Actually, real Israel-hating "academics" say exactly this. From Inside Higher Ed:
Curtis Marez, president of the association and a professor of ethnic studies at the University of California at San Diego, was quoted as saying: "The boycott is the best way to protect and expand academic freedom and access to education.".
The American Association of University Professors wrote an open letter to the ASA saying why academic boycotts are hypocritical. But you won't find a copy of it on the ASA website or Facebook page. Some issues are apparently so important that it would be dangerous to expose people to another point of view. The ASA must think that its members simply cannot be trusted with hearing both sides of a story.
(h/t DM)