JPost Editorial: Genocide must be proven, not proclaimed, the ICJ ruling on Myanmar shows
Thursday’s judgment underscores why evidence of genocidal intent is indispensable. The court’s finding against Myanmar rested on its assessment of the conduct and circumstances of the campaign, not the number of people killed alone.Seth Mandel: The Holocaust’s Lessons Aren’t For Everyone
Israel, however, should not interpret the judgment as a straightforward vindication of its position.
Myanmar genocide ruling may complicate Israel's defense against South Africa
As The Jerusalem Post’s Yonah Jeremy Bob reported on Thursday, aspects of the decision could complicate Israel’s defense. The court took a broad view of evidence relevant to genocidal acts and intent, while maintaining that negligence, even gross negligence, does not itself establish genocide.
Israel’s legal team must therefore study the judgment carefully, particularly its treatment of political statements and the circumstances surrounding civilian suffering.
The ICJ has not cleared Israel of South Africa’s allegations. That case remains pending, and the court has not issued a final judgment on whether Israel violated the Genocide Convention. The provisional measures ordered earlier in those proceedings did not amount to a judicial finding that genocide had occurred.
Nevertheless, Thursday’s ruling should restore precision to a debate in which accusations of genocide are frequently treated as established conclusions before judicial proceedings have concluded.
South Africa is entitled to bring its case, and Israel is entitled to contest it. The court must assess both sides according to the evidence and the law, without allowing the conflict’s political intensity to substitute for either.
Calling every devastating military campaign genocide obscures the distinctions between atrocities. Equally, invoking legitimate military objectives cannot automatically negate evidence of genocidal intent where such evidence exists.
Court must seriously examine, investigate, and insist on standards for Israel case
The Rohingya deserve recognition of what was done to them, justice for those responsible, and an opportunity to rebuild their lives. Their suffering should not be reduced to a rhetorical instrument in arguments about another conflict.
Their case nevertheless demonstrates the seriousness with which accusations of genocide must be examined. South Africa has asked the ICJ to determine whether Israel committed that crime. Thursday’s ruling shows that the court can reach such a conclusion when it finds the legal requirements satisfied.
The response should be neither to prejudge Israel’s guilt nor to pretend its innocence has already been judicially established. It should be to insist upon the same rigorous standard of evidence, including proof of intent, for every state that stands accused.
The lesson for South Africa, Israel, and the international community is that genocide must be proven, not proclaimed.
The constant search for applicable “lessons” from the rise and rule of the Nazis is understandable but misdirected. Victims, not perpetrators and bystanders, ought to be the primary students of the modern world’s singular genocide.Seth Madnel: Get Your Own
As Clark’s review of Hoyer shows, the central question is how the emerging threats to the targeted community—in this case, as in many cases, Jews—are interpreted without the benefit of hindsight:
“The Nazis lacked a majority but had the leverage to secure the ministries of the interior and education for Wilhelm Frick. Frick made uninhibited use of his powers, sacking left-leaning and Jewish civil servants and replacing them with people loyal to the Nazis… Frick would eventually fall from power, once the parties of the centre recovered their will to act and joined forces against him. But the damage was done: there was no purge of the new appointees, and this brief experiment in Nazi governance revealed how weak the resistance to a more concerted assault on liberal-democratic norms was likely to be.”
Modern audiences tend to respond with something vague that they don’t actually mean about preserving liberal-democratic norms. But when they see a Hitler coming, they will be the first to argue that norms must be suspended in order to prevent the New Hitler from gaining power. The lesson for the Jews then and ever is: No one is coming to save you. So you must save yourself.
To read about the gathering storm clouds of anti-Jewish governance is to understand first and foremost that the Zionists were right and everyone else was wrong. It is to see clearly that the Palestinian Arab sin of preventing Jewish immigration to Jewish communities in the Jewish homeland must be reckoned with and atoned for the same way Vichy France had to be reckoned with and atoned for.
It is to comprehend the power and the glory of sovereignty and agency and self-determination.
And perhaps most of all, it is to know the importance of making everyone else’s “universal” lessons irrelevant.
