I saw this video where Nate Friedman visits an anti-Israel and communist protest in New York City.
He tried to interview the usual Neturei Karta crowd, who refused to speak to him because they didn't want to speak into a microphone on Shabbat. (Their leader told him this...on the microphone.)
I was more interested in their signs.
Carrying anything outside an "eruv" (enclosure) on Shabbat is strictly prohibited, but wearing clothing is permitted (obviously.) They "wear" the signs as if they are ponchos, with a hole in the middle for their heads.
But can protest signs be halachically considered clothing, even if "worn"?
Almost certainly not. No one would consider signs to be real clothing, even if "worn," and clothing is only permitted when it is used for the normal purposes of clothing: protection/warmth, decoration or modesty. "Decoration" is for jewelry and the like. These signs cannot be considered decoration, as no normal person wears anything looking like them.
So I cannot see a possible leniency that would allow these "religious Jews" to publicly profane the Sabbath. They are doing the equivalent of carrying something by putting it on a string, typing it around one's neck and calling it a "necklace" just to be able to carry it.
A more interesting question is the one Friedman asked them - how they came to Manhattan. They almost certainly didn't walk from Williamsburg, and in fact they probably couldn't cross the bridge on Shabbat. This means that they are staying in hotels or rent an apartment in Manhattan, both of which are quite expensive. So who is bankrolling them?
Given their meetings with the leaders of the Palestinian Authority, Iran, Hamas and Hezbollah, it seems likely that at least some of their funding comes from antisemites.
This blog may be a labor of love for me, but it takes a lot of effort, time and money. For 20 years and 40,000 articles I have been providing accurate, original news that would have remained unnoticed. I've written hundreds of scoops and sometimes my reporting ends up making a real difference. I appreciate any donations you can give to keep this blog going.
Weekend long read
-
1) The FDD provides a briefing on ‘The Many Faces of the Muslim
Brotherhood’. “The Brotherhood has scores of national branches across the
globe....
The ...
Weekend long read
-
1) The FDD provides a briefing on ‘The Many Faces of the Muslim
Brotherhood’. “The Brotherhood has scores of national branches across the
globe....
The ...
Libyan Jew Luzon demands compensation
-
Raphael Luzon has been a leading campaigner for the rights of Libyan Jews.
In this interview with the Libyan newspaper Newspaper Alsa’ah 24, Luzon
does...
An early Happy Chanukka and a Peaceful Shabbat
-
Dry Bones Golden Oldie, by Sali the LSW.
I saw Sufganiot (Jelly Dounuts) already on sale today in Israel! So Hannuka
is just around the corner. Hopefull...
Elder Eoten
-
The Elder Eoten is one of a handful of Apex Creatures you’ll find while
exploring the most difficult Forest Realm in Nightingale. It’s a huge,
animate tree...
Now What?
-
Today, Jews cannot walk down the street in North America, Europe, or even
Australia without the possibility of being spat on, beaten, or even
murdered. Cou...
Closing Jews Down Under Website
-
With a heavyish heart I am closing down the website after ten years.
It is and it isn’t an easy decision after 10 years of constant work. The
past...
‘Test & Trace’ is a mirage
-
Lockdown II thoughts: Day 1 Opposition politicians have been banging on
about the need for a ‘working’ Test & Trace system even more loudly than
the govern...