Thursday, November 19, 2026

From Ian:

Debunking the Gaza Genocide Allegations
Navi Pillay, the Nobel Peace Prize laureate and head of a UN commission of inquiry on Gaza, wants to indict Israeli President Isaac Herzog for incitement to commit genocide. In a press conference on Oct. 13, 2023, Herzog said that "it is an entire nation out there that is responsible" for the Oct. 7 Hamas attack. The commission doesn't mention that the army received orders, including from Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, to prevent hunger in Gaza and operate in accordance with international law.

The commission's conclusion preceded the investigation. Commission member Chris Sidoti said that if thousands of Palestinians were killed, there was no explanation other than a desire to annihilate. Pillay presented amazingly broad criteria in her definition of genocide. "There is no requirement as to a minimum number of victims for the act to constitute a genocidal act of killing." But she only applies this standard to Israel. Why isn't the Oct. 7 massacre genocide?

She writes that the indiscriminate massacre on the written orders of then-Hamas leader Yahya Sinwar, calling for the killing or kidnapping of anyone they encountered, including children, does not support an intent to annihilate. If killing one person can be counted as genocide when it comes to Israel, how is a massacre based on written orders not one when it comes to Hamas? When you remove the enemy from the picture, all the fatalities become civilians and the entire war looks like genocide.

Israel relinquished the element of surprise by warning civilians, it let aid through and halted operations in order to vaccinate over half a million children against polio. You can't argue an intent to maximize killing while disqualifying evidence of steps taken to limit it while forgoing military advantages.

One of the "genocidal acts" that the commission report attributes to Israel is deliberate starvation. But according to a new study we have conducted, based on the Gaza Health Ministry's records for 2025, mortality from disease and natural causes was 271.7 per 100,000 people, compared with 258.6 in 2019, the last year before the pandemic and the war. For children under 4, the number was 744 compared with 736. That is, even according to Hamas figures, there was no significant excess mortality from disease and malnutrition, and thus no mass starvation in 2025. The UN's declaration of famine turned out to be erroneous.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali: Islamists Won't Stop at the Jews
How should a constitutional republic confront an extreme religious and political ideology that explicitly targets the Jewish people? What happens when those who raise legitimate concerns are publicly and ruthlessly condemned?

Judeo-Christian civilization and the West are threatened by a rising tide of Islamist thought and politics. Islamism, the project of organizing all aspects of life in accordance with an uncompromising understanding of Sharia, is fundamentally at odds with liberal democracy. Sharia rejects freedom of conscience. Its inheritance and family law treat women unequally, and it denies women's basic rights in other ways. Non-Muslims receive markedly different treatment from Muslims under Sharia.

These ideas stand in stark contrast to the American tradition, and to the values of freedom, equality, and individual rights. What is at stake is not the fate of one ethnic or religious community vis-a-vis another. It is the future of individual rights, and the principles that underpin free societies and, ultimately, the survival of Western civilization itself.

Islam is the sum total of religious and legal traditions, commentaries, and interpretations that have arisen within the world's second-largest religion. Islamism is a family of political ideologies united by their aspiration to reshape society and the state in accordance with their interpretation of ideologically hostile teachings. Islamism has an authoritarian bent and frequently targets Muslim dissidents and apostates.

Many Muslims wish to see change within their own religion. But in too many instances, governments and other Western institutions have chosen to empower precisely those Muslim organizations most amenable to Islamist ideas, effectively anointing them as the official voice of Islam and Muslims in the West.

This dynamic has served to entrench the most theologically and socially conservative expressions of Islam, and to marginalize more pluralistic voices. It has given voice to those elements within the Muslim community most hostile to the philosophies and principles that I, and I suspect most readers, hold dear. That voice is growing louder by the day.
Clifford D. May: Israel Can't Be Both Feared in the Middle East and Loved in the West
After Israel's elections and America's midterms, I spent a week in Israel where I heard from officials, soldiers and journalists, Jewish, Muslim and Druze Israelis, and the occasional all-knowing cabdriver. My takeaway? The trauma of Oct. 7, 2023, has not dissipated. Yet Israelis remain stubbornly resilient.

