A new paper in Sexuality & Culture, a peer-reviewed Springer Nature journal, offers a remarkable demonstration of how academic research can be made to reach conclusions that have remarkably little to do with the evidence.
The paper, by Izat El Amoor, is titled "Palestinian Intimate Topographies: Mapping Queer Decoloniality Through Familial Marriage Pressure." The author interviewed 53 queer Palestinians about their struggles with family pressure to enter heterosexual marriages.
The abstract is an impressive collection of ideological buzzwords:
Queer Palestinian activists and scholars face a complex challenge: addressing heteronormativity within Palestinian society without reinforcing dehumanizing narratives exploited by Israeli pinkwashing or homonationalist agendas. Drawing on 53 semi-structured interviews with queer Palestinians across Palestine and Israel, this article employs a decolonial queering lens to examine familial pressure to enter heterosexual marriages. I argue that marriage functions as a central site where communal endurance and “moral hygiene” are negotiated under conditions of settler-colonial erasure. Queer Palestinians do not merely experience these pressures as “traditional” oppression, but navigate them through situated practices of relational agency. Utilizing strategies such as professional mobility, strategic silences, and “tacit subjecthood,” participants reconfigure the domestic sphere as an internal arena of resistance. This framework positions the Palestinian family as an adaptive institution in which relational repair makes it possible to negotiate queer life alongside the struggle for national liberation. In doing so, it challenges the settler state’s “rescue” logic by foregrounding the complexity of queer life within the intimate topographies of the home.
The author positions Palestinian family relationships as part of an overarching struggle against Israeli colonialism.
Only one problem: Not a single interviewee quoted in the paper blames Israel for their problems.
Not one mentions Israeli occupation, Zionism, settler colonialism, or anything remotely resembling the author's central explanation for their struggles. Instead, they describe conservative families, pressure to marry, religious expectations, concerns about family honor, and the difficulty of being gay in traditional Arab society.
Every connection between these experiences and Israeli colonialism is supplied solely by the author himself.
Consider Nirmeen, a 24-year-old bisexual woman from East Jerusalem who describes her alienation from her family:
I feel exiled and alienated around all the others in the family, and around everything Arab generally as a matter of fact. When I am at Damascus Gate... I feel foreign to myself... I am alienated to myself in my clothes, in the way I talk, even when they [the family] talk about gay people, I shut up honestly.
Damascus Gate is a major center of Palestinian Arab social life in Jerusalem. Nirmeen is explicitly describing how uncomfortable she feels within Arab society, even down to the way she dresses and speaks.
Here is El Amoor's interpretation:
Nirmeen’s narrative reveals how the demands of the marital contract are compounded by the spatial and political pressures of East Jerusalem, where Palestinians experience colonial state surveillance while also navigating communal standards of social propriety, which may serve both regulatory and protective functions.
Where did Israeli surveillance come from? Certainly not from anything Nirmeen said in the quoted text. She tells the researcher she feels alienated from Arab society, and the researcher decides that Israeli colonialism must somehow be involved.
There's more. Nirmeen considers entering a marriage of convenience with her gay cousin, allowing both to satisfy family expectations while privately living the lives they choose. The author calls this a "queering of empire."
Now compare Nirmeen's experience with research about gay people in Lebanon.
In a 2020 paper in Middle East Critique, Sabiha Allouche examined Lebanese gays and lesbians who entered heterosexual marriages of convenience to escape family pressure while preserving their private lives.
One lesbian participant, Rita, married a gay man and moved to Morocco to get away from her family's constant pressure to marry. Like Nirmeen, she saw a nominally heterosexual marriage as a way to gain freedom from family expectations.
Same family pressure. Same strategy for avoiding it. Same desire to escape a restrictive social environment.
Except Rita is Lebanese, and Israel has absolutely nothing to do with her predicament.
This doesn't prove that Israeli policies can never affect the lives of queer Palestinians. But it does demonstrate that the specific experiences El Amoor documents can occur without Israeli occupation or colonialism playing any role whatsoever.
Where does blaming Israel come from?
And El Amoor's willingness to impose unsupported political interpretations on his interviewees is hardly the only problem with the paper.
In the introduction, he makes this extraordinary claim:
The urgency of this analysis has intensified following the Hamas attack on October 7, 2023, as Palestinian familial narratives have been weaponized in Israeli and Western media to justify the ongoing genocide in Gaza.
That's quite an accusation. Israeli and Western media supposedly used accounts of Palestinian family behavior to justify genocide.
What evidence does he offer?
One of his three citations is a 2024 article in The Baffler criticizing the famous Israeli comedy show Eretz Nehederet for mocking Western Queers for Palestine activists.
The sketch features clueless American college students interviewing a Hamas terrorist who threatens to throw homosexuals from rooftops. One of the students excitedly assumes he is being invited to a rooftop party.
The joke is about the absurdity of Western queer activists supporting Hamas while remaining oblivious to its treatment of homosexuals.
This is supposed to be evidence of justifying genocide?
The other cited articles similarly discuss pinkwashing, Palestinian feminism, and allegations about Israeli policies. Not one establishes the specific accusation that Palestinian family narratives were used to justify genocide.
When gay Palestinians complain about pressure from their families, El Amoor interprets their experiences as evidence of Israeli settler colonialism. When Israeli comedians mock the contradiction between LGBTQ activism and support for Hamas, he cites it as part of an argument about justifying genocide.
In both cases, the political conclusion is supplied by the author, not established by the evidence.
Sexuality & Culture, a peer-reviewed academic journal that claims to publish systematic and rigorous research, accepted this example of poor scholarship.
Apparently, when gay Palestinians describe their problems with Arab society, the one explanation academia cannot accept is that they might actually mean what they say.
(h/t JW)
Elder of Ziyon







