Terrorist Organization: What Egypt's Court Ruling Reveals About Europe
The following day, the Second Criminal Chamber of Badr placed 35 organizations and 36 individuals on the terrorist list...

Among those named are the powerful Council of European Muslims, successor to the Federation of Islamic Organizations in Europe (FIOE); Musulmans de France; the League of Muslims of Belgium; and national organizations operating in Britain, Germany, and other European countries. The ruling also names the European Council for Fatwa and Research, the European Council of Imams and the European Institute of Human Sciences.

[T]he Egyptian judiciary is not merely targeting political leaders and isolated local initiatives. What emerges is a distinctly European Islamist and terrorist network, driven by a single, coherent ideological project: that of the Muslim Brotherhood in Europe.

Political action does not necessarily begin at the ballot box. It begins much earlier, with the dissemination of religious doctrines and the patient construction of lasting institutions. The method is similar to that of the Italian communist Antonio Gramsci: conquer society from below, and political power will eventually fall into your hands.

Every link in the network shares one overriding point of reference: Sharia, "the divine guidance revealed in the Qur'an and the Sunnah, covering both worship and everyday dealings."

Taken together, these provisions form a coherent logic: to undermine democracy. Islamic Sharia law is placed above all other laws -- first for Muslims, then for everyone else.

Sharia offers no dialogue. It blocks all dissenting voices — Jewish, Christian, atheist — especially when Islamists consider themselves sufficiently numerous to impose their will.

The late, influential Sunni spiritual leader, Yusuf al-Qaradawi, forced to flee from Egypt to Qatar, admitted on his popular Al Jazeera television show, "Sharia and Life," that "If they had gotten rid of the apostasy punishment Islam wouldn't exist today."

Does anyone grasp the magnitude of the humiliation involved in leaving it to Egypt to expose the Muslim Brotherhood's sprawling network across Europe?
  • Friday, November 20, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon

At first I thought the Myanmar ICJ ruling helped Israel because the International Court of Justice kept the “only reasonable inference” standard. When a court infers genocidal intent from conduct, it must find that an intent to destroy the group, in whole or in substantial part, is the only reasonable inference. I said then that the devil was in the details and that I would need to see the actual ruling. 

I’m glad I added that. Because the ruling really did expand the criteria for finding genocide in ways that can falsely find Israel guilty.

Brian L. Cox examined the ruling and identified three problems that compound each other. Taken together, they could allow the Court to find that Israel committed genocide even if genocide is neither the only reasonable inference nor, on a fair reading of the evidence, the most reasonable one. This flips what the court has traditionally done in genocide cases, even as it tries to make it appear that it has kept the same standards. It hasn't.

1. What happens to evidence that points the other way?

The Court says in paragraph 443 that other intentions can coexist with genocidal intent, so long as “the totality of the evidence can only be explained by the perpetrator’s genocidal intent.

Now we are moving from hard evidence for genocide, the court's previous standard, into interpretation of evidence.  When parts of the evidence contradict the genocide finding, they can be discarded in the face of "totality." This is a judgment call and judgments can be twisted. This is why the previous genocide cases set the standard incredibly high.

I have no problem with the idea that an army might have had a different goal in mind for a specific action. Some evidence is consistent with several intentions. But some evidence actually weighs against genocidal intent. That distinction can disappear when judges invoke the “totality of the evidence.” They can acknowledge a fact that cuts against genocide, imagine a reason why a government bent on genocide might have acted the same way, and then give the fact little weight. The evidence is still in the judgment. It just no longer counts against the conclusion. If the judges demand proof for a competing explanation, they should also demand proof for the explanation they use to discount contrary evidence. Otherwise, the “only reasonable inference” can become the only inference the judges allowed the evidence to support.

So Israel allowed polio vaccines into Gaza. That shows that they care about saving innocent Gaza lives. But if the "genocide" evidence the court considers is weighed much heavier than the contradictory evidence, then the "totality" can minimize the counter-evidence while pretending it is part of the totality.