Tehran's hope is that Congress next year will cut off funds for U.S. combat activities to "end the war" with Iran - a euphemism for American humiliation and a historic victory for Tehran's Islamic revolutionaries.

Would the war's end not at least address the "affordability crisis" at the pump? The opposite. If Tehran regains its nuclear program, erects an enormous missile and drone shield, and tolls the ships passing through the Strait of Hormuz, it could effectively set the global price of oil. Should that happen, even the $4.50-a-gallon gasoline this spring will seem like a bargain.

For now, Iran and most of Israel's other mortal enemies are weaker than they were on Oct. 7, but none have been decisively defeated. Each believes it is waging a divinely mandated war.

Hamas built an underground fortress for its fighters - a vast bomb shelter from which Gaza civilians were barred. How is that OK with those in America and Europe who proclaim themselves "pro-Palestinian"?

Genocide means acts committed to destroy a people. That intent is Hamas's, not that of Jews defending themselves. Israel cannot be both feared in the jungle that is the Middle East and loved in the West.


World Court rules Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya
The International Court of Justice in The Hague ruled 9-6 on Thursday that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya Muslim minority during a 2017 military campaign in northern Rakhine State.

The U.N. court found that Myanmar’s security forces killed thousands of Rohingya civilians and committed widespread sexual violence. The Gambia brought the case in November 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention.

The judges found that the only reasonable inference from Myanmar’s actions was that it intended to destroy the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine State, a substantial part of the protected group. The court ordered Myanmar to allow and facilitate the safe, voluntary and dignified return of displaced Rohingya and to pay compensation. It did not set an amount.

South Africa brought its case against Israel on Dec. 29, 2023, alleging that Israel violated the Genocide Convention in the Gaza Strip. Israel rejected the allegations in its March filing, saying its military campaign targeted Hamas and other terrorist groups following the Hamas-led massacre in southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023.

The court has not ruled on the merits of South Africa’s allegations. It extended deadlines in the case, giving South Africa until Nov. 22, 2027, to file its reply and Israel until May 22, 2029, to respond.
Jake Wallis Simons: Genocide once meant something – now the term is just political invective
Like the rest of the world, the UN seems to be deploying “genocide” as a campaigning tool, fuelled by ideology and the empty rage of social media. This week, the California state senator Scott Wiener, who is in line for Nancy Pelosi’s San Francisco Congressional seat, said the quiet part out loud.

“In terms of the word ‘genocide’, it’s traditionally been a very technical legal term under the Geneva Convention,” he said. “But for so many, the word is not just a technical legal term. It is a descriptor for an extreme level of devastation of a people. It’s a heartfelt descriptor.”

Heartfelt or not, replacing facts with feelings is a dangerous game. Just 10 days – 10 days! – after October 7, the Lemkin Institute for Genocide Prevention accused Israel of “genocide”. Hamas, by contrast, had conducted an “unprecedented military operation”, it later declared. Members of Lemkin’s family are fighting to have his name removed from the Institute’s title.

So we arrive at last Tuesday, Holocaust Memorial Day. As any schoolboy knows, or used to know, victims of that genocide totalled about 11 million, of which six million were Jews. Regardless, the BBC and other broadcasters repeatedly paid tribute to the six million “people” who were murdered, erasing the Jews once again as a reprehensible coda to the genocide.

Was that “heartfelt”? Probably. Unsurprisingly, of the 2,000 secondary schools that marked the Holocaust in 2023, 1,146 have since given it up. Lurking in the background is the cunning little piece of anti-Semitic propaganda, shamefully endorsed by the UN, that when it comes to genocide, the Jews are as bad as the Nazis. Yet nobody has used the g-word for massacres by the Iranian regime, enemy of our democracies.

How easily is truth dismissed as a quaint and old-fashioned habit, like trilbies or good manners! But unmoor legal definitions at your peril. When genocide becomes a political weapon, it is wielded against the West.
Preliminary Thoughts on ICJ The Gambia v. Myanmar
Implications for Israel

In an objective reading, I think the facts about Israel are completely different from those in Myanmar. Israel has not intentionally attacked civilians, carried out mass executions, murdered children, or perpetrated mass sexual violence against Gazans. The destruction of civilian infrastructure and civilian casualties can easily be explained by Hamas’ use of human shields, turning homes, hospitals, and schools into military targets.

