The February blizzard had been generous with the neighborhood and merciless with the shul roof. Three feet of snow, then ice, then — on Friday afternoon, two hours before Shabbos — a structural engineer named Phil Rosen stood in the parking lot of Congregation Limudei Avot, looked up at the social hall roof, and delivered his verdict with the grim efficiency of a doctor who has bad news and a waiting room full of patients.
"It's not safe," he said. "Not for an event. Not this week."
Rabbi David Horowitz stared at him. "The Purim party is Monday night."
Phil shrugged with the particular sympathy of a man who has delivered this kind of news before and knows there is nothing useful to add.
"How many people?" he asked.
"Two hundred and thirty. Plus walk-ins."
Phil looked at the roof again. "Yeah," he said. "No."
The theme had been set months ago: Mexico, in honor of President Claudia Sheinbaum, the first Jewish head of state Mexico had ever produced. The invitations were out. The sombreros had been ordered — forty-seven sombreros, non-refundable. A full klezmer-cumbia fusion band had been booked. The caterer had been instructed to go all in on Mexican food, including, at someone's specific insistence, salsa ordered by the gallon. The Sisterhood had been working on the decorations since January.
And now: no hall.
Rabbi Horowitz stood in the parking lot for a long moment after Phil left. Then he went inside, picked up the phone, and called his wife.
Rebbetzin Devorah Horowitz was the chair of the Limudei Avot Youth Team — terrible slogan "Don't be late - join LAYT today!" created in the 1990s but never losing its original "youthful" members. Devorah was the person you called when the caterer cancelled the night before the annual dinner, when the Torah was found to have a letter cracked on Thursday and needed emergency repair before Shabbos, when two b'nei mitzvah families had been double-booked for the same Saturday and nobody had noticed until that week.
She answered on the first ring.
Rabbi Horowitz explained. There was a silence on the other end that he recognized: not panic, but the particular stillness of a woman mentally sorting through a problem before she begins speaking.
"Shabbos starts in two hours," she said finally.
"I know."
"There's nothing we can do until Saturday night."
"I know."
Another pause. "Dovid," she said, "those sombreros were non-refundable."
"I know that too."
"All right," said Devorah. "Saturday night. Tell the Team to be at our house at nine."
Shabbos that week had an unusual quality. Those who knew about the roof — and by Friday night candle-lighting, that was most of the shul — moved through the day with the particular restlessness of people who have a problem they cannot yet address. The davening was fine. The cholent was fine. The Shabbos afternoon naps were, if anything, longer than usual, because sleeping was the one productive thing available.
Devorah made lists in her head of what needed to be done after Havdalah. By the time Shabbos ended she had assembled, in her mind, a complete action plan. What she did not yet have was a venue.
The Youth Team convened at the Horowitz kitchen table at nine o'clock Saturday night: Devorah with her legal pad, Morty Feldstein the gabbai with his ancient address book, and Barry Sternberg, the shul's resident real-estate maven, who arrived still in his Shabbos suit and immediately began working his phone.
"Two hundred and thirty people," said Devorah. "Mexican theme. Monday night. The sombreros are already in Rena Bloom's minivan."
"What about the JCC?" said Morty.
"I called. They have a Sweet Sixteen."
"The Marriott ballroom?"
"Bar mitzvah."
"The firehouse on—"
"They need two weeks' notice minimum for liability reasons."
Barry looked up from his phone. He had the expression of a man who has just remembered something. "There's a new nightclub downtown," he said. "By the waterfront. Called Aura. Just got its certificate of occupancy last week. LED lighting system, the whole thing — apparently the place glows. Owner's holding his grand opening in two weeks but technically the space is ready."
Devorah's pen was already moving. "Capacity?"
"Four hundred."
"Sound system?"
"State of the art, from what I hear."
"It's perfect," said Devorah. "What's the catch?"
Barry set his phone down on the table. "The owner is Kevin O'Donnell."
Kevin O'Donnell was not an antisemite in any classical sense. He had simply once remarked, at a family gathering after one whiskey too many, that he found Jews exhausting — too much talking, too much negotiating. (He wasn't entirely wrong.) He had said it once. It had been repeated, as things get repeated in close communities — imperfectly, with elaboration — until it reached the Jewish community as: Kevin O'Donnell hates Jews and said so at his mother's funeral.
This was inaccurate. But it was what LAYT was working with.
