Arsen Ostrovsky: The West must play to win against terrorism
As history has shown, authoritarian regimes and non-state actors understand and respond to one thing: ruthless power. Whether military, economic or political, decisive action has proven to be the only language understood by those who seek to disrupt global stability.WSJ Editorial: Biden Tilts at Hizbullah Windmills
Western nations learned this lesson the hard way during World War II, when British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain’s policy of appeasement failed spectacularly. Chamberlain’s ill-fated agreement with Hitler, meant to ensure “peace for our time,” only delayed the inevitable. As Churchill scolded him, “you were given the choice between war and dishonour. You chose dishonour and you will have war.”
Ultimately, it was not diplomacy but total military defeat that ended Nazi Germany’s threat to Europe. To use Churchill’s words again, when asked what was Britain’s policy, he said “victory, victory at all costs.”
Yet since its establishment in 1948, the Jewish state has been the only democracy repeatedly denied the right to achieve total victory against enemies who have time and again initiated wars and pogroms, seeking no less than its very annihilation.
Even though it was Israel attacked by Hamas on Oct. 7, it was also an assault on the West and the principles it claims to uphold — freedom, democracy and the rule of law. If the West truly seeks to uphold these sacrosanct values, then it must finally abandon the strategy of limited warfare and throw its full weight behind Israel as the frontier of Western civilization.
This is not the time for half measures. Hamas, Hezbollah and their sponsors in Tehran must be decisively defeated, not contained.
As Ronald Reagan warned in 1964, during his “A Time for Choosing” speech in the peak of the Cold War, “a policy of accommodation is appeasement, and it gives no choice between peace and war, only between fight or surrender.”
The bad actors of today — China, Russia, Iran, North Korea and their proxies — do not negotiate from a place of weakness or fear international opinion. Instead, they project power without concern for identity politics or public sentiment.
In short, the West must play to win in order to defend freedom.
When President Biden told the UN General Assembly on Tuesday that "a diplomatic solution is still possible" with Hizbullah, we wonder where he's been for the past 11 months. Israel gave those months over to diplomacy on its northern front, even as Hizbullah fired 8,500 rockets and forced 60,000 Israelis from their homes. But the U.S.-led talks went nowhere as Mr. Biden pressed Israel not to hit Hizbullah too hard.70 Weapons Depots, 80 Missiles, and 3 Senior Commanders: How a Week of Israeli Strikes Kneecapped Hezbollah
UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres warned Tuesday of Lebanon "becoming another Gaza." Nice of him to wake up. Since 2006, UN peacekeepers have done nothing to stop Hizbullah from taking over the Security Council-mandated buffer zone in southern Lebanon. Now Israel has to do it for them.
One lesson of Oct. 7 is that Israel can't let terrorists build up armies, even if they seem deterred. Northern Israel could never be safe if Hizbullah retains its arsenal.
Israel has destroyed scores of Hezbollah missiles, drones, and rocket launchers across Lebanon over the past several days, orchestrating an unprecedented series of pinpoint airstrikes and intelligence-driven operations that have quickly degraded swaths of the terror group's arsenal—and eliminated at least three of the group's senior commanders.
Israel's air force is pummeling Hezbollah's arms depots and targeting its senior leadership, marking the "most extensive" strikes "ever carried out in its history," according to the country's military leaders and regional news outlets.
Hezbollah, long known as Iran's preeminent regional terror proxy, is being defanged by the Jewish state's armed forces in the process. It has lost almost half of its medium and long-range missiles in a series of Israeli raids designed to annihilate "surveillance equipment, command rooms, and other infrastructure" used by Hezbollah to rain terror on Israel's northern border.
On Wednesday, Israel continued its offensive, showing no signs of backing down from a fight that it largely avoided for months as it turned its attention to Hamas in the wake of the Oct. 7 terror spree. Around 60 key targets belonging to Hezbollah's "intelligence division" were struck across Lebanon, with Israeli military leaders promising to destroy "all of their rocket capabilities" and bases.
All told, Israel has logged close to 3,000 flight hours, using more than 250 warplanes to drop an estimated 2,000 munitions across 200 separate locations in Lebanon, the Israel Defense Forces confirmed to the Washington Free Beacon. The strikes have destroyed around 400 medium-range rocket launchers, 70 weapons storage depots, and around 80 drones and cruise missiles. They've also killed at least three senior commanders—rocket and missile division head Ibrahim Qubaisi, military operations head Ibrahim Aqil, and training unit head Ahmed Wahbi—along with other top fighters.
The coordinated attacks, Israel says, are "changing the operational situation in the north, changing the reality," for Hezbollah as the terror group goes on defense after nearly a year of nonstop terror strikes on Israeli towns throughout the country. The ongoing aerial assault is being viewed as a regional game changer, proving to Hezbollah that it is not as untouchable as its leaders once believed.
Still, experts who spoke to the Free Beacon emphasized that Israel has a long way to go in its bid to defeat the terror group.
Hizballah’s Strategy Is in Tatters, but That Doesn’t Necessarily Mean Victory for Israel
While quite a lot has happened since this piece by John Raine was published on September 20, I think its analysis has only become more persuasive:Alan Dershowitz: Israel's Pager Attack Was Legal under the Laws of War
Whatever shape the next phase [of the war] takes it is now clear that Israel is rendering obsolete the paradigm of violent co-existence within which it has fought Hizballah for decades. That is a problem for the Hizballah leadership, which has relied on being able to fight a limited war in which they exercised control over the levels of violence through careful calibration of their operations. They may no longer have that lever, and they and their patron, Iran, may now need a new strategy to ensure their own survival. What are their options?
Most critically Hizballah will require Iran’s close and sustained support to maintain it as a fighting force, to deliver its regional network of non-state armed groups, and to use its influence with Russia and other powers to garner support—possibly including military support for Hizballah. The group will expect Tehran to guarantee its survival; the regime in Iran has little option but to follow through. Hizballah is a uniquely valuable partner for Tehran and without it the keystone falls out of the axis of resistance, [as Iran’s network of allies and proxies is known]. While the loss of Hamas is politically bearable in Tehran, that of Hizballah is not.