General context. The Rohingya were a stateless minority inside Myanmar’s own borders. For decades, they were stripped of citizenship and restricted in movement, marriage, and reproduction. The trigger for the 2017 “clearance operations” was a set of small ARSA attacks on border posts, which the military used as a pretext for a campaign planned long in advance. Gaza is nothing like this. The war began with Hamas’s October 7 massacre. Hamas is a governing armed organization with tens of thousands of fighters, a vast tunnel network, rocket arsenals and hundreds of hostages.

Selective targeting. In Rakhine, the military went village by village through Rohingya settlements, burned them, and resettled non-Rohingya on the land. The goal was to erase the group’s presence. In Gaza, Israeli operations are aimed at Hamas’s military infrastructure. Where civilian infrastructure has been hit, Israel’s position is that Hamas turned it into military objectives by embedding in homes, hospitals and schools. Whatever one thinks of particular strikes, there is no ethnic sorting of targets comparable to Rakhine. I am confident that Israeli military reports can demonstrate the legality of every approved strike.

Targeting the group’s foundations. The UN Fact-Finding Mission documented mass rape of Rohingya women and girls as a systematic tool of the campaign, along with deliberate killing of children and babies. No comparable systematic pattern has been established against Israeli forces in Gaza. The systematic sexual violence of this war was documented on October 7, against Israelis. The UN Special Representative on Sexual Violence in Conflict found reasonable grounds to believe it occurred.

Systematic nature and scale. In Myanmar, the pattern was mass executions of men and boys, shooting at fleeing civilians, and the methodical burning of hundreds of villages. Israel’s documented pattern is evacuation warnings, designated humanitarian zones, roof-knocking, humanitarian pauses and the entry of aid.

The Court found that Myanmar’s conduct was inconsistent with counter-insurgency: there was no distinction between civilians and fighters and no military logic to the killing of babies. In Gaza, the conduct is consistent with a lawful military aim against a real enemy. Under the “only reasonable inference” test, the Court reaffirmed that the alternative explanation should be decisive.

The Court however, as a UN body, has a systemic bias in favour of UN reports. It also has a history of ignoring opposing evidence provided by Israel. The UN Commission of Inquiry, headed by the same Navi Pillay who sat as an ad hoc judge in the Myanmar Case, issued a September 2025 report alleging genocide by Israeli forces in Gaza. The report also completely minimizes Hamas’ presence in Gaza, detailing uncorroborated accounts of intentional Israeli attacks on children and claims that the only possible explanation for civilian deaths was deliberate targeting. Salo Aizenberg and UN Watch released a very detailed rebuttal of the report here.

In the Wall Advisory Opinion, the ICJ relied entirely on a UN Secretary-General report and several accompanying statements. In his separate opinion from March 28, 2024, in the Genocide Convention Case, ad hoc Judge Barak criticized the Court for completely ignoring contrary evidence provided by Israel:
Israel, in its written observations, presented concrete evidence of its efforts to address the humanitarian catastrophe in Gaza. The Court did not engage with any of these arguments, which are crucial to the question of intent. Instead, it simply dismissed this evidence by quoting a statement by the High Commissioner for Human Rights, who stated that “hunger, starvation and famine is a result of Israel’s extensive restrictions on the entry and distribution of humanitarian aid”. The Court conveniently refrains from evaluating Israel’s evidence that points in a different direction and dismisses over 20 pieces of evidence by reference to a declaration by one official…

The Court’s overall treatment of evidence is problematic. The Court’s conclusions are grounded in several declarations by United Nations officials and reports by intergovernmental organizations that were not submitted by either Party…


In its Occupation Advisory Opinion, the Court held that Gaza was still occupied by Israel, and that Israel may have violated the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination in its actions against the Palestinians. The Court may use this as “context” for Israel’s supposed anti-Palestinian actions.

