Friday, November 20, 2026

  • Friday, November 20, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon

At first I thought the Myanmar ICJ ruling helped Israel because the International Court of Justice kept the “only reasonable inference” standard. When a court infers genocidal intent from conduct, it must find that an intent to destroy the group, in whole or in substantial part, is the only reasonable inference. I said then that the devil was in the details and that I would need to see the actual ruling. 

I’m glad I added that. Because the ruling really did expand the criteria for finding genocide in ways that can falsely find Israel guilty.

Brian L. Cox examined the ruling and identified three problems that compound each other. Taken together, they could allow the Court to find that Israel committed genocide even if genocide is neither the only reasonable inference nor, on a fair reading of the evidence, the most reasonable one. This flips what the court has traditionally done in genocide cases, even as it tries to make it appear that it has kept the same standards. It hasn't.

1. What happens to evidence that points the other way?

The Court says in paragraph 443 that other intentions can coexist with genocidal intent, so long as “the totality of the evidence can only be explained by the perpetrator’s genocidal intent.

Now we are moving from hard evidence for genocide, the court's previous standard, into interpretation of evidence.  When parts of the evidence contradict the genocide finding, they can be discarded in the face of "totality." This is a judgment call and judgments can be twisted. This is why the previous genocide cases set the standard incredibly high.

I have no problem with the idea that an army might have had a different goal in mind for a specific action. Some evidence is consistent with several intentions. But some evidence actually weighs against genocidal intent. That distinction can disappear when judges invoke the “totality of the evidence.” They can acknowledge a fact that cuts against genocide, imagine a reason why a government bent on genocide might have acted the same way, and then give the fact little weight. The evidence is still in the judgment. It just no longer counts against the conclusion. If the judges demand proof for a competing explanation, they should also demand proof for the explanation they use to discount contrary evidence. Otherwise, the “only reasonable inference” can become the only inference the judges allowed the evidence to support.

So Israel allowed polio vaccines into Gaza. That shows that they care about saving innocent Gaza lives. But if the "genocide" evidence the court considers is weighed much heavier than the contradictory evidence, then the "totality" can minimize the counter-evidence while pretending it is part of the totality.

2. Who decides what goes into the “totality of the evidence”?

Before the judges can decide what the evidence means, they have to decide what happened. Much of the material they may be asked to consider comes from outside bodies such as the UN Commission of Inquiry or Amnesty International. These organizations can and are biased about which evidence they credit and which explanations they consider. The Court says it will assess the factual findings in such reports for itself and give the reports’ legal conclusions no evidentiary weight. That sounds reassuring until you see how much interpretation can go into what gets presented as a fact. Myanmar judgment, ¶¶97–100

Cox gives the example of a baby shot inside a tent in Gaza. The commission examined images of the bullet and concluded, on its “reasonable grounds” standard, that it came from a sniper rifle mounted on an Israeli quadcopter. It then reasoned that because the shooting took place in daylight, the operator could see inside the tent and had targeted the mother and baby. There are a lot of evidentiary gaps here that the UN commission glossed over. How did the images of the bullet  identifyit was a quadcopter that fired the bullet and not a stray Hamas bullet? What established who fired it? What could the operator actually see inside that particular tent? What did the operator believe was there? Each step needs evidence of its own. The report said "Considering that the shooting occurred in broad daylight, the Commission concludes that the quadcopter controller would have been able to see inside the tent and assesses that the target was a mother and a baby." If the tent was closed, how does daylight help see inside the tent? Yet if the Court accepts “Israel deliberately targeted a mother and baby” as a finding of fact based on the UN COI being an independent investigator, several disputed inferences have already entered the record before the judges even consider genocidal intent. The judges are not competent to ask the questions I just asked; they are accepting the UN as a source of evidence even when the UN pretends that a picture of a bullet can determine its source, what was visible and the intent of the shooter. 

This is where the Myanmar ruling makes the problem worse. In paragraph 131, the Court allowed itself more latitude to infer facts about events largely or wholly within Myanmar’s exclusive knowledge for which Myanmar had given no satisfactory explanation. There is a sensible reason for this rule. A government may be the only party with the relevant military records. Israel’s refusal to cooperate with the commission does not automatically meet those conditions. But the danger is clear. If judges accept a commission’s conclusion on thin circumstantial evidence while demanding detailed military records before they will credit Israel’s explanation, the evidence for genocide can become easier to believe than the evidence against it. Multiply that by dozens of incidents and the Court may have a seemingly overwhelming body of evidence whose weakest links were never seriously tested. 

3. How much does following the laws of war count?

Cox’s third point concerns the laws of armed conflict. The Court does say that compliance can be evidence about intent. It also says compliance does not put conduct beyond the reach of the Genocide Convention. The question is how much weight compliance gets when the Court decides what a military was trying to achieve. An army that repeatedly cancels or changes attacks to spare civilians, at a real military cost, is giving us evidence about its intent. A targeting manual can tell you what an army says it does. The record of canceled strikes can tell you what it was willing to give up to protect civilians. 

Consider the Gaza aid cutoff. The Court could count the cutoff as evidence that Israel intended to starve Gazans as a means of destroying part of the population. Then, when Israel resumed limited aid in May 2025, the Court could say it did so only because of American pressure. There was American pressure, and Netanyahu publicly acknowledged it. But that helps explain when Israel changed course. It doesn't explain  what Israel wanted the cutoff to accomplish. A government trying to pressure Hamas could also change course when the humanitarian and diplomatic costs grew. Israel had calculated the amount of aid that came into Gaza during the previous ceasefire and calculated how long it would last. 

If cutting off aid is evidence of genocide and resuming aid gets explained away by assuming Israel still wanted genocide, either decision can be made to fit the accusation. That is where the words “only reasonable inference” have to do real work. Interpretation is doing serious mind-reading here, and when you add anti-Israel bias to the mix, it can all appear to be objective.  

The Court has to test the genocide explanation against evidence that could count against it, with the same skepticism it brings to Israel’s explanations. 

The Myanmar ruling gives us no indication that it will.



 



AddToAny

Printfriendly

EoZTV Podcast

Podcast URL

Subscribe in podnovaSubscribe with FeedlyAdd to netvibes
addtomyyahoo4Subscribe with SubToMe

search eoz

comments

Speaking

translate

E-Book

For $18 donation








Sample Text

EoZ's Most Popular Posts in recent years

Search2

Hasbys!

Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون



This blog may be a labor of love for me, but it takes a lot of effort, time and money. For 20 years and 40,000 articles I have been providing accurate, original news that would have remained unnoticed. I've written hundreds of scoops and sometimes my reporting ends up making a real difference. I appreciate any donations you can give to keep this blog going.

Donate!

Donate to fight for Israel!

Monthly subscription:
Payment options


One time donation:

Follow EoZ on Twitter!

Interesting Blogs

Blog Archive