There is a complication for Tehran, however. While it has a spiritual commitment to Hizballah, its strategy has been to avoid escalation to state-on-state war with Israel; . . . its armed forces are not configured for a sustained war with Israel. Its capabilities and its strategy are designed to sponsor asymmetric conflict with Israel through third parties. Its strategy with Israel has been everything short of war, anything but peace.
Yet, although Israel can shift the strategic balance, it is not at all clear it will be able to achieve a decisive victory.
The international "community" and its academic justifiers have claimed that Israel's attacks on Hizbullah communications devices are unlawful. They are dead wrong. The law is clear that if a person becomes a combatant, he is a legitimate military target. Becoming a combatant includes joining or assisting Hizbullah, harboring its terrorists, or allowing one's home or building to be used by Israel's enemies. The law is also clear that once someone becomes a combatant, he or she can be targeted as long as they retain that status.US officials weighing steps Biden could take to preserve two-states after election
If a person qualifies as a combatant, he or she may be targeted and killed while asleep, at work or at play. Combatants need not be actively involved in combat at the moment they are killed. Nor do they need to be actively committing terrorism when targeted. It is enough that they maintain the status of combatant. The individuals who were given beepers by Hizbullah were clearly combatants. Their deaths and injuries were lawful, even if they were shopping or walking when blown up.
Settlement labeling
However this is only one of the few steps that Biden aides are considering taking during the lame-duck period that are broadly aimed at preserving and advancing prospects for a two-state solution.
Another one is to reverse a lame-duck decision taken by Trump in 2020 requiring goods made in Israeli-controlled areas of the West Bank to be labeled as “Made in Israel.” While the move was aimed at presenting the West Bank settlements as an equal part of Israel, it also applied to Palestinian towns in Area C of the West Bank.
That was a move that some Biden aides thought would’ve been taken much earlier in the president’s term, but fell through the cracks, the former senior US official said, acknowledging that it was less likely to be approved if Trump wins, given the likelihood of its reversal.
The concern in the past about labeling settlement products was that opponents would conflate it with a boycott of Israel, but proponents argue that it can be framed as a step that separates the settlements from the rest of the country.
Reopening the consulate
Biden came into office pledging to reopen the US Consulate in Jerusalem, the de facto mission to the Palestinians that Trump shuttered in 2019.
The move required a degree of approval from the Israeli government, which repeatedly rejected the idea. The administration sufficed with establishing an Office of Palestinian Affairs in 2022, which was still part of the US Embassy to Israel but was allowed to send diplomatic cables directly to Washington without being filtered by the US ambassador to Israel.
The lack of follow-through on Biden’s election promise has been a major sticking point for the PA, which some US officials would still like to remedy if Harris wins in November.
The former senior US official said the White House could dangle one last visit from Biden to Israel to participate in the corner-stone laying ceremony for the yet-to-be-built US embassy compound in exchange for Jerusalem lifting its opposition to reopening the consulate.
Leveraging US aid to Israel
One move that has not received as much public attention, but the former senior US official said could prove effective, would be for the US to threaten to change a clause in the Memorandum of Understanding on US security assistance to Israel that allows Jerusalem to spend up to 25 percent of the aid on weapons made in Israel.
Israel is the only country that isn’t required to spend the entirety of assistance it receives from Washington in the US. The former US official said Netanyahu’s aides pushed for this clause to be included in the MoU before it was signed in 2008 because many of the weapon manufacturing plants in Israel are managed by members of Netanyahu’s Likud Party.
While the MoU has already been signed, it is not legally binding, is subject to changes and has already seen minor violations by Israel, the former senior US official said, arguing that the US should threaten to remove the clause in question in order to pressure Netanyahu to take steps that advance a two-state solution.
A ‘realistic’ two-state solution
While the current and former US officials were skeptical that Biden would unilaterally recognize a Palestinian state or allow a resolution to be passed against Israel at the UN Security Council during the lame-duck period, they did think the president could approve a top member of his administration giving a high-level speech laying out Washington’s view on the need for a two-state solution and what a “realistic” proposal could look like.
It could be fashioned by the address former secretary of state John Kerry gave during the lame-duck period of Obama’s second term in December 2016 — a speech that was not received well by Netanyahu, who was still prime minister then.
The current and former senior US officials offered several other ideas of steps that Biden could approve after the presidential election but didn’t want them publicized due to fear that this could harm their chances of being implemented.
We should assume that like Obama, the Biden White House will facilitate some kind of Security Council resolution that harms Israel during the lame duck period. Perhaps full statehood recognition for the Palestinians. They know a future administration cannot roll back an UNSCR.
— Richard Goldberg (@rich_goldberg) September 25, 2024
Daniel Greenfield: Biden Admin Promises It Didn’t Help Israel Take Out Marine Barracks Bomber
When Hezbollah suffered a devastating attack around the 40th anniversary of the Islamic terror group’s bombing of the US embassy (the second time), I was hoping we had something to do with it, but I should have known better.
Then Israel took out Hezbollah’s Ibrahim Aqil whom we have a standing $7 million reward on for his role in the Marine Barracks bombing that killed over two hundred Americans and the Biden-Harris admin frantically disavowed the move and is promising that it is not providing Israel with any intel support.
Pentagon spokeswoman Sabrina Singh said that the US is not providing Israel with support in its current conflict with the Hezbollah terrorist organization, including intelligence,
Singh replied “no” when asked by a reporter if the US is providing any form of support to Israel in the Lebanon conflict.
The US military is not providing intelligence support to Israel for its operations in Lebanon, the Pentagon says, adding the United States is making “a full-court press” for a diplomatic solution to the crisis.
Instead, the Biden-Harris regime signed on to a call for a 21-day truce during which Hezbollah will have the time to rearm, regroup and launch more focused attacks on Israel.
This was posted on the Ayatollah’s website.