Conclusion
In a fair and objective Court, Gambia v. Myanmar sets out what a genocide actually looks like: sorting victims by ethnicity, mass executions, systematic rape, razing villages so the group cannot return. Gaza does not look like this. In a positive reading, the Court applied legal rigor in determining Myanmar’s guilt, and the same rigor will lead to a dismissal of the allegations against Israel. In a more depressing reading, the Court abstained from a radical departure from previous case law to avoid potential American sanctions, understanding that it could find Israel guilty based on twisted facts, with a much less favourable administation in Washington towards Israel.

These are just my early thoughts. I’ll have more in the coming days.


Victor Davis Hanson: Diplomacy Alone Will Not Change the Iranian Theocracy
The current Iranian theocracy cannot change its ways, even if its intransigent refusal to do so will eventually doom it. Theocratic Iran has never negotiated anything in good faith with anyone. It continually chooses terrorism, conflict, and murder, even when such violence is not in its own interests. The Iranian theocracy cannot change its nature even if it wished to - which it doesn't.

During the current supposed "peace" between Iran and the U.S., Iran's terrorist proxies have kept busy making war. U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent and Secretary of State Marco Rubio were reportedly living on a secure military base after they received serious threats from terrorist groups affiliated with Iran's ruling Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC).

In the last half-century, Iranian terrorists have killed more Americans than any other terrorist group except al-Qaeda on 9/11. They have taken American hostages, killed some, blown up embassies, slaughtered Americans as they slept in military barracks and on their ships, and supplied our enemies with shaped-charge IEDs that killed hundreds of American soldiers. They and their surrogates, such as Hizbullah, harbor a sick hatred of Jews and have attacked them worldwide.

What are Iran's grievances and ultimate aims? It seeks vengeance against the West, the Jewish state of Israel, and moderate Sunni Muslim nations, especially the wealthiest Gulf oil exporters. Iran's strategic aims are to rid the region of American influence and power altogether, claim primacy in the Islamic world, destroy Israel (thus further discrediting its supposedly impotent Islamic rivals), and ultimately, from both within and without, overpower the West.
Trump Weighs Iran Strike Options
Describing the prospect of a U.S. strike on Iran, "It's not a question of if, but when and on what scale," a very senior non-Israeli diplomatic official told Israel Hayom.

According to the official, President Trump has instructed his team to prepare several options to dramatically weaken the regime in Tehran until it no longer poses a threat to neighboring countries.

Continued economic warfare is considered highly effective, and conditions in Iran are deteriorating. Members of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps are seeing their salaries cut.

However, it could take many more months before the situation reaches a critical point for the regime.

U.S. security agencies have thwarted at least two Iranian assassination attempts against senior American officials in recent months, stopping both before they could be carried out.

In response, the president decided to all but shut down diplomatic engagement with Tehran.


US Army gives contractors 45 days to build fortified bunkers in Israel amid Iran tensions
As tensions remain high with Iran, the US Army has put out a notice seeking contractors to “urgently” build 17 reinforced concrete bunkers to protect American and coalition troops from missile and drone attacks.

According to a government procurement notice, the Army wants 17 bunkers capable of remaining intact through indirect fire attacks, such as from missiles and drones. Ten bunkers are planned for Israel, five in Saudi Arabia, and two in Lebanon.

"Due to elevated regional force protection conditions, there is an urgent, high-priority requirement to replace nonstandard personnel protection shelters (e.g., converted shipping containers) and provide standardized, precast, reinforced concrete Indirect Fire bunkers," the notice said.

"The objective is to safeguard US and coalition service members operating in potentially hostile environments across multiple countries in [US Central Command] Area of Responsibility," it added.

In Israel, the Army is requiring the construction of 10 “fully operational Indirect Fire (IDF)” bunkers that will include three reinforced concrete sections, blast and fragmentation protection barriers known as Alaska barriers one meter from the entry or exit points that will be three meters high and weigh an approximate 6.1 tons per piece.

US military plans 17 new bunkers across the Middle East amid fears of Iranian missile attacks
The bunkers will also have sniper screens, and their roofs will have 18 inches of cover provided by sandbags, while the sides will have four feet of sandbags.

Due to the urgency, the notice was open to contractors for just three days to submit price quotes. Once one is found, they will have 45 days to finish the work.