When you rely on other people learning lessons, you make yourself vulnerable to self-interested partisanship. We just went through a series of elections in which people who rightly sounded the alarm about Trump’s enabling of anti-Semitic forces in 2016 enthusiastically supported Abdul El-Sayed, Zohran Mamdani, Adam Hamawy and Graham Platner. If your lesson from Nazi Germany is to back the guy with the Totenkopf who rants about Jews, I would like you to stop learning lessons altogether and also stay as far away from electoral politics as possible.
What matters most is what the Jews learned from the Holocaust. For that, all we need are the facts. And that is all historians should deliver.
Set aside the discredited “genocide” libel for a moment, which tinpot authoritarian demagogues use solely as a destabilizing provocation. His answer is: He won’t condemn a standalone massacre of innocent Jews because, three weeks later, Israel initiated a ground incursion into Gaza to get back its citizens that Palestinians took hostage.
Why won’t Mamdani let Jews mourn? Because he doesn’t believe they deserve to.
What’s happening here isn’t just rank anti-Semitism—that part’s undeniable. It’s that there’s an extra layer of creepiness to Mamdani’s statement: It’s stalkerish behavior, and it is characteristic of the wider Western “pro-Palestinian” movement.
Anti-Zionists like Mamdani want October 7 for themselves because the Jews have it. It’s the same reason there’s an imperialist dome along with a mosque built atop the Jews’ holy site in Jerusalem. It’s the same reason Palestinians and their advocates believe that only permitting Jews in 3 percent of Hebron—the four thousand year old Jewish city—is unfair to the Palestinians. And it’s the reason that Nakba Day was created the day after Israeli Independence Day. There is no real significance to the date aside from the naked appropriation of a day that was already meaningful to Jews.
That is also what the genocide libel is about. The comparisons of Israel’s military operations in Gaza to the Holocaust are a manifestation of trauma envy. It’s why the Chicago Tribune can print the following sentence last week about the newly renovated Illinois Holocaust Museum and Education Center: “The renovation did not add permanent museum content about the Hamas-led attack on Oct. 7, 2023, the largest mass killing of Jews since the Holocaust, or Israel’s resulting assault and siege on Gaza, which has been widely considered a genocide.”
Got it? The Holocaust museum did not add an exhibit on Gaza. The Holocaust museum remains a museum about the Holocaust.
Just as Israel remains the Jewish state, despite the desire of so many to confiscate the historic Jewish homeland for other purposes.
ICJ’s Myanmar genocide ruling draws scrutiny for implications for Israel case
Experts have been closely watching the International Court of Justice’s case against Myanmar for clues about how the court will handle South Africa’s separate genocide case against Israel, to discern whether Thursday’s historic ruling — the first time the ICJ has ever found a state responsible for genocide — could carry significant implications for the Gaza proceedings.UKLFI: Natasha Hausdorff Exposes Navi Pillay’s Double Standards on Israel and Hamas
The ICJ ruled 9-6 on Thursday that Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya during its military’s 2017 clearance operations in northern Rakhine state, finding that the military acted with intent to destroy a substantial part of the ethnic minority. The Gambian government brought the case in November 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention.
The ruling has raised concern and speculation about its potential impact on South Africa’s genocide case against Israel, which it filed in December 2023 alleging that Israel’s military campaign in Gaza violated the Genocide Convention. Israel has rejected the allegations, maintaining that its military operations have been directed at Hamas. The ICJ has issued three rounds of provisional measures but has not ruled on the merits. Israel submitted its written defense in March 2026, with South Africa’s next filing due Nov. 22, 2027, and Israel’s response due May 22, 2029.
Experts told Jewish Insider that the ruling could cut both ways for Israel, reaffirming the ICJ’s high threshold for establishing genocidal intent while offering guidance on how the court may evaluate competing military objectives and evidence in South Africa’s case against Israel. The decision could also have broader implications for how the court views the scale of violence, United Nations reporting and Israeli government accounts in the pending proceedings.
Alan Baker, the former legal advisor and deputy director-general of Israel’s Foreign Ministry and head of the International Law Program at the Jerusalem Center for Security and Foreign Affairs, told Jewish Insider, “I don’t think one has to exaggerate the implications of this Gambia-Myanmar ruling.”
“In principle, theoretically, there should not be any implications, because Israel has never had any intention of committing genocide against the people of Gaza,” he said. “Of course there are stupid statements by stupid ministers … but the court itself has said that to determine intent for genocide one has to judge actions, so theoretically, this shouldn’t influence the court’s ruling on Israel.”
