The nominees should be prominent non-Muslims who have accepted and embraced their second-class status in a Muslim-dominated world.
A couple of likely nominees would be:
Iranian Jewish leaders Maurice Mo'atamad and Ciamak Morsathegh
Rev. Manuel Musallem
Bishop Tiny Muskens (and if you follow that link, enjoy the irony of this one)
Who else?
UPDATE: I see that Jihad Watch has two similar awards, but I think there is room for more.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/db604/db6040395bf182030f7b3256c75a436a86ae9a2e" alt=""