This Wednesday, Montview Boulevard Presbyterian Church in Denver will host an event entitled "Faith at Times of Crises: Reflections from Palestine and the U.S." The event, co-sponsored by Bright Stars of Bethlehem, brings together five theologians, scholars and faith leaders to discuss faith, justice and the challenges facing our world.
One of the featured speakers is Rev. Dr. Mitri Raheb, a Palestinian Christian theologian, the founder and president of Dar al-Kalima University in Bethlehem and the author of dozens of books. The organizers describe him as someone whose participation is especially meaningful because of his lived experience, theological scholarship and longstanding commitment to education and cultural development.Here is what this respected theologian wrote on October 7, 2023, while Hamas terrorists were slaughtering Israeli families, massacring young people at a music festival and kidnapping children and Holocaust survivors:
The desire for freedom is stronger than the settler colonial state. The Palestinians keep showing new forms of creative resistance & resilience. Our heart goes to our people in Gaza & especially our staff & students there. Your prayers, advocacy, & support now is much appreciated.
The burning families alive, murder, kidnapping and rapes are "creative resistance"????
Raheb has spent years promoting the concept of creative resistance as a particularly Christian approach to the Palestinian struggle. In his 2014 book, Faith in the Face of Empire: The Bible Through Palestinian Eyes, he describes how Palestinians can use painting, dance, theater and music to advance their cause. His university is dedicated in large part to encouraging this sort of creativity.
In a 2015 letter, he told young Palestinians:
The question is not if we should resist or not, but the most important question is how to resist, and how to resist creatively. We do not want you to die, but to live for Palestine.
So what exactly were the new forms of creative resistance that Mitri Raheb saw on October 7?
Was it the use of paragliders to reach a music festival? The use of bulldozers to breach the border? The kidnapping of an entire family, including a nine-month-old baby? The livestreaming of murders to the victims' own families?
Whatever one's opinion of Israel, settlements or Palestinian nationalism, the deliberate murder of civilians is a moral abomination. One would think that a Christian theologian, of all people, would recognize the difference between producing a play and murdering dancers. Yet on October 7, Raheb applied the very same morally affirmative language he had developed to describe art and education to the events of that day.
To this theologian, Jewish suffering is so irrelevant, and Palestinian opposition to the Jewish state so inherently righteous, that even the mass murder of Jews can be incorporated into a Christian theology of liberation.
And now a church in Denver wants Americans to learn about faith and justice from this man.
This is a travesty.
The church says "We love asking the big questions that don’t have easy answers, " OK, here's a question for you: How the hell did you think this was appropriate?
Then again, maybe the answer is that the church also says, "We believe that joy is one of the surest signs of God’s presence." The Hamas butchers certainly exhibited joy as they livestreamed murders, raped women, cut off their breasts, shot them and continued to rape their corpses. It was very creative resistance. Perhaps this is what the church meant?
(h/t Ben Weinthal)
Elder of Ziyon