A source who held international law positions in Israel’s government told JI that “the picture is mixed, even if [the Myanmar] decision is problematic. … The dissent was solid.”
The former government source pointed out that a decision on the Gaza case is unlikely before 2030 or even 2031 and that the court’s composition will be significantly different then.
Similarly, Baker explained that South Africa asked for an 18-month extension to try to find more evidence for its claim that Israel committed genocide, and as a result, Israel also received an 18-month extension.
“Who knows what will happen by then?” he said.
Still, Baker said one must “take into consideration that the court is a U.N. body and … the judges usually voice the political positions of the countries that appoint them. So despite the fact that it’s called the International Court of Justice, the elements of justice and it being a court is dependent on the positions the judges are ordered to take by their countries.”
In the ICJ, each side in a case may appoint an ad-hoc judge, and the Gambia chose Navi Pillay for its case against Myanmar. Pillay, this year’s Nobel Peace Prize laureate and former U.N. high commissioner for human rights, has courted controversy for years with anti-Israel statements, most recently accusing Israel of committing genocide in an interview with Haaretz. Pillay claimed that Israel killed 73,000 civilians, a figure that critics note includes combatants, and argued that the Oct. 7 attack was not genocidal.
Baker said that “all of [Pillay’s] efforts in this case have been to try to weaken the criteria for determining a genocidal intent with the ulterior motive of using it against Israel. Her whole career in recent years has been directed towards accusing Israel of genocide.”
Has Nobel Peace Prize recipient Navi Pillay abandoned impartial legal analysis in favour of double standards against Israel?
In this UKLFI Charitable Trust interview, its legal director, the barrister and international lawyer Natasha Hausdorff challenges Pillay's accusations against Israel, following the former UN human rights chief's controversial interview with Haaretz.
Pillay, who chaired the UN Commission of Inquiry into Israel and the Palestinian territories, has accused Israel of genocide in Gaza. Natasha questions her evidence, legal reasoning and application of international humanitarian law.
The discussion examines:
Genocide allegations: Why Israeli civilian evacuations, humanitarian assistance and vaccination campaigns are relevant to assessing genocidal intent.
Aerial bombardment: Why airstrikes are not inherently indiscriminate under international law.
Israeli teenagers: Natasha challenges Pillay's portrayal of Israeli military service and the IDF's obligations towards civilians.
Gaza casualties: Why distinguishing between civilian deaths and Hamas combatants is legally essential.
Hamas and October 7: Why Pillay's commission did not find genocidal intent in Hamas's atrocities, despite reaching that conclusion about Israel.
Israel's right to self-defence: Why Natasha rejects Pillay's suggestion that Israel should have relied on arrests and prosecutions rather than military action.
UN Commission of Inquiry: The UKLFI and UN Watch rebuttal of its October 2026 report, challenging its evidence, methodology and conclusions.
Nobel Peace Prize: Natasha questions Pillay's impartiality and the wider international legal establishment.
The interview also examines Pillay's reflections on genocide and collective behaviour, which Natasha argues expose contradictions in her approach.
CHAPTERS:
00:00 Navi Pillay, the Nobel Peace Prize and accusations against Israel
02:04 Genocide allegations, civilian evacuations and humanitarian aid
04:23 Aerial bombardment and international law
06:53 Are Israeli teenagers being trained to kill?
08:28 The claim that Israel killed 73,000 civilians
12:11 Hamas, October 7 and genocide
14:45 Israel's right to defend itself
17:22 Antisemitism, double standards and the Nobel Peace Prize
18:09 Criticism of the international legal establishment
19:00 Pillay's reflections on genocide
Call me Back: The ICJ Ruling That Could Change Israel Forever – with Andrew Fox
A genocide case against Myanmar at the International Court of Justice could expand the definition of genocide in ways that impact Israel’s own genocide case, brought by South Africa.
Andrew Fox, a military and legal expert, lays out for Dan how what happens if Myanmar is found guilty of genocide--and what Israel could do in the meantime to help prove its innocence.