2. Who decides what goes into the “totality of the evidence”?

Before the judges can decide what the evidence means, they have to decide what happened. Much of the material they may be asked to consider comes from outside bodies such as the UN Commission of Inquiry or Amnesty International. These organizations can and are biased about which evidence they credit and which explanations they consider. The Court says it will assess the factual findings in such reports for itself and give the reports’ legal conclusions no evidentiary weight. That sounds reassuring until you see how much interpretation can go into what gets presented as a fact. Myanmar judgment, ¶¶97–100

Cox gives the example of a baby shot inside a tent in Gaza. The commission examined images of the bullet and concluded, on its “reasonable grounds” standard, that it came from a sniper rifle mounted on an Israeli quadcopter. It then reasoned that because the shooting took place in daylight, the operator could see inside the tent and had targeted the mother and baby. There are a lot of evidentiary gaps here that the UN commission glossed over. How did the images of the bullet  identifyit was a quadcopter that fired the bullet and not a stray Hamas bullet? What established who fired it? What could the operator actually see inside that particular tent? What did the operator believe was there? Each step needs evidence of its own. The report said "Considering that the shooting occurred in broad daylight, the Commission concludes that the quadcopter controller would have been able to see inside the tent and assesses that the target was a mother and a baby." If the tent was closed, how does daylight help see inside the tent? Yet if the Court accepts “Israel deliberately targeted a mother and baby” as a finding of fact based on the UN COI being an independent investigator, several disputed inferences have already entered the record before the judges even consider genocidal intent. The judges are not competent to ask the questions I just asked; they are accepting the UN as a source of evidence even when the UN pretends that a picture of a bullet can determine its source, what was visible and the intent of the shooter. 

This is where the Myanmar ruling makes the problem worse. In paragraph 131, the Court allowed itself more latitude to infer facts about events largely or wholly within Myanmar’s exclusive knowledge for which Myanmar had given no satisfactory explanation. There is a sensible reason for this rule. A government may be the only party with the relevant military records. Israel’s refusal to cooperate with the commission does not automatically meet those conditions. But the danger is clear. If judges accept a commission’s conclusion on thin circumstantial evidence while demanding detailed military records before they will credit Israel’s explanation, the evidence for genocide can become easier to believe than the evidence against it. Multiply that by dozens of incidents and the Court may have a seemingly overwhelming body of evidence whose weakest links were never seriously tested. 

3. How much does following the laws of war count?

Cox’s third point concerns the laws of armed conflict. The Court does say that compliance can be evidence about intent. It also says compliance does not put conduct beyond the reach of the Genocide Convention. The question is how much weight compliance gets when the Court decides what a military was trying to achieve. An army that repeatedly cancels or changes attacks to spare civilians, at a real military cost, is giving us evidence about its intent. A targeting manual can tell you what an army says it does. The record of canceled strikes can tell you what it was willing to give up to protect civilians. 

Consider the Gaza aid cutoff. The Court could count the cutoff as evidence that Israel intended to starve Gazans as a means of destroying part of the population. Then, when Israel resumed limited aid in May 2025, the Court could say it did so only because of American pressure. There was American pressure, and Netanyahu publicly acknowledged it. But that helps explain when Israel changed course. It doesn't explain  what Israel wanted the cutoff to accomplish. A government trying to pressure Hamas could also change course when the humanitarian and diplomatic costs grew. Israel had calculated the amount of aid that came into Gaza during the previous ceasefire and calculated how long it would last. 

If cutting off aid is evidence of genocide and resuming aid gets explained away by assuming Israel still wanted genocide, either decision can be made to fit the accusation. That is where the words “only reasonable inference” have to do real work. Interpretation is doing serious mind-reading here, and when you add anti-Israel bias to the mix, it can all appear to be objective.  

The Court has to test the genocide explanation against evidence that could count against it, with the same skepticism it brings to Israel’s explanations. 

The Myanmar ruling gives us no indication that it will.



