
Tuesday, July 19, 2022
Tuesday, July 19, 2022
Elder of Ziyon
2017, antisemitism, Arabi21, Electronic Intifada, history, Jews, Joseph Massad, Khazar, Khazar libel, logical fallacy, revisionist history
We've discussed Columbia University professor Joseph Massad before and noted his antisemitism and bigotry since this blog began in 2004.
In an article for Arabi21, Massad strongly indicates that he subscribes to the discredited Khazar theory. While it is not the main point of his article, he writes, "The Zionists of European Jews claimed that they are the descendants of the ancient Palestinian Hebrews and that their settlement project is nothing more than a 'return' to their ancient country, Israel....The pan-Jewish nationalism of European Zionism, which sought to re-establish the glories of the 'Jewish' kingdoms of the Palestinian Hebrews (who were appropriated by the Zionists as ancestors of Europeans who had converted to Judaism), was portrayed as 'progressive' and socialist."
This is similar to what he wrote in English for Electronic Intifada in 2017, saying that European Jews were converts to Judaism.
The Wikipedia entry on the genetics of Ashkenazic Jews shows that nearly all studies find their origin is in the Middle East. So Massad, in the 2017 article, makes his argument that most European Jews as converts by calling it "an established historical fact."
That is "proof by assertion."
The usual version of the theory that Jews are converts is the Khazar theory, which has also been repeatedly debunked from genetic, historical, linguistic and other perspectives. It is embraced by Palestinians because their entire claim of indigeneity is destroyed when another people were there first and most Palestinian Arab families proudly trace their ancestry to Arabia. (The Palestinian Christians, on the other hand, seem to be descended from Jews.)
Since the truth is not on their side, they need to push the Khazar lie. And that lie is meant to say that Jews don't have any historic ties to the Jewish homeland.
Denying Jewish history is just as antisemitic as denying the Holocaust.

Related Posts:
Iran upset when Muslims admit the Holocaust happened (update)Iran's Ahl al-Bayt News Agency (ABNA), a Shiite news site whose views mimic that of Iran's leadership, reports that Saudi authorities designated Muhammad bin Abdul-Karim al-Issa, Secretary-General of the Muslim World Lea… Read More
A brief Twitter thread on anti-Zionism and antisemitismA follower of mine from Brazil asked me a question on Twitter:Good morning, Sr. Elder of Ziyon. I'm from Brazil and could you tell why does Palestine hate Israel? In Brazil, all history teachers love Palestine and hate Israel… Read More
Lapid's speechHere is the text of Yair Lapid's first speech as new Israeli prime minister. It is a good one.I want to start by thanking the 13th Prime Minister of the State of Israel, Naftali Bennett. For your decency, for your friendship … Read More
Palestinians hold a conference where they claim to be Canaanites (update) On Saturday a "Palestinian Canaanite Conference" was held in the Mahmoud Darwish Museum in Ramallah. At the conference, Palestinian prime minister Mohamed Shtayyeh claimed that the Palestinians are descendants of the… Read More
Survey: US Jews are not Islamophobic - but 26% of Muslims themselves are!The Institute for Social Policy and Understanding has released its 2022 survey on Muslims in America. The survey shows that Jews are the one faith group that is most tolerant towards Muslims. Even more than Muslims … Read More