Antisemitism should be spelled
without the hyphen. It’s something I’ve known for years, even if auto-correct
just won’t get the message. Neither will the media, of course, or even most
dictionaries.
“What’s the difference?” you
might well ask. “It’s just a little mark on the page. Meaningless.”
Ah, but it’s not.
The concept of “antisemitism”
(without the dash, thank you) and the term, were introduced by Wilhelm Marr when
he founded the DieAntisemitenliga, the League of
Antisemites, in 1879. Materials put out by the league often employed the word “antisemitism.”
The league, in fact, was the first popular political movement based solely on
anti-Jewish sentiment. Marr’s famous and oft-reprinted tract, The Victory of Judaism Over Germandom, made
the claim that “the
Jewish spirit and Jewish consciousness have overpowered the world.”
Statutes of the Antisemitism League flanked by two of Marr's antisemitic tracts
Marr wore the title “antisemite”
as a badge of honor. From the perspective of Marr and his colleagues, to be an
antisemite was to be “woke.” But then, politics with a specifically anti-Jewish
flavor and focus were big all over Europe in the years leading up to the 20th
century.
The word “antisemitism” had its
roots in an 18th-century treatise on languages which analyzed the
differences between Aryan and Semitic languages. The terminology that was used
led to the false assumption that there were racial groups corresponding to
these two groups of languages. The minds of the time made a leap so that “Jew”
became synonymous with “semite” in the lexicon of the day.
The interesting thing here is
that there was already the perfectly good expression Judenhass, or “Jew hate,” in the popular lexicon. But Marr wanted
to make his hatred about race, rather than religion. The new term he coined
avoided altogether the question of religion. “Antisemitism” also sounded more
scientific, more intellectual, therefore more credible and more acceptable. Also,
people just liked it. So the word “antisemitismus”
spread like wildfire as a new way to speak about hating the Jews.
But the thing is, there’s no such
thing as a “semite” or even a “semitic” people. The terms were invented by some
historians in the 1770s
to refer to people who speak Semitic languages But in truth, there are onlySemitic languages. There
is no race or people that are “semites.”
In other words, when you spell
the word with a hyphen, the word makes no sense. Because you can’t be against
something that doesn’t exist. And there’s no such thing as a semite.
The other problem is that
people say that Arabs are semites, too, therefore Arabs can’t be antisemites,
because they can’t be against themselves.
Except there’s no such thing as
a semite.
The term antisemite, you see,
is standalone. It only means “someone who hates Jews.” And that is all it was
ever intended to mean.
Antisemitism, as a term, is based on racist claptrap. The word was lifted from the field of linguistics to give
weight to the idea of hating the Jews (and only the Jews) as a race (which they
aren’t). The pseudoscientific sound of the term gave it loft and validity.
Which is stupid.
To be clear: Jews aren’t
semites. Neither are Arabs.
Antisemites hate Jews, not
Arabs.
So when you use the hyphen you’re
unwittingly espousing turn of the century European racism. You’re also ignorant
of history. If Marr had meant to include Arabs he would have spelled the word
he invented with a hyphen to include them.
Historians, at least those who care
about academic rigor, are careful to spell the word without the hyphen. But the media
continues to hyphenate the word. And spell-check and the auto-correct function
of Word just won’t get the message. Historian Shmuel Almog, in
fact, wrote about the problem
with the hyphen all the way back in 1989:
“So the hyphen, or rather its omission, conveys a message; if
you hyphenate your 'anti-Semitism', you attach some credence to the very
foundation on which the whole thing rests. Strike out the hyphen and you will
treat antisemitism for what it really is—a generic name for modern Jew-hatred
which now embraces this phenomenon as a whole, past, present and—I am
afraid—future as well.”
We have lots of ideas, but we need more resources to be even more effective. Please donate today to help get the message out and to help defend Israel.
This blog may be a labor of love for me, but it takes a lot of effort, time and money. For 20 years and 40,000 articles I have been providing accurate, original news that would have remained unnoticed. I've written hundreds of scoops and sometimes my reporting ends up making a real difference. I appreciate any donations you can give to keep this blog going.
The Surrender to Hamas Deal
-
*"And a new king arose over Egypt who did not know Joseph." Exodus 1:8*
Every country fights Islamic terrorism alone. What should have been a world
war...
Are we There Yet?
-
[image: Dry Bones cartoon, Israel, Hostages, Shuldig, Gaza, Hamas, War,
Oct7,]
Has Israel been Trumped?
* * * Please support DRY BONES (through PayPal or y...
Chief Rabbi of Turkey passes away
-
The Haham Bashi or Chief Rabbi of Turkey, Isak Haleva, has died aged 85.
Haleva served as chief rabbi since 2002 in an increrasingly hostile climate
fo...
Steve Kramer: Eternal Refugee Status? – No problem
-
Steve Kramer: Eternal Refugee Status? – No problem IsraelSeen.com
Steve Kramer: Eternal Refugee Status? – No problem In addition to the many
news sources I...
The BBC apology should be absolutely rejected
-
Last week I ran an exclusive which exposed blatant antisemitism in a live
BBC News interview with a Jerusalem based Rabbi. When faced with the
undeniable...
Jewish "settlers" in 1932, in Russia
-
Mr. Medad, are Jews in their historic national homeland termed "settlers"?
That's the language everyone now uses. In the London Times of August 20,
1932, ...
Just in time for Chanukah – 4 interesting new books
-
He’s An Anti-Zionist Too!: Cartoons by Elder of Ziyon The Elder of Ziyon
(EoZ) is one of the most important pro-Israel bloggers. You can read my
interview ...
Hamas/Gaza War Musings #36- Dangerous Surrender!
-
As a student of the Bible/Tanach, most recently Prophets/Navi, that's the
message. Gd will save us if we do the right thing. That's how we won the
1967...
One Choice: Fight to Win
-
Yesterday Israel preempted a potentially disastrous attack by Hezbollah on
the center of the country. Thirty minutes before launch time, our aircraft
destr...
Closing Jews Down Under Website
-
With a heavyish heart I am closing down the website after ten years.
It is and it isn’t an easy decision after 10 years of constant work. The
past...
‘Test & Trace’ is a mirage
-
Lockdown II thoughts: Day 1 Opposition politicians have been banging on
about the need for a ‘working’ Test & Trace system even more loudly than
the govern...