"We can't just call him," said Devorah.
"No," agreed Barry and Morty simultaneously.
They sat for a moment.
"What about Reverend Callahan?" said Morty.
Reverend Kenneth Callahan — Vicar of St. Brendan's Church on Maple Avenue, three blocks from the shul — had grown up with Kevin O'Donnell, been an altar boy with Kevin O'Donnell, attended the same schools, played on the same streets. He had once, in 1974, taken the blame for a broken rectory window that Kevin O'Donnell had definitely broken. Kevin would do almost anything Ken asked, partly out of affection and partly out of a debt he had never quite acknowledged but never entirely forgotten.
Devorah looked at her watch. Nine-thirty on a Saturday night.
"Call him," she said.
Morty called. The Reverend answered on the third ring, sounding not at all put out.
"Of course I know the shul," said Reverend Callahan warmly, when Morty explained. "Rabbi Horowitz is a good man. What can I do?"
Morty explained the situation. There was a thoughtful pause.
"Kevin can be stubborn," said Reverend Callahan. "But I'll try. I can't promise anything."
"We understand completely," said Morty.
"And," said Reverend Callahan, with what Morty would later describe as a gentle but utterly unmistakable firmness, "if I'm going to all this trouble, I would like to attend. I have always wanted to see a Purim celebration."
Morty covered the phone and looked at Devorah. She spread her hands: obviously.
"Reverend Callahan," said Morty, "you are not only invited, you are our guest of honor."
Kevin O'Donnell called back forty minutes later. He had spoken to Callahan. He was willing — reluctantly, with conditions, in the voice of a man doing a favor he had not entirely agreed to do.
Condition one: the venue had to be left exactly as found.
Condition two: the shul was responsible for any damage.
Condition three — and here his voice took on the careful tone of a businessman protecting an investment — before any outside event could use the space, he needed a formal audit of the premises. His insurance carrier required it. His accountant was unavailable until Monday morning.
"Monday morning?" said Devorah.
"Ten o'clock," said O'Donnell. "Not a minute before. That's the earliest my carrier will accept."
Devorah looked at the ceiling. The party was Monday night. The audit would clear — if it cleared — with perhaps ten hours to spare.
"Fine," she said. "We'll have our own accountant there."
She hung up and looked at Morty.
"Who do we have?" she said.
Morty opened his address book.
"Marvin Gross," he said.
Marvin Gross was a precise, quietly anxious man who had been doing taxes for half the shul for twenty-three years and who approached every financial document with the focused intensity of someone defusing something. He was reached at home mid-Saturday-night, in the middle of what he described as "a very important Sudoku."
"I need you to audit a nightclub on Monday morning at ten o'clock," said Devorah.
A pause. "What kind of nightclub?"
"The kind with a certificate of occupancy and an insurance carrier."
"Is this for the—"
"Purim party. Yes."
Another pause. "I'll need to prepare."
"You have all day Sunday."
"I'll need the preliminary financials by—"
"Barry Sternberg will get them to you tonight."
A very long pause. "All right," said Marvin. "You know, Devorah, what I call a last second audit? An oy-dit!"
Devorah groaned.
Sunday was organized chaos with better lighting.
The band confirmed. The caterer confirmed, including four cases of salsa — the good kind, the kind that came in glass jars, at Devorah's specific instruction.
Rena Bloom's daughter made two minivan trips to move the forty-seven sombreros to Barry's garage, which was now functioning as a staging area.
Simcha Katz — who had a genuinely lovely voice and had been performing at local events for years — was called Sunday morning. He was delighted, asked for a rehearsal track, and said he needed forty-five minutes to prepare.
Tehila Goldstein — who had been performing amateur magic since her Bat Mitzvah and had last year made the assistant rabbi's reading glasses disappear so completely they were never recovered — was called Sunday afternoon. She said yes before Devorah finished the sentence.
Decorations were sourced. Papel picado, streamers, a large paper-maché piñata in the shape of a donkey. Congregants were notified of the venue change by phone tree, two group texts, and one email blast. A subset of congregants who were on none of these lists would show up at the shul Monday night in sombreros and have to be redirected.
Monday was Taanit Esther. The fast began before dawn.
Devorah had not slept particularly well. She lay in the dark at six in the morning running the checklist: the band, the decorations, the sombreros, Simcha, Tehila, the salsa, the congregants, the venue — and the audit. Always back to the audit.