"All the Right Words, for All the Wrong Reasons" That's a fitting title to describe the ICJ judgment published in the ๐ฌ๐ฒ v ๐ฒ๐ฒ genocide case today. And the expanded standards for an affirmative "genocide" finding expressed now have profound implications for @Israel years from now when the Court eventually publishes the merits judgment in the ๐ฟ๐ฆ v ๐ฎ๐ฑ case. The purpose of this post is to highlight how 3 specific aspects of today's judgment, taken together, drastically expand the circumstances pursuant to which the ICJ can derive an affirmative finding in cases brought before it pursuant to Article IX of the Genocide Convention as compared to jurisprudence that existed before today. These factors, in turn, inform the likelihood that the Court will return a similar affirmative finding against ๐ฎ๐ฑ later. Bottom line up front (as we frequently express in the military), or the tl;dr version (common parlance on social media) is this: The majority judgment of the ICJ is careful to give the impression that material aspects of the genocide standard remain consistent with existing jurisprudence. However, careful scrutiny reveals this judgment constitutes a significant expansion of that standard. This makes it far more likely that the Court will, in future, continue the precedent established today of concluding that genocide has occurred - even when this finding isn't necessarily convincingly the only reasonable inference. Given the present platform & the page length of the majority's judgment combined with the various separate & dissenting opinions, the present analysis cannot aspire to comprehensively cover every important aspect of today's decision. Instead, for present purposes I will focus on the 3 most important aspects involving the drastic expansion of the genocide standard developed today: 1) Clarification of the "only reasonable inference" standard; 2) Special regard for "independent" bodies such as fact-finding missions or commissions of inquiry appointed @UN; 3) The Court's understanding of the relationship between the commission of genocide and the practical application of the law of armed conflict (LOAC, or "international humanitarian law" in the Court's preferred parlance) Each of these considerations will be addressed below, in that order since each successive factor complements the one before it. 1) Clarification of the "only reasonable inference" standard This was perhaps the most anticipated aspect of today's judgment - with the exception of the final "genocide" determination - and for good reason. The existing "only reasonable inference" standard of proof is incredibly high, as it should be when a Court is determining whether the "crime of crimes" has been committed. The most relevant passages involving the application of this standard - in the present judgment & for future precedent - is ¶¶ 438-443 (pic 1). As the judgment recalls in ¶ 438 (green highlight), the "only reasonable inference" standard has previously been articulated by the Court in the 2007 Bosnia Judgment & 2015 Croatia Judgment. The Court then describes what each party to the dispute indicated in evidence they provided throughout the proceeding (¶¶ 439-40), as well as the views of select intervening states (¶ 441). In relation to intervening states, it is worth pointing out that what is referred to as the "joint Declaration" - from ๐จ๐ฆ๐ฉ๐ฐ๐ซ๐ท๐ฉ๐ช๐ณ๐ฑ๐ฌ๐ง - itself encourages a broader interpretation for "only reasonable inference" by suggesting this test should apply "only between alternative explanations that have been found to be reasonably supported by the evidence" (pic 1, blue highlight, which is a direct quote from ¶ 52 of the joint declaration - available here: https://t.co/o3oH36mxlL). This suggestion from these 6 countries is fundamentally at odds with the "only reasonable inference" standard because, by definition, if there are alternative explanations that have been found to be reasonable and the Court is selecting one rather than the other(s), it stands to reason that the inference selected was not the ONLY reasonable one. In any event, after explaining the precedential basis for the "only reasonable inference" standard & presenting various views presented to the Court on the subject throughout the proceeding, the judgment goes on to explain the Court's understanding of the test ( ¶¶ 442-43). This is where the judgment goes off the rails - at least in terms of existing jurisprudence - while giving the impression that nothing has changed at all. According to today's judgment, "When some elements of the evidentiary record may allow additional intentions to be inferred, but the totality of the evidence can only be explained by the perpetrator's genocidal intent, the only reasonable inference standard is met" (pic 1, red, emphasis added). Now, you can see from the text I italicized that this passage refers to the existing standard: "only reasonable inference." However, this is the first time the Court has ever explicitly added a totality of the evidence component to this existing standard, and this represents the subtle - though significant - departure from previous jurisprudence. This subtle change is significant because ... there is no mention of a process for independently evaluating the individual aspects of evidence consulted to aggregate this new "totality" standard. So, dozens of separate pieces of information can now be aggregated - whether or not each one is individually credible & whether or not each