— Mike Lee (@BasedMikeLee) September 25, 2024
Truly, terrifyingly chilling. pic.twitter.com/VmILkzdIyM
Excellent remarks from Trump about Iran trying to kill him: "No threat will shake me, no enemy will intimidate me, and I have never been more determined than I am today, and I will never back down"
— Ryan Saavedra (@RealSaavedra) September 25, 2024
As president, he says Iran will be blown "to smithereens" if the threats continue pic.twitter.com/Ke3LUSWoDr
“We are being killed…while Iran reaps the benefit of the bloodshed and corpses.”
— The Free Press (@TheFP) September 25, 2024
Lebanese voices, silenced by war and erased by Western media, are speaking out against Hezbollah.@peacecomcenter brings us the truth from Lebanese TV commentator Maryam Majdolen Al-Lahham. “No… pic.twitter.com/ZXbs99idH4
A 𝙢𝙪𝙨𝙩 𝙬𝙖𝙩𝙘𝙝 and a 𝙢𝙪𝙨𝙩 𝙨𝙝𝙖𝙧𝙚@Jonathan_Elk is Lebanese. He’s a wonderful man.
— Kosher🎗🧡 (@K0sher_C0ckney) September 25, 2024
Every word of this.
This is one of the most accurate summaries of what is going on with Hezbollah’s occupation of Lebanon.
pic.twitter.com/tMDc7NVydC
Just a reminder: After the massive explosion in Beirut in 2020 that killed 218 people and injured 7,000, the Tel Aviv municipality illuminated city hall with the Lebanese flag in solidarity with the people of Lebanon.
— Avi Mayer אבי מאיר (@AviMayer) September 25, 2024
Israel’s war is with Hezbollah, not with the Lebanese people. https://t.co/O0FVmSu3BD
Bassem Eid: Hizbullah Doesn't Care about Palestinians as Rocket Strike Shows
Hezbollah, the Shi'ite militia that holds Lebanon hostage, has always been perceived as an outside player in the Arab world for the way it scurries to carry water for its patron, Iran. To counterbalance this, Hezbollah has always tried to portray itself as the foremost defender of the Palestinian cause in opposition to Israel. On Sept. 23, as Hezbollah rockets came crashing down on the West Bank Palestinian town of Deir Istiya, this false friendship was fully revealed as a cynical farce.
After all, this is, unfortunately, a tired old play in the region. The cause of a Palestinian state was adopted by the Arab League (AL) as a cynical ploy from its very origins: in 1945, the year the AL was founded and World War II ended—and more than two years before Israeli independence—the AL declared a boycott on what it termed "Jewish products and manufactured goods." The AL always presented maximalist goals, refusing proposals to split the British Empire's Palestine Mandate between Arabs and Jews and instead opting for all-out war.
This cynicism continued with the schemes of Gamal Abdel Nasser, the Egyptian general who overthrew his country's leader, King Farouk, and established a "United Arab Republic" that gobbled up Syria and Yemen and briefly aimed to create a new great power that would have controlled the geographic space of Israel. While a million Jews expelled from the Arab world and Iran were integrated into the State of Israel, the various Arab states refused to normalize the status of Palestinian arrivals, forcing them to live as stateless persons in permanent "refugee camps."
An interesting sleight-of-hand took place after Israel defeated Nasser's ambitions in the 1967 Six-Day War. Before that conflict, Gaza was integrated as a tiny piece of Nasser's empire. At the same time, the West Bank and East Jerusalem were annexed into Hashemite Jordan, and Syria ruled a small piece of the Galilee with an iron fist. Not one of these countries attempted to give the Palestinians under their control self-rule. Instead, the AL founded the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) at its 1964 Cairo summit, giving it a charter calling for Israel's destruction.
Predictably, this Frankenstein's monster came back to bite the hand that created it, as the PLO attempted to overthrow the Jordanian government in 1970, leading to its expulsion and then destabilizing the formerly functional Republic of Lebanon and sparking its 15-year civil war. The space created by the PLO's former "state within a state" in South Lebanon has now been replaced by Hezbollah and its Iranian advisors.
Even Arab media reports on the abysmal living conditions of Palestinians in Lebanon and the state sanctioned restrictions on their basic rights. Al Jazeera in 2019 article covered the “racist” system in Lebanon against Pals. 2/https://t.co/3vE3O6fjmO pic.twitter.com/npTO3ykTux
— Aizenberg (@Aizenberg55) September 26, 2024
An NPR story described how Palestinians in Lebanon cannot own land and build even where they live. Hezbollah is attacking for on reason: to destroy Israel & kill all Jews as its masters in Iran ordered. END https://t.co/QhM82uqJmF pic.twitter.com/F4nKufZ9Wy
— Aizenberg (@Aizenberg55) September 26, 2024
US leads push for Israel-Lebanon ceasefire, without noting Hezbollah
The United States, Australia, Canada, European Union, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates and Qatar called jointly on Wednesday night for an “immediate 21-day ceasefire across the Lebanon-Israel border to provide space for diplomacy towards the conclusion of a diplomatic settlement.”Israel denies agreeing to U.S., French 21-day cease-fire proposal for Israel-Lebanon border
Minutes before the statement went out, U.S. President Joe Biden and French President Emmanuel Macron stated that “it is time for a settlement on the Israel-Lebanon border that ensures safety and security to enable civilians to return to their homes.”
Neither of the two statements referred to Hezbollah, a U.S.-designated terror group, which has launched thousands of rockets at the Jewish state since Oct. 8. Israel has targeted launch sites and missiles tied to Hezbollah and has not declared war on Lebanon.
In a call with reporters on Wednesday night, a senior U.S. official referred to the proposal as an “important breakthrough.”
“There is no government of Lebanon,” wrote Mark Dubowitz, CEO of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies. “No mention here of Hezbollah or Hamas.”
“Imagine releasing two statements calling for a temporary ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon as if the government of Lebanon has any agency and sovereignty without mention of Hezbollah, which holds the power here,” wrote Jason Brodsky, policy director at United Against Nuclear Iran.
“That’s how disconnected from reality this sounds,” Brodsky wrote.
Kabir Taneja, a fellow at the Observer Research Foundation, wrote that it is “strange that Biden-Macron joint statement on border conflict between Israel and Lebanon fails to clarify the fact that the military exchange taking place is with Hezbollah, not the Lebanese armed forces.”
