
Monday, October 29, 2018
Monday, October 29, 2018
Elder of Ziyon
This article from 1934 brings on a sense of deja vu:
We have lots of ideas, but we need more resources to be even more effective. Please donate today to help get the message out and to help defend Israel.
Just like today, people were lecturing the Jews on how they need to act for their own good. If they act at all like a proud people who stand up to their enemies, then the enemies will get upset and it will be the Jews' fault.
It was all out of "love," though. Professor Cadbury had no doubt that he loved the Jewish people and only wanted the best for them. If only the Jews would listen to his sage advice, the Nazis would realize that they are making some innocent mistakes and will change their ways to good.
And if Israel would only make a few more concessions to the Palestinians, then they would suddenly become peaceful people and not demand anything more.
Even though - for those willing to listen to them in their own languages - both the Nazi and Palestinian leaders say quite explicitly that they don't want compromise; they want total victory over their "oppressors."
I hate to draw analogies with Nazis, but this article sound exactly like so many op-eds and international diplomats today lecturing Israel on how to be more peaceful in the face of genocidal intentions.
The analogy doesn't end there. The liberal Jews of the Reform Movement who hosted Cadbury were very sympathetic to his message.
Just like today, liberal Jews are more willing to listen to the messages of their "friends" who rail against Israeli policies than to most Israelis themselves.
(h/t Bill Poser)

Related Posts:
Warriors of the Mind (Forest Rain) They came one by one, sometimes in pairs. Quietly they entered the auditorium. Unassuming people, you might not notice if you passed in the street. No external factors could alert you to the fact that these are elite w… Read More
A new market in Gaza made out of mud bricksIn 2010, I reported on an actually useful UNRWA program to build houses out of bricks made with local materials. This way, houses (apparently only single story) could be built without worries about importing materials t… Read More
Sarah Tuttle-Singer and the "Palestinian Narrative" (Michael Lumish) I find the Jewish Indigeneity Question fascinating. I recently published an article thanking native American thinker and activist, Ryan Bellerose for advancing the importance of Israel to the … Read More
Hamas closed any NGO in Gaza with the words "peace" or "coexistence" in its nameA single phrase in an article on the thousands of NGOs in the territories, written for the Islamic Jihad mouthpiece Palestine Today, is pretty telling: While Hamas in Gaza was closing down any institution with the titles "co… Read More
03/18 Links: Netanyahu warns donors Gaza their aid money is being ‘buried’ in tunnels; Security guard severely wounded in stabbing attack in Jerusalem’s Old CityFrom Ian: IDF Blog: IDF Thwarts Hamas Attempt to Renew Old Terror Tunnel Last night, March 17, the IDF thwarted an attempt by Hamas to renew an old terror tunnel directed towards the Kerem Shalom crossing in southern Israel. … Read More