 

Thursday, November 19, 2026

From Ian:

Commentary: The Pincer Attack Against American Jews
If the next president is Vance, these Democrats in Congress will find surprising common ground with a politician they otherwise revile. Vance appears to have been methodically establishing the arguments he will use to reverse the case he made only two years ago for Israel’s status as an American ally. In May 2024, two months before he was announced as Trump’s running mate, Vance gave a major foreign policy address to the isolationist Quincy Institute. There, before an audience of Israel skeptics, Vance explained why he supported Israel but not Ukraine.

“I certainly admire the Ukrainians who are fighting against Russia, but I do not think that it is in America’s interest to continue to fund an effectively never-ending war in Ukraine,” Vance said. In contrast, allying closely with Israel can “actually give us missile-defense parity. That’s a very important national security objective of the United States of America, and that’s something we’re working with one of the most innovative economies in the world to accomplish.”

The basic question, Vance said, is this: “Do we want clients who depend on us, who can’t do anything without us? Or do we want real allies who can actually advance their interests on their own with America playing a leadership role?”

Vance’s post-midterms statement was a point-by-point refutation of this case for Israel. The war with Iran has apparently demonstrated, to Vance, that Israel can’t and won’t always fight alone. This drains American resources and flies in the face of an “America First” strategy. Therefore, we must “change our relationship to Israel.”

Yet this raises a question: Throughout his career, Vance has been willing to adapt his principles to match whatever has popular support on the right. Polls show a majority of Republican voters still believe that Trump’s level of support for Israel is right where it should be. Why would Vance stake out a position on the other side?

The answer is that Vance chooses policy stances not by their popularity but by their usefulness to his own career advancement. The two are not always the same. Vance envisions a race for the 2028 Republican presidential nomination in which supporters of the U.S.-Israel alliance will already be backing a different candidate. His ambition therefore would naturally lead him to jettison his grudging, utilitarian support for our alliance with Israel. To win the nomination, however, he’ll have to convince enough Republicans to follow suit.

How might he seek to do this? Not only by blaming Israel for decisions his administration made, but by taking a page out of anti-Israel Democrats’ playbook and exacerbating the existing divides within American Jewry.

Vance’s wing of conservatism is populated by NatCons—the National Conservatives. As Naya Lekht writes elsewhere in this issue, the NatCons advocate a form of blood-and-soil nationalism for the American right. They recently held a conference in Jerusalem where several speakers exhorted Israelis to tell U.S. Jews to stop complaining about anti-Semitism. The message: American Jews are ruining it for Israel. This is a right-wing version of the Democrats’ ongoing campaign to convince American Jews that Israelis are to blame for all their woes.

Thus are American Jews presented with the following demand: They need to renounce the parts of Judaism that extremist political demagogues find distasteful and disassociate themselves from the Jews who won’t follow suit.

“Judaism and the Jewish people are not the same as Israel and AIPAC. They’re not the same,” El-Sayed said in August. He’d said the same thing three weeks earlier on Meet the Press: “I love and revere Judaism and the Jewish people…. But they are not the same as AIPAC and Israel.”

AIPAC, of course, isn’t Israel. It is an organization of Americans who support the U.S.-Israel alliance. El-Sayed’s comments are a reminder that Israel’s enemies see American Jews as a direct threat to their agenda. It’s a sentiment shared by numerous progressives, who will now have the wind at their backs—and an unlikely cheerleader in JD Vance who hopes to replicate their success.

This is more than a horseshoe. It’s a pincer attack, and attacks must be foiled or the attackers will simply continue to advance. Many American Jews—the majority in Michigan who voted for el-Sayed, for example—have decided they are not going to fight, or are going to accept some illusory deal whereby they will be left alone if they go along to get along. The Jews throughout history who try to buy off those with deadly intent against them either end up no longer being Jews or learning too late the cost of their appeasement.

The rest of us, unable to retreat into illusion, are going to have to fight the pincer attack for them—not because these contemptible Jews deserve to be fought for, but because it is the battle for our children and grandchildren, who do.
Jake Wallis Simons: Ed Miliband’s diplomacy is narcissism mixed with progressive ideology
In his own mind, Ed Miliband must have been a crusader in shining armour, Palestinian colours fluttering from his lance. “Do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution,” the Foreign Secretary thundered as he slammed his visor on Tuesday and announced fresh sanctions on Israel.