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s office denied agreeing to a French and American proposal for a 21-day cease-fire on the border with Lebanon, as he was en route to the U.N. General Assembly on Thursday.
Israel has not reached a cease-fire agreement, Netanyahu spokesman Omer Dostri said, calling it “an American-French proposal that the prime minister has not even responded to.”
Dostri also said that reports that Israel was scaling down its strikes in Lebanon are “the opposite of the truth. The prime minister instructed the IDF to continue fighting at full force.”
The Biden administration on Wednesday announced an effort to negotiate a 21-day cease-fire on the Israel-Lebanon border, in the hopes that a short-term agreement will allow time for the parties to reach a long-term deal to end the fighting on Israel’s northern border and allow Israeli and Lebanese civilians to return home.
“The exchange of fire since Oct. 7th, and in particular over the past two weeks, threatens a much broader conflict, and harm to civilians,” President Joe Biden and French President Emmanuel Macron said in a statement on Wednesday night. “We therefore have worked together in recent days on a joint call for a temporary ceasefire to give diplomacy a chance to succeed and avoid further escalations across the border.”
The statement does not mention Hezbollah, the Iran-backed, Lebanon-based terrorist group that has fired approximately 9,300 missiles at Israel since Oct. 8, a day after the Hamas terror attacks killed more than 1,200 people in Israel. Hezbollah has killed 49 Israelis and wounded over 370. The government of Israel evacuated 63,500 people from towns closest to the border and thousands more have left their homes.
The US, France, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and others have published a statement demanding that the governments of Israel and Lebanon accept a ceasefire and “give a real chance to a diplomatic settlement.” What happens now?
— Israeli Citizen Spox (@IsrCitizenSpox) September 26, 2024
In this Daily Briefing, Citizen Spokesman @paulrubens… pic.twitter.com/XORUTzKOse
It’s fascinating the magic wand that Hezbollah and Hamas have that they can carry out a year of war and not be mentioned. This is a system of international language designed to preserve these groups, these “non-state” actors and not hold them accountable and force Israel to… https://t.co/rkcyStwyK0
— Seth Frantzman (@sfrantzman) September 26, 2024
The proposal is a ceasefire consistent with UNSCR 1701. Then the onus is on Biden and Macron to enforce 1701 to get a ceasefire. Now everyone Googles 1701 to discover it mandates Hezbollah be disarmed south of the Litani River, which is Israel’s stated condition for a ceasefire. https://t.co/P81WDBmt4p
— Richard Goldberg (@rich_goldberg) September 26, 2024
Ceasefire with whom?
— Eylon Levy (@EylonALevy) September 26, 2024
How did none of the leaders of 🇺🇸🇦🇺🇨🇦🇪🇺🇫🇷🇩🇪🇮🇹🇯🇵🇸🇦🇦🇪🇶🇦 think, “Huh, why doesn’t this statement say Hezbollah? Shouldn’t we mention it?” pic.twitter.com/WjdtPSqmsr
Biden shuffles to the cameras to lecture Israel that it's time to surrender. He's so pathetic and un-American. https://t.co/iYxwxjqUOd
— Noah Pollak (@NoahPollak) September 26, 2024
The Biden-Harris position on the Israel-Lebanon war is that the Israelis are wrong because they're not taking into account Hezbollah's feelings. I'm not exaggerating or parodying. Seriously. Read this. That's their argument. pic.twitter.com/CLunItx6Zi
— Omri Ceren (@omriceren) September 26, 2024
How is it possible that the joint statement on Lebanon by @POTUS and @EmmanuelMacron doesn’t even mention Hezbollah or Iran? How can you talk about a war without mentioning one of the parties? Is Israel fighting ghosts? pic.twitter.com/Ow77fuUv25
— Eylon Levy (@EylonALevy) September 26, 2024
Macron shaking hands with a man who helped implement policies to pay terrorists and their families if they successfully killed Jewish people.
— Kosher🎗🧡 (@K0sher_C0ckney) September 26, 2024
Also a Holocaust denier and who’s colleague announced in February that the Palestinian Authority is “ready for unity with Hamas” and… https://t.co/NWehPIhMqT
Hezbollah has been shooting rockets at Israel for nearly a year — not a word from you. Tens of thousands of Israelis have been evacuated for months. You don’t care.
— Ezra Levant 🍁🚛 (@ezralevant) September 26, 2024
Now that Israel is finally taking out Hezbollah terrorists and their weapons, you’ve sprung into action. https://t.co/UamHJcMzJY
You had 11 months to demand an immediate ceasefire as soon as Hezbollah started firing indiscriminately at Israel on Oct 8 before Israel even entered Gaza
— Avi Yemini (@OzraeliAvi) September 26, 2024
After 9,000 rockets, Israel finally responds and attracts your condemnation
We get it; anything for Islamist votes https://t.co/VEgs3GSXXC
.@SenatorWong met with & gave a commitment to the @PalestinePMO; a man who recently declared a national day of mourning for a vile international terrorist wanted by the ICC for war crimes
— Menachem Vorchheimer (@MenachemV) September 26, 2024
Why would @SenatorWong engage with someone who stands with terrorists & war criminals ? https://t.co/4teoNQYYUt pic.twitter.com/mHzdCsPAEI
"Where the Americans were prepared to negotiate with Hamas, the Israelis wanted to obliterate it." is really a perfect encapsulation of the cowardly, impotent foreign policy of the Biden admin. How much negotiating did the US do with Al Qaeda after 9/11? https://t.co/B16gTby27T
— Keegan Nazzari (@Keegan_Nazzari) September 25, 2024
Sen. Sanders moves to block $20b in arms sales to Israel
U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) on Wednesday introduced legislation to block arms sales to Israel. The Joint Resolutions of Disapproval would prevent the transfer of more than $20 billion in offensive weapons to Jerusalem. The Senate will vote on the resolutions when lawmakers reconvene in November.
In explaining his rationale for introducing the resolution, Sanders accused Israel’s “extremist government” of waging an “all-out war against the Palestinian people.”
