The Dawn of Western Palestinianism
The drama is no less artificial than it is effective. Palestine works as a unifying symbol because it is infinitely elastic. Sudan’s catastrophe offers no convenient Western villain. Ukraine ruins the anti-imperialist script because Russia is the invader, and Washington arms the victim. Israel, by contrast, can be cast as America’s outpost and the Western order’s proxy, which is to say that it can embody everything the radical left already opposes. To one activist, Palestine means anti-colonialism; to another, anti-capitalism; to a third, racial justice or resistance to American power. A slogan scrawled on a Paris wall summed up the radicals’ pooled ambitions: “Palestine will save us all.”Europe is petting the wolf: How the red-green alliance threatens Western democracy
The political theorists Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe had a name for this: a “chain of equivalence,” in which separate grievances are welded into a single identity against a common enemy. Mélenchon has drawn openly on their work. A student angry about teacher shortages, a worker squeezed by prices, a climate activist, and a campaigner against Israel need not share the same priorities. Persuade them that their grievances are symptoms of one oppressive system, and they become a movement. That’s what France saw this fall. The students had real grievances; French public education has been failing for years. But on October 17, they marched alongside Yellow Vest veterans, unions, and cost-of-living protesters. The Palestinian flag was the one banner every faction could carry.
The strategic payoff is obvious. A school budget can be negotiated. A crusade can’t. For movements that live on permanent conflict, that’s the point.
Nor is the coalition an accident of the street. It’s the deliberate product of organizations working in concert. In September, the Association France Palestine Solidarité, BDS France, Stop Arming Israel France, and Urgence Palestine issued a call for a month of action against arms transfers to Israel. The signatories included the CGT, France’s oldest labor confederation; the student union UNEF; Mélenchon’s LFI; the Communist Party; the decolonial Parti des Indigènes de la République; and Perspectives Musulmanes.
This coalition also reached the school protests. Reporting in Le Point, French journalist Nora Bussigny described how Étudiants Musulmans de France (EMF) called on its chapters to join the mobilization and how it had previously worked with RED Jeunes, a prominent youth activist network, in a campaign against what they call “state Islamophobia.” EMF itself urged members to join the October 17 demonstrations. The students’ complaints are real. But other movements were quick to fold those complaints into their own political agendas.
Here was the red-green alliance in miniature: far-left groups and activist networks rooted in political Islam, joining the same mobilization effort despite very different long-term aims. A demand for math teachers was becoming a vehicle for a much broader argument about French institutions.
And then there is Samidoun, also named among the September campaign’s supporters. In 2024, the U.S. Treasury designated it as a fundraising front for the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, a terrorist organization. Nothing ties the other signatories to its activities, but when a group like that can share space on a list with France’s major unions and parties, it says something about how little the coalition worries about the company it keeps.
None of this escaped the notice of the West’s adversaries. On October 7, France’s foreign ministry said official Iranian accounts had been spreading disinformation about the student movement. Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot has also pointed to Russian and Chinese narratives exploiting the unrest. That doesn’t mean that foreign governments organized the demonstrations. They didn’t need to. The Islamic Republic knows a useful fracture when it sees one. It only needs to persuade Westerners that every grievance proves their own societies illegitimate. The Palestinian cause is useful to Tehran not because it might succeed, but because the arguments around it may never end. It provides the regime with a perpetual source of information warfare.
The greatest irony is that Palestinians themselves vanish from Western Palestinianism. Where are the marches for accountable Palestinian institutions, for elections, or for an alternative to Hamas? There are, in fact, Palestinians calling for these things. There is, for example, Ahmed Fouad Alkhatib, who grew up in Gaza and has lost relatives in the war. He condemns the suffering inflicted on Palestinian civilians and holds Hamas responsible for the catastrophe it unleashed on October 7, 2023. But in Western Palestinianism, a Palestinian who wants a negotiated peace, or simply a safe future for his children, is a Palestinian who has forgotten his lines.
This is where Wilf’s point comes home. A politics built chiefly on denying Jewish sovereignty cannot offer Palestinians a future. Exported to the West, it does something else: It turns a distant national conflict into a permanent indictment of the societies its supporters live in and a gift to those who want to bring down the nations of the free world. The condescension at the heart of Western Palestinianism demands that Palestinians play the role of the world’s exemplary victims. Their suffering is useful, as it foots the bill for a form of multigenerational European group therapy. But Palestinian agency is nothing but a terrible inconvenience.
The Soviets came for communism. The Qataris came for Islamism. And Europe is being devoured along the way.
As early as the 1980s, the Soviet Union understood that it could not defeat the West through military force alone. Instead, according to accounts of Soviet intelligence strategy, it devoted an estimated 85% of the KGB's resources not to traditional espionage, but to subversion and psychological manipulation.
The strategy was to infiltrate Western academia, media and cultural institutions with what might be called "soft agents," individuals capable of gradually undermining Western citizens' confidence in their own values and national institutions.
The collapse of the Soviet Union slowed the process. But the rise of Vladimir Putin, himself a former KGB officer, gave it renewed momentum.
And then, I believe, this Russian campaign of influence found a powerful counterpart in Qatar.
Qatar is a ruthless state wrapped in the seductive glamour of extraordinary wealth. Behind the polished image of desert nobility, I see something very different: barbarians dressed in tailored suits and flowing white robes.
Its ideological bible, in my view, is the manifesto of the Muslim Brotherhood, with its vision of "civilizational jihad" — the gradual conquest of societies in the name of Islam.
Armed with fervent jihadist conviction and hundreds of billions of dollars, Qatar has, I contend, helped normalize what should be unthinkable: the admission of unskilled Muslim immigrants who contribute nothing to the economy, receive generous welfare benefits from their first day and, in the most extreme cases, passionately believe that the very people who welcomed them are infidels whose heads should be severed once they have accumulated sufficient power.
And so we return to Turin.
While police officers brace themselves in the heart of Italy's luxury shopping district, preparing for unrest that authorities already anticipate, Europe's leaders continue to embrace what they see as the purity of their liberal values.
Someone needs to wake them up.
Someone needs to tell them that the creature they are so lovingly stroking is, in fact, the wolf.



