After all, this is the man who, back in 2015, left his aides-mémoires lying around in a dressing room until the tabloids found them. “Happy warrior”, he had reminded himself in the notes. “Relish the chance to show who I am.” More than a decade later, the country knows who Miliband is, and knows it good and proper.

Narcissism and ideology do not effective foreign policy make. The new sanctions were slapped upon eight developers involved in construction on the West Bank. The measures were timed to pre-empt the deadline for tenders to build on the E1 area, a 4.6-square-mile section of land hyperbolically described as key to a future Palestinian state.

There is just one problem: nobody is building anything. Israel’s Attorney-General, Gali Baharav-Miara, has frozen the E1 tender process until coalition negotiations have confirmed a new government. Oops! What a bungle. The Foreign Office jumped the gun, sanctioning companies over a process that has been paused and may now never happen at all.

Why didn’t Miliband wait until Israel’s position was clear? Clearly, pulling the trigger was more important than hitting the target. In normal times, Britain’s foreign policy would be based firstly upon making our country more prosperous and secure, and secondly upon fostering stability overseas in a style that is conducive to our interests. But these are not normal times. These are times of performance.

When it comes to the Middle East, neither Miliband nor his Foreign Office apparatchiks appear to care for the facts. If they did, they would surely form policy on the understanding that the Palestinian leadership has repeatedly rejected offers of sovereignty over the years, while whining about it at the same time.

Let’s see. There was 1937, 1947, 2000, oh, and 2008, when Ehud Olmert offered Mahmoud Abbas 94 per cent of the West Bank with extra land to reach 100 per cent, East Jerusalem as a Palestinian capital, and the Old City turned over to international control. Who in their right mind would shun an offer like that? Answer: Mahmoud Abbas, that’s who.

It could not be more obvious. The Palestinian leadership does not want a country alongside Israel, but one in place of it. That is the true obstacle to the two-state solution. Does nobody see through the grift? How have we convinced ourselves that supporting authoritarianism, corruption, mendacity and jihad is virtuous? We are making abject fools of ourselves, with Miliband leading the charge.
NGO Monitor: UK puts its reputation above Israel’s security concerns
In response to the United Kingdom’s statement on Tuesday urging Israel to “allow immediate, rapid and unimpeded humanitarian access throughout Gaza,” NGO Monitor noted that the British government has a history of moral posturing while ignoring the risks to Israel of providing terror groups a way to resupply.

The Jerusalem-based watchdog group posted to X on Tuesday a document it first publicized in May 2025 from the Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO), dated November 2022, showing that British officials were aware of Hamas involvement in Gaza cash-assistance programs, but chose to provide funds to the programs anyway, despite the significant risk the money would be diverted to the terror group.

The FCDO document explains that “the cash assistance component will be implemented in coordination with the Gaza Ministry of Social Development MoSD.” MoSD is Hamas-run, something the document acknowledged.

“The MoSD in Gaza is affiliated with the de facto authorities and thus UK Aid can be linked directly or indirectly with supporting the de factor [sic] authority (Hamas) in Gaza which is part of a proscribed group,” it stated.

Under a column titled “risk category,” the document rated the risk “reputational. Risk appetite: receptive.” In others, the FCDO recommended going ahead with the assistance.

“Time and again, the United Kingdom dismisses real security risks, choosing instead to advance an activist foreign policy. NGO Monitor found that British diplomats opted to ignore concerns that Hamas was likely dictating the disbursement of U.K. taxpayer funds, while also reassuring the terrorist organization that U.K. proscription would not change U.K. funding practices,” Anne Herzberg, NGO Monitor’s legal adviser, told JNS.