“[Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin] Netanyahu has bombed hospitals and schools, starved children, destroyed infrastructure and housing stock, and made life unlivable in Gaza. The United States must end its complicity in this atrocity,” wrote Sanders, adding that “sending more weapons is not only immoral, it is also illegal.”
Sanders went on to state that “now the world must contend with the dramatic escalation in Lebanon.”
Sen. Peter Welch (D-Vt.) and Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Or.) joined Sanders in introducing the resolutions.
You introduced legislation to block arms sales a day after Hezbollah launched a ballistic missile at Tel Aviv.
— Eyal Yakoby (@EYakoby) September 26, 2024
Make it make sense. https://t.co/Qip6NRaVEx
Um... Israel has killed almost every leader of Hezbollah.
— Kassy Akiva (@KassyAkiva) September 26, 2024
I think they're doing just fine. pic.twitter.com/B2b8NlTzuv
I was in a Hezbollah tunnel – this is what awaits Israel
As I took my first steps into the vast tunnel, stretching from an opening in the Galilee region deep into the bowels of the earth, the air turned sour and dusty.
The tunnel, discovered by Israeli forces and promptly sealed off in 2019, was half a mile long and 260 feet deep – all of it dug with handheld drills by Hezbollah fighters, piece by piece.
Descending the steps into the gloom, past walls dimly lit by glowing electrical cables, it was almost hard to believe that such a colossal tunnel had been dug by a secretive squad, and not industrial excavators.
But the evidence was right in front of me: all over the tunnel walls were cylindrical marks left by the hand drills of the Hezbollah men, who must have spent hundreds if not thousands of hours toiling away in the darkness.
It took several minutes to meander down to the bottom of the tunnel, which ended in a wall of rubble where the IDF had blocked the pathway leading to Lebanon.
It was May 2020 when I toured the tunnel with an Israeli army commander, a time when a full-scale Israeli invasion of Lebanon was only a vague possibility.
But with a possible ground invasion looming, the tunnel offers just a glimpse of the type of enclosed, difficult territory Israeli troops will be facing. It is also just one component of Hezbollah’s vast arsenal, which also includes huge quantities of precision Iranian missiles smuggled into Lebanon via Syria.
Col Roi Yosef Levy, then Israel’s Northern Border brigade commander for the Israel Defense Forces (IDF), said as he showed me around the tunnel. “[It took] 14 years to build and only a few people inside Hezbollah knew about it.”
Had the tunnel not been discovered, Israel suspects it would have been used to launch a surprise assault on the north, perhaps to capture hostages and then take them back to Lebanon.
Hezbollah’s tunnel network is now feared to have grown even more vast and sophisticated in the four years since its discovery, posing a challenge for Israel should it opt for a ground invasion of southern Lebanon.
Israel estimates that the tunnel network, which can be used for hiding shock troops for attacks or moving supplies, stretches for hundreds of kilometres.
Hezbollah recently published footage that showed a truck mounted with rocket launchers passing through long, winding tunnels. The same slick propaganda clip also features Hezbollah troops driving on motorcycles through tunnels surrounding a command centre, Imad 4, passing posters of Hassan Nasrallah, their leader.
Imad 4, a nod to Imad Mughniyeh, the late Hezbollah army chief, is a complex inspired by similar bases in Iran and North Korea, likely built in the Bekaa Valley rather than southern Lebanon.
Nasrallah claims to have started expanding the tunnels in the wake of the 2006 Israel-Lebanon war, and Israel says the tunnels are enmeshed with houses in villages and other communities across southern Lebanon.
The tunnel network remains shrouded in secrecy, something of an unknown quantity in any future war between the two countries. Some Israeli analysts call it the “land of tunnels”, and say they draw inspiration and possibly direct expertise from similar underground networks in Iran, Hezbollah’s main military backer, and North Korea.
Hezbollah doesn’t want you to watch this video.
— Israel Defense Forces (@IDF) September 26, 2024
And they really don’t want you to share it. pic.twitter.com/aN9kE42a2L
By now you know that Hezbollah has been attacking Israel for the last 11 months, but did you know that they’ve also been attacking the entire Western world for the last 40 years? pic.twitter.com/u9Ht1LfYEX
— Israel Defense Forces (@IDF) September 26, 2024
Secondary Explosions = Stored Munitions
— Israel Defense Forces (@IDF) September 25, 2024
It's basic. Secondary explosions occur because we are precisely targeting the munitions of Hezbollah that are aimed at killing our civilians. pic.twitter.com/HvgbEkps2L
Lot of people are talking about Lebanon and Israel.
— Arsen Ostrovsky 🎗️ (@Ostrov_A) September 26, 2024
But many are omitting #Hezbollah - the terrorist party responsible for instigating the situation we find ourselves in today.
🗒️ See this Fact Sheet below, produced by @The_ILF & @MisgavINSen, for more information. pic.twitter.com/vAn05XITjB
We need Hezbollah’s missiles to go away. This is a house THIRTY KILOMETERS from Lebanon hit by Iran’s proxy army. pic.twitter.com/c9oZz5al7F
— Eylon Levy (@EylonALevy) September 26, 2024
The Blue Line marks the Israel-Lebanon border post-2000 IDF withdrawal. Despite UN Resolution 1701 calling for Hezbollah's disarmament, they now hold 150,000 rockets, backed by the Iranian regime. Regular attacks show Hezbollah has crossed the line, costing innocent lives. pic.twitter.com/AGFjTbFUyy
— HonestReporting (@HonestReporting) September 26, 2024
The Israeli border town of Kiryat Shmona has been abandoned for a WHOLE YEAR, since Hezbollah declared war on October 8, 2023. They haven’t even taken their sukkahs down. On the road with Officer Dean Elsdunne👮♂️ #israelunderattack pic.twitter.com/oFf6W6Z8eC
— Eylon Levy (@EylonALevy) September 26, 2024
A barrage of rockets that were fired by Hezbollah from Lebanon landed in the Haifa Bay https://t.co/RtMwS4GOmp pic.twitter.com/2AQrA8jsYH
— Documenting Israel (@DocumentIsrael) September 26, 2024
According to the military, Sarour directed and commanded numerous various aerial attacks on Israel, including explosive-laden drones and cruise missiles.