At nine forty-five she drove downtown and parked in front of Aura. The building was dark and unlit and looked, in the gray morning light, considerably less glamorous than its name suggested. Marvin Gross was already there, standing on the sidewalk with his briefcase, wearing a tie.
O'Donnell's accountant arrived at ten on the dot. He and Marvin shook hands with the formal courtesy of two men who understand that they are about to spend several hours looking at the same spreadsheets. They went inside.
Devorah waited in the car. She was fasting. She was running the checklist. She was wondering, not for the first time, whether she had forgotten something.
At twelve-fifteen, Marvin emerged. He walked to the car, opened the passenger door, and sat down. He placed his briefcase carefully on his knees.
"Well?" said Devorah.
"The Aura audit," said Marvin, with the quiet satisfaction of a man who has spent two hours in a dark nightclub verifying asset disclosures and found them entirely in order, "came through clean."
What followed was a controlled hurricane. The band arrived at three and set up. The caterer arrived at four with the food, the paper goods, and twenty-four sealed glass jars of salsa, which were distributed across the tables as centerpieces. The decorations went up in two hours, assembled by a rotating crew of shul members who had been waiting since Saturday night for something useful to do. The sombreros were transferred from Barry's garage to the cloakroom.
By six o'clock, the Aura nightclub looked like a Mexican wedding hall designed by someone who had also recently read the Megillah.
The LED lighting system, which Kevin O'Donnell had imported from a designer in Amsterdam, could cycle through every color in the spectrum and responded to sound levels. When the band struck up their first rehearsal chord at six-thirty, the lights shifted from gold to amber to a warm pulsing red, and the three people present for the sound check stood in silence for a moment, unexpectedly moved.
Megillah was read at the shul, as usual. The fast ended. People changed into costumes — an unusual number of sombreros, for reasons that had been thoroughly explained in the group texts — and made their way downtown.
Reverend Kenneth Callahan arrived at seven forty-five in his clerical collar, which he had decided was, under the circumstances, entirely appropriate. He accepted a ginger ale from the bar and stationed himself near the entrance, watching the room fill up with something that could only be described as wonder.
By eight-thirty, the Aura nightclub contained two hundred and forty-three Jews in various states of Mexican-themed costume, one Anglican vicar, and a paper-maché donkey that someone's child had already attempted to dismantle.
Simcha sang three songs using the state of the art sound system. The second brought down the house. The third — a Hebrew-Spanish medley — prompted a standing ovation and an encore.
Tehila Goldstein produced a glass jar of salsa from the center of the table, held it up so the whole room could see it was untampered, set it back down — and then, at the climax of her act, made Barry Sternberg's watch appear inside it. The jar was still sealed. Barry's watch was unambiguously visible through the glass.
The room erupted. Even Kevin O'Donnell, watching from near the bar with his arms folded, unfolded his arms.
It was, by any measure, a triumph.
Devorah found her husband by the dessert table at ten o'clock. She had a plate of rugelach she wasn't eating because she was still running the checklist. She had been running it all evening — between conversations, during the music, while watching Tehila's act — the quiet, methodical audit of a woman who had built the whole thing and knew exactly where every seam was.
The lights were cycling through something warm and golden. Reverend Callahan was explaining patiently to a group of skeptical teenagers that his collar was not, in fact, a Purim costume. Tehila was performing a card trick for eight-year-olds with the absolute gravity of someone defusing a bomb.
"Dovid," said Devorah quietly. "Do you think anything was missing tonight?"
Rabbi Horowitz looked out at the room for a long moment. Then he looked at his wife — who had taken a condemned shul roof, a blizzard, a reluctant Irishman, a nervous accountant, and forty-seven non-refundable sombreros, and turned them into this — and smiled.
"What else could you ask for? You did it all!
"The LA Youth Team 'oy-dit' of Aura, and Simcha, and salsa, Vicar Ken, Tehila — nu?"
The rebbetzin swatted her husband with her sombrero.
Have a happy and safe Purim!
!לַיְּהוּדִים הָיְתָה אוֹרָה וְשִׂמְחָה וְשָׂשׂוֹן וִיקָר" — כֵּן תִּהְיֶה לָּנוּ"
|
"He's an Anti-Zionist Too!" cartoon book (December 2024) PROTOCOLS: Exposing Modern Antisemitism (February 2022) |
 |
Buy