
Tuesday, November 28, 2023
Tuesday, November 28, 2023
Elder of Ziyon
NPR's Ailsa Chang spoke with Liz Cathcart, executive director of the non-profit Hostage U.S., about "what life can be like for hostages once they’re free."
Clueless doesn't begin to describe this interview.
I'm sure that Cathcart is an earnest person who deals with Americans who are held hostage abroad for various reasons. But she clearly doesn't know anything about what the Israeli hostages went through.
She says things like "The best story of hope that we can give is that the vast majority of cases that we deal with and with a family who is whole again, who recognizes that they went through an incredibly traumatic experience and they are built stronger and have learned coping mechanisms that they can apply to many different scenarios in their lives."
The hostage families are not whole again. Most of them have family members who were murdered. Some of them witnessed the murder or rape of their loved ones or friends. Certainly all of them lost friends and neighbors. Many have husbands or fathers still in captivity. They are not living in their own homes and won't be for months, and many homes were destroyed. The trauma is not just for the hostages themselves but for the other surviving members of their families, and for their entire communities who have lost so many.
Chang and Cathcart use a tone of voice indicating how much they care, but they couldn't be bothered to do even a modicum of research. They don't care. They just thought this would be a good segment, and pretending to care is what they need to do for their audience.
The entire segment is an advertisement for Hostage US. The "advice" given is utterly useless in helping any Israeli hostage who was released, and it is tone deaf about what they went through. It trivializes the real trauma that they are continuing to go through and instead it recommends vacuous kumbaya cheerleading.

Related Posts:
Palestinian Arabs keep getting killed in Syria, and no one caresI noted that the death toll of Syrian Palestinians had gone over 1000 last month. Things have, if anything, accelerated since then. On Sunday and Monday, six more were killed. On Tuesday, nine were killed - including five m… Read More
Ma'an acts as mouthpiece for Jew-hating Al Aqsa FoundationMa'an, which strives to appear like it maintains good journalistic standards in English, has an Arabic article today that shows again that it reports things differently to different audiences. The artiicle is about the Bi… Read More
Friday Links Part 2From Ian: Daniel Pipes: Obama to Palestinians: Accept the Jewish state One key shift in U.S. policy was overlooked in the barrage of news about U.S. President Barack Obama's eventful fifty-hour visit to Israel last week. Th… Read More
From Egypt to the IDFThe IDF blog has a really great story: Dina recalls how she tried to find herself among the troubling mix of religions. “We had a mosque next to the school, and the girls would go there to pray. I told this to my mother,… Read More
Friday Links Part 1From Ian: Britons in aid convoy kidnapped and sexually assaulted in Libya Three women who were part of an aid convoy passing through Libya on the way to Gaza have been sexually assaulted in Benghazi, after a group of five B… Read More