— Emanuel (Mannie) Fabian (@manniefabian) September 26, 2024
In recent years, the IDF says he led Hezbollah's drone manufacturing, and established sites in Lebanon where the terror group…
Watch Hezbollah commander Muhammad Srour, who was eliminated in an Israeli airstrike in Beirut today, as he trained the Houthis in Yemen to launch drone and missile attacks on Saudi Arabia, according to al-Arabiya. https://t.co/ysYzAIPbdq pic.twitter.com/alURCdmXJU
— Open Source Intel (@Osint613) September 26, 2024
A small Israeli drone reportedly targeted a Hezbollah member in southern Lebanon earlier today. pic.twitter.com/FQJdLv1CQn
— Joe Truzman (@JoeTruzman) September 26, 2024
A Massive Explosion and several Rocket Cook-Offs seen, following an Israeli Airstrike on a Hezbollah Weapons Depot near the Town of Aabbassiyeh, in the Tyre District of Southern Lebanon. pic.twitter.com/WBBdcd0DoY
— OSINTdefender (@sentdefender) September 26, 2024
Watch as the IDF strikes a civilian building in Lebanon used by Hezbollah to store weapons. A missile inside detonates after the strike. Israel warned residents to evacuate, underscoring that it targets terror, not civilians, while Hezbollah hides in civilian areas. pic.twitter.com/Wisz6B4Jj0
— StandWithUs (@StandWithUs) September 26, 2024
Melanie Phillips: Eye-witness to atrocity at Supernova
An important, extraordinary and shattering film started screening this week. Surviving October 7th: We Will Dance Again is about the massacre at the Supernova music festival during the Oct. 7 pogrom in southern Israel.Families of Hamas Hostages Plead For Action At UN Human Rights Council
A preview was shown at the JW3 Jewish community center in London on Tuesday evening; it was subsequently being screened on BBC television and is being streamed on Paramount.
Somewhere over 360 of the approximately 3,500 participants and staff at the festival were murdered and about 40 kidnapped into Gaza, where an unknown number are still being held hostage.
The film stuns because it shows us the events of that terrible day as they unfolded through the eyes of the young festival-goers—and of the Hamas terrorists themselves—through footage taken from phones, Go-Pro cameras and studio interviews with survivors themselves.
We see the secular young Israelis dancing during the Friday night before the attack at what they called a “trance party” (with a disconcerting number of them high on drugs).
We watch with them as dawn rises—and in the sky rise the first rockets from Gaza, which the festival-goers think is just a regular attack that will soon be over. We see their increasing alarm as the rockets keep coming.
We and they hear the shooting start, and they can’t believe what’s happening—disbelief accentuated by the effect of the drugs they’ve taken.
Shockingly, we see what’s unfolding through the Hamas Go-Pro cameras as, deliriously screaming Allahu akbar (“God is great” in Arabic) and about martyrdom, the Gaza stormtroopers smash through the border fence, and ride their motorcycles and vehicles into Israel and the festival. And then we watch as they systematically commit mass slaughter.
We watch the young Israelis being mown down as they run. They film themselves as they confide their terror to their iPhones and desperately chart what’s happening. Through the eyes of Noam, we watch them hide in a garbage bin, which is then raked with bullets, killing her longtime boyfriend, David, and leaving her wounded among a pile of bodies.
We hear the heartbreaking sound of these secular young Israelis crying out the words of the Shema as they realize they are facing their deaths. We see the astounding courage of Aner Shapira, who tosses out, one by one, no fewer than seven grenades thrown by terrorists into the roadside shelter where he is trapped—with a group including his best friend, 23-year-old Israeli-American Hersh Goldberg-Polin, who was subsequently taken hostage and murdered—but is finally killed by the eighth. Another young survivor, Eitan, takes over throwing out the grenades until he passes out after an explosion, only to recover to find himself among a mound of the dead.
Families of Hamas hostages held in Gaza made an emotional plea for their loved ones’ lives before the United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC) on Wednesday.Michael Oren leads delegation of displaced Israelis in northern Israel to Washington
Each speaker detailed the harrowing conditions their family members have endured for almost a year, and called for the release of the 101 remaining hostages in Gaza.
Amit Levy testified about his 20-year-old sister, Naama Levy, who was seen in a viral video from the day of her abduction. The footage shows her bloodied and barefoot, her ankles cut, and with her hands bound behind her back she’s forced into a Jeep. The sight of her bloodstained sweatpants raised fears that she may have been sexually assaulted by Hamas terrorists.
“Every day and hour that passes, her life is in grave danger,” Levy said. “She is held without access to food, water, hygiene, or the personal freedoms she once had.”
Levy shared that his sister was wounded by a grenade on October 7, and his family worries she hasn’t received proper medical care.
“My family and I are deeply worried about her physical and mental well-being, knowing that even someone as strong as Naama cannot remain the same after a year of captivity under constant threat,” he continued. “No one should endure such inhuman suffering, least of all my little sister, who is the kindest person I know.”
In a Hamas bodycam video released in May, Levy was seen with her face bloodied and pleading with terrorists, telling them she has “friends in Palestine.”
Naama Levy is an alumnus of Hands of Peace, an organization that promotes peace between young Israelis and Palestinians.
Shay Dickmann recalled how three generations of her family were caught in the path of Hamas’s massacre in Kibbutz Be’eri.
Shay Dickmann shared her family's tragic story from Hamas’s massacre in Kibbutz Be’eri. She spoke of Carmel Gat who was executed by Hamas after surviving 328 days in Gaza.
— Kassy Akiva (@KassyAkiva) September 25, 2024
"She is dead, but the hope to save lives isn’t dead." pic.twitter.com/8FCIQjqc6p
Michael Oren, the former Israeli ambassador to the U.S., has spent months trying to raise awareness on Capitol Hill about the plight of Israelis who live near the Lebanon border, as their story has gotten far less attention than Israelis in the south hard hit by the Oct. 7 attacks. He brought a delegation of those from the north to meet with lawmakers in June, when the focus was still on Israel’s war against Hamas in Gaza.