“Due to extreme operational urgency (soldiers currently at risk using non-standard containerized shelters), the subsequent solicitation is anticipated to have an expedited 3-day quote turnaround window,” the notice stated.


IDF Officer: Targeting Hamas Officials "Makes It Easier for Soldiers on Front Lines"
The IDF Southern Command has carried out a series of precise, targeted strikes against Hamas brigade commanders and other senior terrorists in Gaza, as the military seeks to prevent the terrorist organization from rebuilding its capabilities, Lt.-Col. A. told Walla on Wednesday.

He said close coordination between firepower and intelligence, along with increasingly sophisticated operational methods, have enabled the military to strike targets with maximum precision, even in densely populated areas.

He said that in the recent strike at Nasser Hospital in Khan Yunis, in which the commander of Hamas's Khan Yunis Brigade was seriously wounded, "those presented as innocent civilians [among the casualties] were actually terrorists."

He noted that Hamas commanders' efforts to plan attacks and rebuild the organization's capabilities force them to move outside the tunnel network, exposing them to Israeli intelligence and strikes.

"Hamas has not disappeared. It is certainly not the Hamas of Oct. 7, but it is constantly seeking to grow stronger....Our job is to act relentlessly to ensure that it does not have the conditions needed to return to what it once was."

Systematically targeting Hamas's chain of command makes it significantly more difficult for the organization to threaten IDF troops and Israeli civilians. "Every targeted killing like this provides another glimmer of security for the soldiers on the front lines, making things a little easier for them and reducing the threats they face."
IDF ends one-day tunnel demolition operation inside Hamas-controlled part of Gaza
The Israeli military on Thursday morning completed a rare ground operation beyond the so-called Yellow Line in the central Gaza Strip that divides the territory between Israeli and Hamas control, a day after it began, saying it had demolished a section of a Hamas tunnel that the terror group was attempting to restore.

Palestinian civilians, who were ordered to stay away amid the raid, returned to the area to check their belongings and assess the damage after the military pulled back its forces.

The Israel Defense Forces said that during the day-long operation, troops demolished a section of a Hamas tunnel that the terror group was attempting to restore adjacent to the Yellow Line.

Reservists from the Harel Brigade, troops from the 607th Combat Engineering Battalion, and the elite Yahalom Combat Engineering Unit crossed the Yellow Line as part of a “targeted operation” against the tunnel, which the military said “posed an immediate and direct threat” to forces.

The army said the tunnel had crossed into the Israeli side of the Yellow Line and was connected to Hamas “activity hubs” in central Gaza, enabling the terror group’s operatives to launch attacks on Israeli troops.

“The IDF destroyed a section of the underground infrastructure to remove the threat, after identifying attempts by the Hamas terror group to restore it in violation of the ceasefire agreement,” the army added.


Global Journalists’ Group Quietly Cuts 40 Terrorists’ Names From Its ‘Slain Gaza Journalists’ List, Contradicting Embattled Committee to Protect Journalists
The International Federation of Journalists quietly excised 40 names from its widely cited list of "journalists" killed in Gaza, an attempted clean-up likely meant to ward off further criticism after the Washington Free Beacon first documented the list’s inclusion of multiple battle-hardened terrorists.

Seven of the names struck off the Brussels-based group’s list remain on a dueling list maintained by the New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists, which after its own review has doubled down on classifying many Palestinian militants who masqueraded as newsmen as "slain journalists." More than half the names on CPJ’s now revised list of supposed journalists slain in Gaza "have connections to terrorist groups," the Free Beacon first reported last month.

The IFJ, which touts itself as the world’s largest advocacy group for reporters, has been under fire for including as "slain journalists" confirmed terrorists who were active on the battlefield. The situation mirrors that of the CPJ, which is facing similar scrutiny for its list of "slain journalists" in Gaza and recently removed some names after months of infighting.

The clash between the two dueling lists—with the CPJ list continuing to include the names of seven "journalists" removed from the IFJ list—highlights how both groups are struggling to make the case—without credible evidence—that Israel targets Palestinian journalists. The IFJ, for its part, has tried to dodge more scrutiny by only vaguely acknowledging that it’s removed at least 40 names from its list since early October. A small disclaimer online that says the IFJ "is working hard to keep this list up-to-date and accurate."

