Monday, March 20, 2023
Elder of Ziyon
Ibrahim Abrash, writing in Palestinian news site Amad, says that Bezalel Smotrich is ignoring the Jewish Scripture when he says there were no such thing as the Palestinian people.
Because look at the many times that the Torah mentions Philistines and the Land of the Philistines!
It's been a while since Palestinians claimed to be Philistines. It was a common claim at the UN in the 1940s, when the Syrian representative stated, "The Palestinian Arabs are the descendants of
the same inhabitants of that country of forty
centuries ago who fought in the first campaign
which the Jews waged against Palestine in the
fifteenth century before Christ. In the Bible,
they are called the Philistines. After about the
thirteenth century, they adopted the Arabic language, which was later replaced by the Syrian
language, a language closely related to the former. These people have not changed. They are
the same people who were living there then.
They have been there for forty centuries--since
prehistoric times."
(Note his backhanded way of saying that Palestine is really a part of Greater Syria.)
The claim that Palestinians were Syrians became less popular as the term "philistine" in English is equated with narrow-mindedness and being uncultured.
The obvious next move was for Palestinians to claim to be Canaanites, because that way they can say that the Jews ethically cleansed them twice, and Canaanites were definitely in the bulk of the Land of Israel before the Jews.
But when Jerusalem became an issue, Palestinians suddenly became Jebusites, a people who have no independent known history outside the Torah. But they lived around Jerusalem, so therefore Palestinians must have been Jebusites.
Of course, the same Bible that says Jebusites existed says that they legally sold Jerusalem to King David.
Notice that there is never the slightest bit of historical, scientific, linguistic or cultural evidence for these contradictory and supposedly unbroken histories of Palestinians.
So now we are back to Philistines, since that is the most convenient lie for the current threat.
Any lie will do, as long as they counter Jews' claims.
Which reminds me of a recent comic of mine:
