The Lebanese Ministry of Health's Own Numbers Undermine the Civilian Casualty Narrative
In April, based on the Lebanese Ministry of Health's numbers, I wrote that roughly 80% of Lebanese deaths in the current war were adult males — far above their approximately 37% share of the population.
That by itself is improbable if Israel is bombing and destroying indiscriminately, the way the media likes to imply.
But it turns out those incredible numbers are not even close to the reality.
Their latest infographic shows that there have been 2,679 deaths, of which 2,459 are adult males - which is 91.8%.
Comparing the April 17 and May 3 numbers, we see the number of women killed and injured has gone down, not up, meaning that they ministry was classifying some people wrongly.
91.8% males is very impressive. But even that is an undercount, for two reasons.
When we look at the small print in the infographic, we see this:
The Health Ministry, against all international standards, is counting 18 year olds as "children."
A back of the envelope calculation estimates that between 50-100 of the "children" killed were really 18 years old. So the percentage of adult males may be in the 93-95% range.
But that's not even all of it.
A Reuters investigation published May 3 — the same day as the ministry's latest dashboard — reports that Hezbollah's own sources say the ministry numbers are incomplete. Three sources, two of them Hezbollah officials, told Reuters that the ministry's figures do not include many of the group's casualties, and that several thousand fighters have been killed, though Hezbollah does not yet have the full picture. A Hezbollah commander told Reuters that scores of fighters went to the frontline towns of Bint Jbeil and Khiyam intending to fight to the death, and their bodies have yet to be recovered.
That means that there are plenty, maybe even over a thousand, terrorists not yet on the Ministry of Health lists.
This is almost certainly unprecedented for modern warfare (since the days when armies only fought armies.)
The data does not prove that every adult male death is a Hezbollah fighter. It proves something narrower and more verifiable: that the casualty distribution is wildly inconsistent with indiscriminate fire, that Hezbollah's own sources confirm the ministry numbers are a significant undercount, and that the framing of this war as a campaign of civilian devastation rests on numbers that were never true and that even the ministry's own subsequent revisions have moved even further away from.
|
"He's an Anti-Zionist Too!" cartoon book (December 2024) PROTOCOLS: Exposing Modern Antisemitism (February 2022) |
 |
Buy 