To those who claim Israel doesn't care about Palestinian lives

I was upset when I saw Brant Rosen, a Reconstructionist-ordained anti-Zionist rabbi, suggest that Jews should say Psalms for Israeli war crimes in Gaza.

One prayerful Jewish response to the war crimes Israel is committing in #Gaza https://t.co/bFq6gnllWg

— Brant Rosen (@RabbiBrant) November 13, 2019

Sickeningly, this was retweeted by the Reconstructionist Rabbinical Association.

I responded:

I challenge you to show me a SINGLE war crime under international law that Israel has committed in Gaza since Monday, @rabbibrant.

Israel's allowed to attack military targets. Israel's allowed to kill terrorists while minimizing civilian deaths. So what are the crimes? https://t.co/YQYD742YNz

— Elder Of Ziyon ҉ (@elderofziyon) November 13, 2019

Meanwhile, I can name some Jewish laws you are violating.

Loshon hora.
Diba.
Chilul Hashem.
Not being dan l'chaf zechut.
Lifnei Iver.

— Elder Of Ziyon  ҉ (@elderofziyon) November 13, 2019

He didn't respond.

A day later I tweeted out two articles (Distinction and Proportionality) I wrote in 2014 about Gaza and international law, pointing out that people who claim Israel is guilty of war crimes simply do not know a thing about international law. I tagged Rosen.

He responded, instead of answering my question, by trying to ask me a "gotcha" question:

Prove to me that the Israeli military tries to “minimize casualties.”

— Brant Rosen (@RabbiBrant) November 14, 2019

Well, that's easy! I responded immediately:

Leaflets? Phone calls? Comparison with civilian/militant ratio in any similar conflicts in history in urban areas? Reading Israel's MAG reports? Testimony of hundreds of IDF soldiers?

Are you that completely clueless? Or is it on purpose that you don't educate yourself?

— Elder Of Ziyon ҉ (@elderofziyon) November 14, 2019

I didn't even mention roof knocking, or that  US military brass come to Israel to learn how to minimize casualties, or the reports from major military figures worldwide that assert that no one does more than Israel to minimize civilian casualties. 

People like Brant Rosen use Electronic Intifada as their Torah and Philip Weiss as their prophet. For someone to call himself a rabbi and yet revel in his ignorance about a conflict that he spends so much time opining on is mind blowing.

The mentality of Jewish haters of Israel could fill a psychology textbook.

---

---

We have lots of ideas, but we need more resources to be even more effective. Please donate today to help get the message out and to help defend Israel.