But last week, as fighting intensified between Israel and Hezbollah, the delegation he brought to the Hill had a fresh urgency to it, coming just two days after the audacious operation that detonated pagers and walkie-talkies used by Hezbollah members in Lebanon, killing at least 20 people and injuring nearly 3,000, including Iran’s ambassador to Lebanon.
“The objective of the first delegation was to raise awareness. Since then, the situation has deteriorated remarkably,” Oren told Jewish Insider in an interview at the Washington Hilton, on the sidelines of last week’s Israeli American Council national summit, which the delegation also attended.
In the wake of the escalation, he said, the focus of people’s attention has changed “slightly.”
Both trips were organized through the Israel Advocacy Group, which Oren formed after the Oct. 7 terror attacks, in collaboration with the Democratic Majority for Israel and the Republican Jewish Coalition. Since Oct. 7, Hezbollah has bombarded Israel’s north with some 9,000 rockets, missiles and drones.
A group of four Israelis, representing a diverse range of ethnicities and backgrounds, alongside Oren, spent all day Friday meeting with Congress and the Biden administration. The packed day started with breakfast and a panel with ambassadors of Italy, Germany, Spain, United Arab Emirates, Estonia, Austria and Norway, as well as State Department officials, organized by the American Jewish Committee.
The delegation members were: Liat Cohen Raviv and her 23-year-old daughter, Doron Cohen, both residents of Metula, a town of about 2,500 people that abuts the Israel-Lebanon border and has been almost entirely evacuated; Samer Atallah, a member of the Druze community of Yarka, near Majdal Shams; and Nitsan Daniel, from Kibbutz Kfar Szold, located about three miles from the Lebanese border. The delegation met with senior White House advisors, Sens. Ted Cruz (R-TX), Rick Scott (R-FL) and Lindsey Graham (R-SC), as well as Reps. Nikki Budzinski (D-IL), Glenn Ivey (D-MD), Ritchie Torres (D-NY), Lucy McBath (D-GA), Brian Mast (R-FL), Jared Moskowitz (D-FL), Brad Schneider (D-IL), Don Davis (D-NC), Lois Frankel (D-FL), Jared Golden (D-ME) and Grace Meng (D-NY).
Israel has true allies in the the United States Congress. Thank you to the Senators and Representatives who met with our delegation of northern Israel residents and assured us that they stand with Israel as it defends itself from Hezbollah’s relentless aggression 🇮🇱🇺🇸
— Michael Oren (@DrMichaelOren) September 25, 2024
ישראל זוכה… pic.twitter.com/QIFcNKdAIm
One of the most harrowing recordings from October 7th is of a nine-year-old girl on Kibbutz Be'eri.
— Hen Mazzig (@HenMazzig) September 26, 2024
A police dispatcher listened as she pleaded with Hamas men who had captured her, telling them she was just a child and that she had school to attend the next day.
The operator… pic.twitter.com/yhctuRNFvK
“Every day that passed it became more and more difficult.”
— Israel War Room (@IsraelWarRoom) September 26, 2024
-Margalit Moses
101 Israelis are still held by Hamas. We’re continuing to share reminders of what hostages went through — and what some of them continue to experience. pic.twitter.com/zHkQRWUnWR
This Is What Iran May Be Planning | Israel Undiplomatic w/ Mark Regev & Ruthie Blum
Israelis in cities across the country's central region woke up early Wednesday morning to air-raid sirens warning of incoming terrorist missiles fired by Iran-backed Hezbollah from Lebanon.
The attack comes after a series of major Israel Defense Forces victories over the past week.
Tune in to "Israel Undiplomatic" for a complete assessment of what has been happening and how things may unfold between Israel, Hezbollah and the Islamic Republic of Iran.
Chapters
0:00 Sirens in Tel Aviv
5:00 Analysis
9:00 The larger picture
10:30 How does Iran fit the picture?
14:00 Escalation going forward
26:00 Intelligence on Oct 7
27:00 Panetta pans Israel
The Quad: Beepers, Bombs and the Blame Game - Unpacking Israel’s War With Hezbollah
This week on "The Quad," Fleur Hassan-Nahoum and co-host Shoshanna Keats Jaskoll, as well as guest hosts Aviva Klompas and Shirel Liberman, unpack the alleged Israeli beeper operations and recent targeted strikes against Hezbollah. It seems as if no matter what Israel does to limit civilian casualties, it will always be blamed, they conclude.
"The Quad" also interviews British-Israeli analyst Jonathan Spyers, head of research at the Middle East Forum, on why Hezbollah joined the war in support of Hamas on Oct. 8 and its end game.
And, of course, they reveal the Scumbags and Heroes of the Week!
Chapters
00:00 Introduction
01:54 Media perception
05:15 Israel's response to Hezbollah
07:44 Israeli humanitarian efforts in Syria
12:55 Iran's influence in the region
20:28 Hezbollah's miscalculations
23:40 Iran's strategic calculations
28:46 Role of Sunni Arab states
31:34 Jordan's complicity in smuggling
34:22 Future prospects
35:19 Scumbags and Heroes of the Week
People always say that Israel has a right to defend itself, and when they do, they object to it. pic.twitter.com/w7YiWEkGZu
— Bill Maher (@billmaher) September 26, 2024
Here is my speech at the UN this evening. pic.twitter.com/KWXRnOdEql
— Andrew Fox (@Mr_Andrew_Fox) September 26, 2024
This is one of the most incredible monologues I’ve seen yet, again from @SkyNewsAust and this time Chris Kenny.
— Cheryl E 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🎗️ (@CherylWroteIt) September 25, 2024
Just fantastic stuff.
H/T @sirwg202110 pic.twitter.com/jIqX8eX3fS
While most of the world’s media attacks Israel, a brave Sky News Australia anchor, Erin Molan, gave an incredible speech on her show about the hypocrisy both in Australia and around the world against Israel! pic.twitter.com/L5p6hW4E2y
— יוסף חדאד - Yoseph Haddad (@YosephHaddad) September 26, 2024
Learn your history!