one itself supports the inference of genocidal intent - together to represent the "totality of the circumstances". This can then be regarded as the "only reasonable inference" of genocidal intent, thereby displacing all other potentially reasonable inferences, and this is now sufficient to support an affirmative finding of genocide. The problem here, of course, is that the Court has maintained the existing "only reasonable inference" standard on the surface, but it has now fundamentally altered how it will apply that existing standard - and it has done so in a manner that drastically elevates the prospect of an affirmative finding. The joint dissent of 6 judges published along with the main judgment raises this issue, but the separate dissent of Judge Sebutinde presents the most compelling objection to this new approach that uses existing terminology. As she observes, the "totality" standard cannot "transform evidence capable of supporting a reasonable inference of genocidal intent into proof that genocide is the only reasonable inference. Where the evidentiary record continues reasonably to support a non-genocidal explanation of the established conduct, its cumulative character cannot cure that deficiency" (¶ 78, part of the broader discussion from ¶¶ 67-78). Another problem with this implicit expansion of the "only reasonable inference" standard is that there is ample evidence in the public record regarding how it is applied in practice. For example, the first @UN Commission of Inquiry report to accuse ๐ฎ๐ฑ of "genocide" claimed that the "pattern of conduct" observed from Israeli officials was the "only reasonable inference that could be drawn from the totality of the circumstances" (pic 2, top). However, careful scrutiny of this analysis reveals that individual elements of "evidence" either themselves do not indicate that genocidal intent is the "only reasonable inference" and much of that evidence is itself of questionable reliability. In the context of the September 2025 UN CoI report that adopts the "totality of the circumstances" standard while accusing ๐ฎ๐ฑ of "genocide" reveals that Judge Sebutinde's caution that this standard cannot "transform evidence capable of supporting a reasonable inference of genocidal intent into proof that genocide is the only reasonable inference" applies just as much to the CoI "finding" as it does to the majority judgment in the present case. For another example of the "totality of the circumstances" standard that adopts a similar methodology, consider the "Subhuman" report published by @amnesty in Dec 2024 that uses the exact same terminology to accuse ๐ฎ๐ฑ of genocide (sec 7.4, https://t.co/rpBXnY13uW). What the Court has done today, then, is purport to retain the "only reasonable inference" standard from existing jurisprudence while adding the "totality of the circumstances" method of applying that existing standard. In doing so, it aligns ICJ jurisprudence with entities such as the UN CoI and Amnesty International that have demonstrated in practice that this represents a broader method for deriving an affirmative "genocide" finding - while still referring to the "only reasonable inference" standard. One consideration that makes this development even more troubling is the first time the ICJ has adopted the "totality of the circumstances" standard to supplement the "only reasonable inference" test, which is adopted verbatim from the UN CoI report that has previously accused Israel of committing genocide is that the ad hoc judge appointed by The Gambia for this case is none other than Navi Pillay - who also happened to be the chair of that Commission in September 2025 when that report was published. It is of course reasonable to consider whether it was appropriate in the first instance to allow Pillay to remain on a panel of judges that would be in a position to shape ICJ jurisprudence in Gambia v Myanmar, which will of course go on to impact the outcome of the South Africa v Israel case later, when she was also chair of a UN Commission that already has formally accused Israel of genocide in 2025. That prospect may have been abstract before today. But now that the ICJ has adopted the "totality of the circumstances" standard to augment the existing "only reasonable inference" test, and this modification is taken verbatim from the same UN Commission of Inquiry report that has already formally accused Israel of genocide, concern regarding the independence of the ICJ today in relation to the merits judgment to come in South Africa v Israel is no longer theoretical. This is especially concerning considering how the ICJ conveyed today the particular weight it is prepared to ascribe to "reports by international organizations that are specifically mandated to monitor the situation in a given area" (¶ 99). 