Anti-Zionism’s next frontier is Western military action against Israel
Over the past few months, we may have caught a glimpse of where the anti-Zionists' insatiable hatred of Israel may be heading.Melanie Phillips: Miliband’s murderous solution
In September, British Labour MP Tahir Ali, an anti-war politician who called the US-Israel war against Iran "illegal," called for British “military action” against Israel during a House of Commons debate on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, while also arguing that Israel should be required to disarm. He only apologized for his remarks due to pressure from leaders in his party.
Earlier this month, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, a French presidential candidate and leader of the "anti-imperialist" party France Unbowed, which rejects Western military intervention around the world, pledged during a campaign rally to take direct military action regarding Israel if elected, including deploying French Navy ships challenging Israel's blockade of Gaza.
And, only a week ago, the anti-Zionist writer Benjamin Moser, whose book on the history of anti-Zionism received rave reviews at The Guardian, declared – during a podcast interview – that Israel will and should be destroyed "militarily and economically."
While such pronouncements, particularly by Mélenchon and Ali, can be viewed as an obscene kind of "virtue signaling," rather than a serious call for military action against Israel, it is nonetheless disturbing that the idea of invading Israel – a nation they and their ideological fellow travelers already view as lacking moral legitimacy, and which has forfeited its right to exist – has become a populist talking point for segments of the putatively pacifist Left.
How cognitive dissonance fueled anti-Israel radicalization
So, how did we get to this point? Perhaps the best answer comes from Israeli writer Shany Mor, who, in late Oct. 2023, commenting on how many in the West had already turned against Israel, wrote that “many would think that an atrocity like the Hamas-led October 7 massacre in Israel would lead opponents of the Jewish state to temper their attacks.”
Instead, he correctly observed, “from college campuses to mainstream media outlets, elite left-wing circles responded to the terror group’s barbarism by intensifying their denunciations of Israel.”
Mor argued that this behavior is “an example of cognitive-dissonance reduction, the process by which people reconcile new information that contradicts their firmly held priors.”
“Western activists for Palestinians,” he added, “are dedicated to two nearly theological precepts: that Israel is evil, and that no Palestinian action is ever connected to any Palestinian outcome.”
Hamas’s antisemitic savagery, he concluded, “posed a threat to this worldview, and the only way to resolve it was by heightening Israel’s imagined malevolence. The terrorist atrocities didn’t trigger a recoiling from the cause in whose name they were carried out; they led to an even greater revulsion at the victim.”
Anti-Zionists, three years after they decided to double down on their hatred of Israel, have no other path to take than continuing to find more and more incendiary and vilifying rhetoric targeting both Israel and, by extension, if not by design, its millions of Diaspora Jewish supporters around the world.
Calling on Western armies to confront Israel militarily is merely the latest manifestation of a movement consumed by a pathological hatred that requires the total dehumanization of its target to justify its own extremism.
Their core belief is the fantasy of creating the brotherhood of man, in which there are no nations and no religions to divide us and—in the words of John Lennon’s song “Imagine”—nothing to fight or die for.The Muslim Brotherhood as a Terrorist Organization: What Egypt's Court Ruling Reveals About Europe
Every conflict can be solved by negotiation and compromise. In their culture of moral relativism in which there’s no objective good or bad, right or wrong, the only thing that matters is the consequences. Wars must be avoided, as that means dead people. So Israel must negotiate a solution with the Palestinians.
The fact that Palestinian Arab identity is itself constructed around the extinction of the Jewish presence in the land of Israel is simply blanked out. It can’t be allowed to get in the way of the unshakeable liberal belief that everyone in the world only wants a nice job, a nice family and a nice life.
Believing in nothing very much themselves, trapped in their bubble of narcissistic hedonism, such liberals cannot begin to grasp the strength of fanatical Islamic religious belief that seeks the annihilation of Israel and the death of Jews. They say that war solves nothing (World War II, anyone?) and the only solution is through negotiated settlement.
That’s why Miliband is obsessed with the two-state solution, which he described as “the ‘North Star’ of this government’s approach” to Israel and Palestinian Arabs.
The fact that a state of their own has already been offered and rejected by the Palestinian Arabs five times—and that a Palestinian state would put all of central Israel within firing range from the strategic hilltops of Judea and Samaria—means nothing to him at all.
What he so signally fails to grasp is that the unending Middle East impasse that obsesses him beyond all else was actually created by his own country through precisely the strategy he is now demanding Israel accepts.
For Britain pioneered the “two-state solution” twice. First, when Winston Churchill hived off three-quarters of Palestine, which had all been designated for the Jewish homeland, to carve out Jordan for the Hashemite Arabs. And second, when it tried unsuccessfully to palm off to the Arabs much of what was left of Mandate Palestine to stop them from murdering even more Brits and Jews.
This reward to the Palestinian Arabs for genocidal terror, which has remained the strategy of Britain and the West ever since, has incentivized them to continue to try to wipe Israel out in the certainty that Britain and the West will punish the Jews ever more severely for resisting.
Britain is therefore the original creator of this terrible conflict, and has much Israeli and Arab blood on its hands as a result. Burnham and Miliband are merely continuing to perpetuate a truly infernal legacy.
The following day, the Second Criminal Chamber of Badr placed 35 organizations and 36 individuals on the terrorist list...
Among those named are the powerful Council of European Muslims, successor to the Federation of Islamic Organizations in Europe (FIOE); Musulmans de France; the League of Muslims of Belgium; and national organizations operating in Britain, Germany, and other European countries. The ruling also names the European Council for Fatwa and Research, the European Council of Imams and the European Institute of Human Sciences.
[T]he Egyptian judiciary is not merely targeting political leaders and isolated local initiatives. What emerges is a distinctly European Islamist and terrorist network, driven by a single, coherent ideological project: that of the Muslim Brotherhood in Europe.
Political action does not necessarily begin at the ballot box. It begins much earlier, with the dissemination of religious doctrines and the patient construction of lasting institutions. The method is similar to that of the Italian communist Antonio Gramsci: conquer society from below, and political power will eventually fall into your hands.
Every link in the network shares one overriding point of reference: Sharia, "the divine guidance revealed in the Qur'an and the Sunnah, covering both worship and everyday dealings."
Taken together, these provisions form a coherent logic: to undermine democracy. Islamic Sharia law is placed above all other laws -- first for Muslims, then for everyone else.
Sharia offers no dialogue. It blocks all dissenting voices — Jewish, Christian, atheist — especially when Islamists consider themselves sufficiently numerous to impose their will.
The late, influential Sunni spiritual leader, Yusuf al-Qaradawi, forced to flee from Egypt to Qatar, admitted on his popular Al Jazeera television show, "Sharia and Life," that "If they had gotten rid of the apostasy punishment Islam wouldn't exist today."
Does anyone grasp the magnitude of the humiliation involved in leaving it to Egypt to expose the Muslim Brotherhood's sprawling network across Europe?



