— Brigitte Gabriel (@ACTBrigitte) September 25, 2024
The Palestinians have been slaughtering Christians and Jews in the most heinous ways for DECADES, including in 1976 in my home country of Lebanon.
This is the truth everyone must understand. pic.twitter.com/7Gq1BFqVp6
As it should.
— Senator John Fetterman (@SenFettermanPA) September 26, 2024
Immediately after 10/7, I strongly affirmed supporting any assistance—financial, military or intelligence—without conditions, in Israel’s war against terrorists.
And never forget to #BringThemHomeNOW pic.twitter.com/qhHVe0dnri
Watch: Senator Fetterman gets harassed by a Hezbollah supporter at the airport, Fetterman's response?
— Eyal Yakoby (@EYakoby) September 26, 2024
"So weird dude."
We need more leaders like Fetterman, who will not be intimidated by the terror mob. pic.twitter.com/PnJLZqzFfJ
Whenever you are confronted by bullies, fight back. No amount of harassment and intimidation from useful idiots like CodePink will dissuade me from defending Israel’s right to defend itself.
— Ritchie Torres (@RitchieTorres) September 26, 2024
Israel has every right to defend its people against the world’s most heavily armed… pic.twitter.com/ZNsAholU91
Piers: “A WAR CRIME By All Means” Israel vs Hezbollah Debate Feat Elica Le Bon & Aaron Maté
Israel’s military carried out a series of bombings against its northern neighbour of Lebanon yesterday; bombings that have been condemned by many, but surprising to no one. Israel have claimed the strikes were targeting Hezbollah but once again, scores of innocent civilians are now dead; including children. Officials around the world openly worry that this next step could trigger a full-blown regional war.
With so much on the line, and so much history to comb through, Piers Morgan creates a dialogue between stakeholders on each side. First he talks to Lebanese Ambassador to the UK Rami Mortada for his official position. Then the debate begins with British-Iranian attorney Elica Le Bon, pro-Palestinian activist Aaron Maté, Special Envoy for the Foreign Ministry of Israel and host of 'The Quad' on JNS Fleur Hasan and pro-Palestine commentator Wajahat Ali.
00:00 - Introduction
01:00 - How close is the Middle East to regional war?
03:30 - Remi Mortada says Hezbollah does not want a full scale war
07:30 - "Nothing justifies killing civilians"
11:30 - Can you condemn both Hezbollah and Israel?
15:00 - Is it sensible of Israel to consider another ground war?
22:30 - Who started this war?
28:00 - The actions of Hezbollah since October 7th
35:00 - How violence breeds violence
45:00 - Netanyahu's hold over Israel
48:30 - The threat of Hamas
52:00 - The future of the Middle East
F*ck. Give this a watch and a share @elicalebon just did one of the biggest Mic drops on the Israel / Hezbollah conflict
— Kosher🎗🧡 (@K0sher_C0ckney) September 25, 2024
Straight facts. Every word.
pic.twitter.com/8OWyKghhDI
A retraction must be immediately issued. Denial of clear and convincing evidence of sexual violence by jihadists is completely unacceptable. @aaronjmate pic.twitter.com/9o7cuCisII
— Elica Le Bon الیکا ل بن (@elicalebon) September 26, 2024
The Israel Guys: Will Israel INVADE & RETAKE southern Lebanon as a Buffer Zone?
Will Israel INVADE & RETAKE southern Lebanon as a Buffer Zone? Well they’ve done it before! There's enough Iranian terrorists there to drive any sovereign nation to declare a buffer zone! One thing you should know is that Israel has been at war with Lebanon since 1948. Lebanon was then and remains now hostile to Israel's existence, nothing’s changed. Israel's northern towns have lived in constant threat from these brutes since Israel's founding! It’s high time to remove the northern threats and create a permanent buffer zone held by none other than Hezbollah's most feared and hated enemy… the Israeli settlers!
The Israel Guys: UNBELIEVABLE: Pope Called For Israel to Do What?
Israel just started Operations Northern Arrows and is now working around the clock to erase the terrorist organization of Hezbollah from the face of the earth. You would think that the world would be happy that Israel is destroying evil right? Well unfortunately not. 12 countries are now calling for a ceasefire between Israel and Lebanon, yes, they’re saying Lebanon and not Hezbollah, as if Israel was at war with Lebanon!
Great. She’s absolutely right about Ukraine.
— Arsen Ostrovsky 🎗️ (@Ostrov_A) September 26, 2024
Now say that about Israel, which continues to be under relentless attacks from Hezbollah in the north and Hamas from Gaza. https://t.co/4F3kyWnOnA
Open support for Hezbollah by @OsamaAbuirshaid, national director of @AMPalestine. Israel's retaliation against Hezbollah after a year of 10,000 rockets shot at its country & displacing 80,000+ civilians has removed even the pretext of civility from the usual actors. pic.twitter.com/vTOPKtP73W
— Canary Mission (@canarymission) September 25, 2024
Antifa blog "Scenes from the Atlanta Forest" has published a post calling for Israelis abroad to be killed. The Israelis are compared to Nazis during the holocaust.
— Andy Ngo 🏳️🌈 (@MrAndyNgo) September 26, 2024
The post urges comrades to hunt them down and kill them.
The violent extremist blog is the main propaganda outlet… pic.twitter.com/vHvFKV9GIZ
Immediately granted bail
— Australian Jewish Association (@AustralianJA) September 26, 2024
A man has been charged with multiple counts of damaging property after pro-Palestinian slogans were spray-painted onto the Australian War Memorial (AWM) and ABC Canberra buildings earlier this year.
Multiple memorial sites in Canberra were defaced with… pic.twitter.com/U0DfJhqoj8
Based UAE 🇦🇪 https://t.co/bPkEeR9xEY
— Jay Asliken 🕋☪️✈️ (@assliken) September 26, 2024
Buy the EoZ book, PROTOCOLS: Exposing Modern Antisemitism today at Amazon! Or order from your favorite bookseller, using ISBN 9798985708424. Read all about it here! |
|