2) Special regard for "independent" bodies such as fact-finding missions or commissions of inquiry appointed by the UN. Once again, this is a seemingly subtle new development for what at first glance appears to be an existing standard. In today's judgment, the Court begins a section called "third-party fact-finding" (p. 37) by observing: "In evaluating evidence from third-party fact-finding, the Court has generally considered the independence and qualifications of the author, the methodology used in the preparation of the evidence, and the comprehensive nature and overall quality of the evidence" (¶ 97). The Court then recalls 3 factors established in previous genocide jurisprudence it will utilize to evaluate the weight that should be afforded to such third-party reports: "Their value depends, among other things, on (1) the source of the item of evidence (for instance partisan, or neutral), (2) the process by which it has been generated (for instance an anonymous press report or the product of a careful court or court-like process), and (3) the quality or character of the item (such as statements against interest, and agreed or uncontested facts)" (citing 2007 Bosnia Judgment ¶ 227 & 2015 Croatia Judgment ¶ 190). No big deal, right? The Court in Myanmar, after all, is just applying precedent established in previous genocide judgments, is it not? Actually, it isn't. But before considering what has changed, it is useful to pause to reflect on what is different regarding the various third-party fact-finding mechanisms over the years. In general, these reports used to be fairly conservative in their factual determinations and legal conclusions. For example, a 1992 UN special rapporteur report that included an assessment of activity in the former Yugoslavia (E/CN.4/1993/46) observed "a certain reluctance in the international community to use the term 'genocide', even when reference is made to situations of particularly grave violations of the right to life which seem to clearly match the criteria contained in the" Genocide Convention (¶ 687). That report then suggests, "All measures should be taken to prevent acts of communal violence from degenerating into large-scale killings that may reach the dimension of genocide." Building on that rapporteur's work, a subsequent Special Rapporteur for the Situation of human rights in the territory of the former Yugoslavia, Tadeusz Mazowiecki, submitted a number of reports on that situation to the Human Rights Commission. Although this extensive work output suggested atrocities such as war crimes & ethnic cleansing had been committed, no allegation of "genocide" was ever included in these reports. Likewise, in relation to the situation in Myanmar, a UN fact-finding mission concluded "there is sufficient information to warrant the investigation and prosecution of senior officials in the Tatmadaw chain of command, so that a competent court can determine their liability for genocide in relation to the situation in Rakhine State," this recommendation stops short of explicitly alleging Myanmar is responsible for genocide (A/HRC/39/64, ¶ 87, emphasis added). Although the ICJ appears to be simply continuing with existing jurisprudence in relation to how third-party reports are regarded, it is worth remembering that the UN CoI assigned to report on Israel's conduct has repeatedly & explicitly alleged Israel has and continues to commit genocide. This is composition of third-party reports is fundamentally different than anything the ICJ has encountered before - including in the Myanmar situation for which it issued its judgment today. With that unique landscape in mind, let's return to the matter of whether the ICJ truly has merely continued with its existing jurisprudence in relation to third-party fact-finding mechanisms. Once again, the change in approach appears subtle yet it is actually rather profound in practice. That's because today, for the first time in a genocide case, the ICJ has adopted the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact" standard to apply when the applicant experiences various challenges in acquiring evidence to provide to the Court. Now, the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact" standard was initially adopted in the Corfu Channel cases merits judgment from 1949 (p. 18). It was then applied as well in the DRC v. Uganda reparations judgment (2002, ¶ 157) and, more recently, in the Ukraine v. Russia (ICSFT & CERD) judgment (2024, ¶ 169). As the Court explained in the latter reference (๐บ๐ฆ v ๐ท๐บ), "The Court has also recognized that a State that is not in a position to provide direct proof of certain facts 'should be allowed a more liberal recourse to inferences of fact and circumstantial evidence' (citing Corfu Channel & DRC v Uganda). Seems fairly consistent with previous jurisprudence as well, right? WRONG. And that's because the Court has explicitly refused to apply the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact" standard in previous genocide cases. For example, in the Bosnia judgment (2007), the Court notes that the applicant acknowledged it bears the burden of proof to demonstrate that genocide had been committed by the respondent. However, under the particular circumstances of that case, the applicant contended "that in certain respects the onus should be reversed, especially in respect of the attributability of alleged acts of genocide to the Respondent, given the refusal of the Respondent to produce the full text of certain documents" (¶ 204). In refusing to endorse this suggestion, the Court noted it had "long recognized that claims against a State involving charges of exceptional gravity must be proved by evidence that is fully conclusive" and therefore it must "be fully convinced that allegations made in the proceedings, that the crime of genocide or the other acts enumerated in Article III have been committed, have been clearly established" (¶ 209). In the Bosnia judgment, then, the Court could have extended the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact" standard from Corfu Channel when the applicant claims its efforts to meet the applicable burden