“The British Foreign Commonwealth and Development Office stated it was more concerned with its ‘reputational risk’ than that of Hamas aid diversion. Despite the Oct. 7 atrocities and the ensuing war, the U.K. government has decided to double down on its reckless and failed policies,” she said, referring to the Hamas-led invasion of southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.
From Ian:

Debunking the Gaza Genocide Allegations
Navi Pillay, the Nobel Peace Prize laureate and head of a UN commission of inquiry on Gaza, wants to indict Israeli President Isaac Herzog for incitement to commit genocide. In a press conference on Oct. 13, 2023, Herzog said that "it is an entire nation out there that is responsible" for the Oct. 7 Hamas attack. The commission doesn't mention that the army received orders, including from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, to prevent hunger in Gaza and operate in accordance with international law.

The commission's conclusion preceded the investigation. Commission member Chris Sidoti said that if thousands of Palestinians were killed, there was no explanation other than a desire to annihilate. Pillay presented amazingly broad criteria in her definition of genocide. "There is no requirement as to a minimum number of victims for the act to constitute a genocidal act of killing." But she only applies this standard to Israel. Why isn't the Oct. 7 massacre genocide?

She writes that the indiscriminate massacre on the written orders of then-Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, calling for the killing or kidnapping of anyone they encountered, including children, does not support an intent to annihilate. If killing one person can be counted as genocide when it comes to Israel, how is a massacre based on written orders not one when it comes to Hamas? When you remove the enemy from the picture, all the fatalities become civilians and the entire war looks like genocide.

Israel relinquished the element of surprise by warning civilians, it let aid through and halted operations in order to vaccinate over half a million children against polio. You can't argue an intent to maximize killing while disqualifying evidence of steps taken to limit it while forgoing military advantages.

One of the "genocidal acts" that the commission report attributes to Israel is deliberate starvation. But according to a new study we have conducted, based on the Gaza Health Ministry's records for 2025, mortality from disease and natural causes was 271.7 per 100,000 people, compared with 258.6 in 2019, the last year before the pandemic and the war. For children under 4, the number was 744 compared with 736. That is, even according to Hamas figures, there was no significant excess mortality from disease and malnutrition, and thus no mass starvation in 2025. The UN's declaration of famine turned out to be erroneous.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali: Islamists Won't Stop at the Jews
How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? What happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?

Judeo-Christian civilization and the West are threatened by a rising tide of Islamist thought and politics. Islamism, the project of organizing all aspects of life in accordance with an uncompromising understanding of Sharia, is fundamentally at odds with liberal democracy. Sharia rejects freedom of conscience. Its inheritance and family law treat women unequally, and it denies women's basic rights in other ways. Non-Muslims receive markedly different treatment from Muslims under Sharia.

These ideas stand in stark contrast to the American tradition, and to the values of freedom, equality, and individual rights. What is at stake is not the fate of one ethnic or religious community vis-a-vis another. It is the future of individual rights, and the principles that underpin free societies and, ultimately, the survival of Western civilization itself.

Islam is the sum total of religious and legal traditions, commentaries, and interpretations that have arisen within the world's second-largest religion. Islamism is a family of political ideologies united by their aspiration to reshape society and the state in accordance with their interpretation of ideologically hostile teachings. Islamism has an authoritarian bent and frequently targets Muslim dissidents and apostates.

Many Muslims wish to see change within their own religion. But in too many instances, governments and other Western institutions have chosen to empower precisely those Muslim organizations most amenable to Islamist ideas, effectively anointing them as the official voice of Islam and Muslims in the West.

This dynamic has served to entrench the most theologically and socially conservative expressions of Islam, and to marginalize more pluralistic voices. It has given voice to those elements within the Muslim community most hostile to the philosophies and principles that I, and I suspect most readers, hold dear. That voice is growing louder by the day.
Clifford D. May: Israel Can't Be Both Feared in the Middle East and Loved in the West
After Israel's elections and America's midterms, I spent a week in Israel where I heard from officials, soldiers and journalists, Jewish, Muslim and Druze Israelis, and the occasional all-knowing cabdriver. My takeaway? The trauma of Oct. 7, 2023, has not dissipated. Yet Israelis remain stubbornly resilient.

Tehran's hope is that Congress next year will cut off funds for U.S. combat activities to "end the war" with Iran - a euphemism for American humiliation and a historic victory for Tehran's Islamic revolutionaries.

