Former Israeli Hostage: "If Hamas Continues to Live in Gaza, We Will Not Live Here"
Avinatan Or, who was kidnapped on Oct. 7, 2023, and released after more than two years in Hamas captivity, told the Israel Hayom Summit on Nov. 11 about life inside a Gaza tunnel. "In darkness, the brain goes into survival mode. You can no longer see anything, and your other senses become sharper. Smells grow stronger, sounds become more distinct. When you want to survive and you have nothing, you will do anything to find something, something to hold on to, something to believe in, something that gives you hope."Antisemitism Made a Zionist of Me
"In captivity, I could see no reality other than what our captors chose to show me. They decided what I would see, what I would hear, what I would smell and what I would know. They took away my freedom in every sense except one: In the darkness of the tunnel, I refused to surrender my freedom to choose. The freedom to choose how to respond to the reality forced upon me. Every morning and every evening, even when I could no longer tell them apart, I held on to that freedom. It was my responsibility to choose how I would live my life each day."
"A few days before I was freed, Abu Hassan, one of the Hamas terrorists, entered my cell and told me, 'As long as the State of Israel exists, this war between Israel and Hamas will never end.' That conversation made it absolutely clear to me who we are facing and what Hamas is really about. They have only one goal: the destruction of the State of Israel."
"I heard their ideology, I saw their plans, I tasted their hatred. I experienced what war really is....That is precisely why this war must end with only one outcome. Our mission is to ensure that an enemy whose entire existence is devoted to spreading death cannot live alongside us. Because if they live there, we will not live here. We must complete the mission and destroy Hamas."
Opponents of Israel have turned into a threat to the American ideal of religious pluralism and tolerance. Four Yeshiva school buses in Brooklyn were spray-painted with swastikas and the slogans "Free Palestine," "F--- Israel" and "America First" on Nov. 2. The vandals brought their quarrel with Israel to the school buses of American children simply because they were Jewish.How I Chose Sides on Israel
On Oct. 29, Mohamed Sabry Soliman pleaded guilty to hate crimes after setting Jews on fire in Colorado in June 2025. He attacked Jews who were calling for Hamas to release Israeli captives. He killed an 82-year-old woman and wounded 12 others. He announced after his arrest that he wanted "to kill all Zionist people" and "would do it again."
The incidents are piling up. I am a Zionist because on the ground, activist anti-Zionism is becoming indistinguishable from antisemitism. Cody Allen Balmer claimed anti-Zionism as his motive for setting fire to the Pennsylvania governor's mansion in 2025 when he attacked a Jewish governor and his family.
I've always generally supported Israel, beginning with the strategic reason that Israel is an ally in a region in which the U.S. has national interests. For that matter, I've supported Israel because my Christian faith seems to require it. Jews, as Pope John Paul II noted, are our elder brothers, and the safety of God's covenant people currently requires the existence of a Jewish state.
Does anyone believe that if Israel surrendered today to Hamas, Hizbullah and Iran, the Jews in a new Palestine, running from the river to the sea, wouldn't be slaughtered? Israel is an outpost of Western inheritance, facing enemies who are hostile to the West itself. First the Jews, then the Christians.
From that old support I have come to full-blown Zionism - because that is the most coherent way to oppose the activists who aim at something profoundly antithetical to the American spirit. As long as we have a social politics in which antisemitism wears the cloak of anti-Zionism, the duty of Americans is clear: When Jews are targeted as Jews, the solidarity the moment requires from the rest of us is standing up as Zionists.
Seven months before October 7, I knew embarrassingly little about Israel. Today, I consider myself one of its most committed defenders.
After watching another American election in which our relationship with Israel became a political liability, it’s important to remind myself that my convictions aren’t determined by election returns. In fact, it’s exactly when my political positions become inconvenient that I must remember why I hold them in the first place.
In February 2023, I was invited on a ten-day trip to Israel through an organization called Passages, whose mission is to “bring a new generation of Christian leaders to Israel to deepen their faith, forge lasting bonds with the Jewish people and return home equipped to strengthen America.” To be transparent: as a Catholic convert of nine years at the time, I was focused on this trip from my own faith’s perspective. We were scheduled to arrive on October 22.
I vowed to learn as much as I could about Israel before my trip. So, I started reading. What began as trip preparation quickly became something much more meaningful. I sought out the land but found its people.
Centuries—millennia—of persecution, exile, and repeated attempts at annihilation, countered by unrelenting endurance and determination to preserve their faith, traditions, and identity, have resulted in a modern people that is the envy of the world: Israel has the highest fertility rate of any OECD country and is a global leader in technological innovation, spending more on R&D per GDP than any OECD country.
I wasn’t studying with blinders on, though. No country is perfect, and I don’t vow blanket support for Israel’s government. But I could say the same about America. Instead, I developed a genuine affection for a people and its story. While my history lesson should have tipped me off, I still couldn’t imagine so many people in my own country (and around the world) developing such a violent hatred toward them.
Then October 7 happened, and my trip was canceled. While I struggled to comprehend the brutality, I was astonished by something else: the reaction. Some Americans were already finding ways to rationalize the murder before many Israeli families had even learned the fate of their loved ones. It wasn’t just the celebration from some of the usual bad actors, but the refusal of others to condemn it that shocked me.
That response began to shape my understanding of a debate that has consumed me for the last three years. With my opinions (and dare I say, morals) intact, I began listening less to what people were saying and more to who was saying it.
I recalled a lesson from my parents: you can tell a lot about a person by the company he keeps. The people we admire, defend, and voluntarily associate with reveal a lot about our values. I began applying this simple childhood lesson to the increasingly bitter Israel debate.
No matter how fast I scrolled between internet personalities, mainstream media voices, and even elected officials, I couldn’t avoid three figures in my algorithm. And they made it easy for me to choose sides.