The IFJ says that it is still working "closely" to verify information with its affiliate, the Palestinian Journalists' Syndicate, a little-known Palestinian journalist group that the Free Beacon first reported in September is run by a West Bank activist who regularly calls for bloodshed and touts terrorists as "heroes."

Two media watchdog groups highly critical of the "slain journalist in Gaza" lists—the Israel-based Honest Reporting and the Boston-based Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis (CAMERA)—separately claimed, based on parallel investigations, that sometime between October 3 and October 8, the IFJ quietly expunged 37 names, followed by 3 more in early November. Both audits were shared exclusively with the Free Beacon and reveal that most of the deleted names were Palestinian combatants for Hamas or other terrorist groups who were posing as reporters.

In several cases, the IFJ quietly deleted entries from its list, but the individuals remain listed in CPJ’s database. This could be due to the way in which CPJ defines a journalist: After weeks of infighting, the group’s board voted 17-1 earlier this year to affirm that "organizations affiliated with militant groups" meet the criteria of a legitimate journalistic outlet "provided they are not engaging in combat or inciting violence in a manner likely to have imminent effect."

The IFJ’s definition, by contrast, is more traditional: "A journalist is one who devotes the greater part of his/her working time to the profession of journalism and who derives from it most of his/her income being employed or working as a freelance."


UNIFIL's Exit from Lebanon Exposes Its Failure to Disarm Hizbullah
UNIFIL's mandate is set to expire on Dec. 31, 2026. Since 1978, UNIFIL has functioned as an international observer and liaison channel that documented violations, reported cross-border incidents, and imposed diplomatic friction on major escalations.

Washington firmly opposes renewing UNIFIL or creating another traditional UN peacekeeping force. Instead, the U.S. is pushing for a smaller, non-UN verification body modeled on the Multinational Force and Observers (MFO) in the Sinai that does not act as a military buffer. Hizbullah will fiercely oppose any U.S.-led MFO-style monitor.

Israel views UNIFIL's exit as the end of a failed arrangement that allowed Hizbullah to entrench. With UNIFIL gone, primary responsibility for southern Lebanon falls on the Lebanese Armed Forces (LAF).

Israel demands active enforcement of Hizbullah's disarmament; Hizbullah threatens civil war if disarmament is attempted. The LAF lacks the political resolve, national consensus, and military strength to impose its monopoly on force alone. Removing UNIFIL without resolving this leaves the IDF and Hizbullah facing each other directly across a contested border. Thus, the likelihood of a direct collision between Hizbullah and Israel is high.
Air Force bombs entrances to underground Hezbollah missile site in east Lebanon — IDF
The Israeli Air Force carried out strikes on Thursday evening in eastern Lebanon’s Beqaa Valley, targeting an underground Hezbollah site used by the terror group for the production of missiles and the storage of weapons, the military said.

It marked the second Israeli strike in the Beqaa Valley within days, after the military on Monday said the IAF had struck a weapons shipment from Syria that was destined for Hezbollah in Lebanon. That strike marked the first in eastern Lebanon in several months.

The subterranean missile manufacturing site, located near the eastern Lebanon town of Janta, has been struck by the Israel Defense Forces numerous times before.

The military said that it recently identified Hezbollah operatives arriving at the missile site and, therefore, on Thursday, struck the entrances “to prevent its rehabilitation.”

Lebanese media reported several strikes in the area. There were no immediate reports of casualties.

“The Hezbollah terror organization continues to exploit various areas in Lebanon for terror activity, weapons smuggling, and the movement of terrorists, in violation of the ceasefire agreement signed with Lebanon and to harm Israeli civilians and IDF soldiers,” the military said in a statement.


Comedy Cellar: The Streamer Who Picked Apart a Pulitzer Winner While Playing Video Games | LonerBox
LonerBox joins Noam Dworman, Dan Naturman and Periel Aschenbrand on Live from the Table for a conversation about political streaming, the Israel-Palestine conflict, historical narratives, and the state of political debate.

They discuss the limits of history books, selective empathy, Western protest movements, Epstein, January 6, Hasan Piker, Benjamin Moser’s book, Anti-Zionism, and why so much of the Middle East conflict is misunderstood.