Would the war's end not at least address the "affordability crisis" at the pump? The opposite. If Tehran regains its nuclear program, erects an enormous missile and drone shield, and tolls the ships passing through the Strait of Hormuz, it could effectively set the global price of oil. Should that happen, even the $4.50-a-gallon gasoline this spring will seem like a bargain.

For now, Iran and most of Israel's other mortal enemies are weaker than they were on Oct. 7, but none have been decisively defeated. Each believes it is waging a divinely mandated war.

Hamas built an underground fortress for its fighters - a vast bomb shelter from which Gaza civilians were barred. How is that OK with those in America and Europe who proclaim themselves "pro-Palestinian"?

Genocide means acts committed to destroy a people. That intent is Hamas's, not that of Jews defending themselves. Israel cannot be both feared in the jungle that is the Middle East and loved in the West.

Our weekly column from the humor site PreOccupied Territory.

Satellite crosshairs

Check out their Facebook and Substack pages.





Dublin, November 22 — A growing number of governments have concluded that the most effective way to penalize the Jewish State for its behavior is to refuse its defense and security technology, a policy whose principal result so far has been to leave those governments less able to protect their own officials, events, and airspace. They expect that outcome to teach Israel a lesson, according to officials.

Ireland’s An Garda Síochána recently acquired Israeli-designed counter-drone systems manufactured by Sentrycs for use during the country’s presidency of the Council of the European Union. The purchase occurred despite a 2024 declaration by then-Tánaiste Micheál Martin that Ireland would not procure military or defense equipment containing Israeli-made products. Sources familiar with the procurement described the equipment as among the best available and noted the difficulty of obtaining comparable capability without Israeli involvement. Irish officials underscored the harsh message this must convey to Tel Aviv.

The episode fits a broader pattern. Spain has canceled or suspended multiple contracts with Israeli firms, including orders for Spike anti-tank missiles, Litening targeting pods, and PULS rocket artillery systems. Spanish officials and defense analysts have acknowledged that the embargo has created gaps in anti-tank and rocket-artillery capability and that fully replacing the systems will require additional time, money, and redesign. Some previously canceled technology has reappeared through European licensing arrangements. Spanish authorities have maintained that the resulting constraints on their own forces still constitute a meaningful form of pressure, they swear.

France has restricted Israeli participation at major defense exhibitions and limited certain forms of cooperation. Israeli industry executives have responded that demand for the underlying systems remains high regardless of political messaging, and that customers continue to seek workarounds when the equipment is judged operationally necessary. French officials have not described these workarounds as a dilution of the lesson being taught, though analysts do note the consistency with French propensity to respond to conflict by surrendering.

Other European states have imposed or announced similar restrictions only to confront the same practical constraint: Israeli firms currently supply a substantial share of certain categories of proven counter-drone, air-defense, precision-guidance, and related systems. With those systems unavailable, security organizations either accept reduced capability, pay more for less-mature alternatives, or quietly source the original technology through intermediaries, often declaring, "That'll show 'em!"

Scholars point to the important parallels with anti-Israel policies writ large, which have consistently generated for more harm and suffering among Israel's foes than among Israelis.



 

AddToAny

Printfriendly

EoZTV Podcast

Podcast URL

Subscribe in podnovaSubscribe with FeedlyAdd to netvibes
addtomyyahoo4Subscribe with SubToMe

search eoz

comments

Speaking

translate

E-Book

For $18 donation








Sample Text

EoZ's Most Popular Posts in recent years

Search2

Hasbys!

Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون



This blog may be a labor of love for me, but it takes a lot of effort, time and money. For 20 years and 40,000 articles I have been providing accurate, original news that would have remained unnoticed. I've written hundreds of scoops and sometimes my reporting ends up making a real difference. I appreciate any donations you can give to keep this blog going.

Donate!

Donate to fight for Israel!

Monthly subscription:
Payment options


One time donation:

Follow EoZ on Twitter!

Interesting Blogs

Blog Archive