Tuesday, November 17, 2026

  • Tuesday, November 17, 2026
  • Elder of Ziyon


A new paper in Social Sciences, “Political Attacks, Principled Defenses: UNRWA and Humanitarian Rhetoric in the Gaza War,” by Denis Kennedy, offers an interesting finding. As Israel increased pressure on UNRWA, the agency increasingly invoked neutrality and eventually adopted more explicitly political rhetoric. Kennedy interprets this evolution as “principled self-defense.” 


The title itself shows the problem. Kennedy, at the outset, considers Israel’s attacks on UNRWA to be political, and UNRWA’s defense to be principled, a word he uses over twenty times in the paper.  


Yet the paper barely considers a competing explanation: Israel's objections to UNRWA were themselves motivated by concerns that the agency violated the neutrality it claimed to uphold. Kennedy doesn’t need to agree with that explanation, but his content analysis of press releases and reports cannot settle the motives of either side, and his interpretation gives one side the benefit of the doubt.

What is actually being measured?

Kennedy examined 533 public documents issued by UNRWA, Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch between January 2023 and January 2025. He shows that UNRWA's neutrality language increased sharply after allegations that its employees participated in the October 7 massacre. When Israeli legislation subsequently threatened its operations, the agency moved toward more confrontational, rights-based public advocacy.


This demonstrates how UNRWA adapted its communications under pressure. It does not show that those communications were truthful, that the response was principled, or that the criticisms were illegitimate. The basic question—whether UNRWA had earned its claims of neutrality—remains unanswered and unexamined.


The comparison with Amnesty and Human Rights Watch, to show that UNRWA was more neutral, muddies the issue. UNRWA is a UN service-delivery agency bound to humanitarian neutrality in its mandate. Amnesty and HRW are advocacy organizations that openly accuse governments of abuses. Of course UNRWA invokes neutrality more frequently than HRW and Amnesty; they don’t even pretend to be neutral. It is a fairly bizarre methodology to compare them. 

What Israel was actually alleging

Israel didn’t try to shut down UNRWA out of a desire to stop all humanitarian aid to Gaza. Its stated objection was that an organization claiming special neutrality had failed to maintain it; that it was in fact aligned with Hamas in deed if not in word. There is evidence relevant to that charge even if not every allegation has been substantiated.


The UN-commissioned Colonna review of April 2024 recognized UNRWA's extensive neutrality procedures. It also identified employees expressing political views, problematic content in some textbooks used in UNRWA schools, and politicized staff unions pressuring management. 


On August 5, 2024, the UN's Office of Internal Oversight Services reported evidence indicating that nine UNRWA employees might have participated in the October 7 attacks; their employment was terminated. Kennedy discusses the initial accusations and the resulting reputational damage without mentioning the subsequent UN investigation, even though its results fell within his study period. That omission is striking.


Israel also continued working with other humanitarian organizations. In November 2024 COGAT described daily coordination-board meetings with organizations operating in Gaza, daily discussions involving Israel, the United States, Egypt and the UN, and other aid-coordination arrangements. This challenges any assumption that Israeli opposition to UNRWA was necessarily opposition to humanitarian assistance itself. 

Who made UNRWA emphasize neutrality?

UNRWA has a long history of tolerating pro-terror and anti-Israel messaging in its schools. I started researching these in 2014, citing UNRWA websites that showed children celebrating terror attacks and UNRWA school websites that included explicit antisemitism not to mention lots of UNRWA teachers who celebrated terrorism on their social media. UN watch has since then documented a great deal more that exposes UNRWA’s lack of neutrality.


UNRWA responded to most of these accusations quietly, silently removing school websites and telling teachers to remove the problematic posts. It didn’t publicly condemn these issues, it didn’t mount a public investigation and report. But it clearly didn’t want to jeopardize its funding.This is not “principled.” This is defending its budget.


There was more pressure from the US. For years, American donor agreements have imposed requirements involving screening, audits and accountability. The 2023–2024 U.S.–UNRWA Framework for Cooperation called for quarterly neutrality assessments of agency installations. These measures did not emerge in a vacuum. Donor scrutiny and funding conditions helped produce the accountability machinery UNRWA cites in its own defense.


The types of pressure Kennedy characterizes as political attacks apparently enforced the very humanitarian and neutrality principles UNRWA professes. Arguably, the attackers were the principled ones, and UNRWA’s responses were political. Treating the agency's defensive language as evidence of principle while marginalizing the evidence behind the criticism reverses the burden of inquiry.

The assumption hidden in the conclusion

Kennedy's research question—how humanitarian institutions change their rhetoric under threat—is entirely legitimate, and his findings are potentially useful. But rhetoric is not reality.An institution accused of misconduct has a powerful incentive to advertise the virtue it is accused of lacking, just as a company accused of fraud might make honesty the centerpiece of its public relations campaign. Counting those declarations cannot determine whether the company is honest.


Kennedy documents UNRWA's language of principle. He does not establish which side was actually acting on principle.



 



AddToAny

Printfriendly

EoZTV Podcast

Podcast URL

Subscribe in podnovaSubscribe with FeedlyAdd to netvibes
addtomyyahoo4Subscribe with SubToMe

search eoz

comments

Speaking

translate

E-Book

For $18 donation








Sample Text

EoZ's Most Popular Posts in recent years

Search2

Hasbys!

Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون



This blog may be a labor of love for me, but it takes a lot of effort, time and money. For 20 years and 40,000 articles I have been providing accurate, original news that would have remained unnoticed. I've written hundreds of scoops and sometimes my reporting ends up making a real difference. I appreciate any donations you can give to keep this blog going.

Donate!

Donate to fight for Israel!

Monthly subscription:
Payment options


One time donation:

Follow EoZ on Twitter!

Interesting Blogs

Blog Archive