LonerBox is Scottish-Lebanese live-streamer who covers politics and internet culture. His content mostly consists of debates and news coverage spanning a variety of topics, but with a special focus on the Middle East.

00:00 LonerBox on the Moser Interview and Why Tough Questions Matter
10:56 How Livestreaming Creates a New Political Community
16:17 Autism, ADHD, Research and Emotional Distance
26:31 Can History Books Capture What Really Happened?
33:35 The Evidence Gap in the Arab-Israeli Conflict
37:44 Are Western "Pro-Palestine" Protests Listening to Palestinians?
44:35 How LonerBox's Views on Israel Changed
48:23 Epstein, January 6 and Conspiracy Theories vs. Evidence
1:13:02 Moser, Hasan Piker and the Politics of Selective History
1:22:02 The "Invisible Fighter" Myth
1:28:20 Lebanon, Hezbollah and the Cost of "Resistance"


Channel 4 News “fact checkers” defend their lie about the ICJ
A Channel 4 News “Fact Check” investigation published on Nov. 13, “Revealed: secret files on UK arms exports to Israel”, by data scientist Brian O’Flynn, included the patently false claim that the ICJ ruled that there was a “plausible risk of genocide in Gaza”.

Here’s a capture of the frame – two minutes in to the 11 minute programme – that appears on screen as O’Flynn claims that “The International Court of Justice (ICJ) issued a landmark ruling on Israel’s conduct. It said that there was a plausible risk of genocide in Gaza”.

However, the letter with the words “a plausible risk of genocide in Gaza” that editors highlighted in green, falsely characterising the ICJ’s actual ruling – issued on January 24, 2024 – was the copy of a UK Judges’ and Lawyers’ Open Letter on the issue, and not the text of the ICJ ruling itself, which, as we’ll show, never ruled on the merits of South Africa’s case.

The lie was repeated in Channel 4 News’ online article about the investigation:


Here’s Joan Donoghue, the ICJ president at the time of the ruling, stating definitively – while being interviewed on BBC’s Hardtalk in 2024 – that the court made no such claim.

The claim is so unambiguously false that we were able to prompt corrections at the Guardian to articles which contained the same mischaracterisation of the ICJ’s preliminary ruling.

Last week, we complained to Channel 4 News, asking that they correct the error, and we received the following email:
Thank you for contacting Channel 4. Whilst we accept that the ICJ did not use the exact words “a plausible risk of genocide in Gaza”, we consider this a fair summary of the findings of that judgment. This interpretation has been widely adopted and repeated by legal experts, including hundreds of senior UK lawyers and former judges, and was consistent with the analysis provided by our contributor Professor Janina Dill. It has also been reflected in subsequent UN commentary. The report made the source of the quote clear on screen (“UK Judges’ and Lawyers’ Open Letter Concerning Gaza – 3 April 2024”). We do not consider there is any material fact to correct in this instance but nonetheless appreciate your feedback.

Even by the low standards at Channel 4 News we’re used to, this is an astonishing reply from their Viewer Relations Department. Though she admits that the court didn’t rule that “there was a plausible risk of genocide,” she falsely claims that it is, nonetheless, a “fair summary of the findings of that judgement.”




 



AddToAny

Printfriendly

EoZTV Podcast

Podcast URL

Subscribe in podnovaSubscribe with FeedlyAdd to netvibes
addtomyyahoo4Subscribe with SubToMe

search eoz

comments

Speaking

translate

E-Book

For $18 donation








Sample Text

EoZ's Most Popular Posts in recent years

Search2

Hasbys!

Elder of Ziyon - حـكـيـم صـهـيـون



This blog may be a labor of love for me, but it takes a lot of effort, time and money. For 20 years and 40,000 articles I have been providing accurate, original news that would have remained unnoticed. I've written hundreds of scoops and sometimes my reporting ends up making a real difference. I appreciate any donations you can give to keep this blog going.

Donate!

Donate to fight for Israel!

Monthly subscription:
Payment options


One time donation:

Follow EoZ on Twitter!

Interesting Blogs

Blog Archive