of proof have been frustrated by, for example, refusal of the respondent to cooperate. The Court refused to do so given the "exceptional gravity" of the genocide allegation. In that case, then-vice president Al-Khasawneh even directly criticized the refusal to adopt the "more liberal recourse" standard from Corfu Channel in his dissenting opinion (¶ 34). For the next genocide case, Croatia (2015), the Court once again had occasion to consider adopting the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact" standard in a circumstance wherein the applicant complained of challenges meeting the burden of proof due to exclusive control by the respondent of relevant evidence (¶ 170). Once again, the Court declined (¶ 174). That jurisprudential precedent regarding the burden of proof specific to genocide cases changed today when the Court endorsed the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact." In relation to third-party fact-finding mechanisms, the Court observes: "As a general rule, a State is not obliged to grant United Nations mechanisms access to its territory. The Court has found, however, that in cases where one of the parties exercises exclusive control over a territory, rendering the other party 'unable to furnish direct proof of facts giving rise to responsibility', the latter State 'should be allowed a more liberal recourse to inferences of fact and circumstantial evidence'" (¶ 130, emphasis added). In this passage, the Court cites to previous decisions in Corfu Channel & DRC v Uganda & Ukraine v Russia for support. And, it is of course true that these cases do implement the "more liberal recourse" standard. What the Court fails to mention today, though, is that this is a departure from prior precedent specific to genocide cases in which it has explicitly refused to adopt this test given the "exceptional gravity" of genocide allegations. Continuing on the same topic, this is how the Court justifies the new precedent set today: "In the present case, neither the Applicant nor the United Nations fact-finding bodies on which The Gambia substantially relies had access to evidence within the territory where the alleged acts occurred. The Court observes that The Gambia is thus at a disadvantage with respect to direct access to certain kinds of evidence. Accordingly, in the assessment of the evidentiary record, the Court takes into account both Myanmar’s failure to genuinely investigate the alleged atrocities itself (see paragraphs 511-516 and 553 below) and its refusal to allow access to evidence and witnesses in its territory and to respond to the requests of the fact-finding bodies established by the United Nations to investigate the matter" (¶ 131). That passage explains the new precedent, and here is the new precedent that has now been extended to genocide cases for the first time in ICJ history : "The Court may therefore have more liberal recourse to inferences of fact in relation to events with respect to which Myanmar has largely or wholly exclusive knowledge and for which it has not provided a satisfactory and convincing explanation (see paragraph 111 above)" (also ¶ 131, emphasis added). At first glance, then, the ICJ maintains the "only reasonable inference" standard that has also been established by prior precedent in genocide cases. However, it has now added a "totality of the circumstances" component that allows consideration of factors that do not individually support an inference of genocide. And the Court has now extended the "more liberal recourse" standard that was previously excluded from genocide cases for circumstances in which the respondent refused to cooperate with third-party fact-finding mechanisms. This "more liberal recourse" standard will work in tandem with the "totality of the circumstances" standard to dilute the "only reasonable inference" test - all while the Court claims it has remained consistent with existing precdent. Given that Israel has not cooperated with the UN Commission of Inquiry, the Court can now also be expected to extend the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact" standard that did not apply to genocide cases before today. And with a more activist Commission of Inquiry than has ever been considered for previous genocide cases (Bosnia, Croatia, and now The Gambia), the "more liberal recourse to inferences of fact" standard will almost certainly result in far greater evidentiary value being given to a third-party fact-finding mechanism that has persistently & strenuously insisted ๐ฎ๐ฑ is responsible for genocide in #Gaza. One additional reason this is especially troubling is that the extraordinarily low standard of proof - "reasonable grounds" - adopted by the CoI (pic 2, top) allows it to make findings of fact & conclusions of law based on shockingly little evidence. For example, in the "essence of childhood" conference room paper published by the Commission in June 2026 alleging (among other accusations) @IDF troops deliberately targeted children as additional evidence of "genocide", the CoI conveys factual circumstances claiming children in Gaza were shot by Israeli quadcopters (pic 3). However, no source - including the Commission - has conclusively established that ๐ฎ๐ฑ even operates quadcopters with "sniper rifles." And the evidence relied on by the report includes testimony that was conveyed from family members to medical professionals then from medical professionals to the Commission, as well as projectiles the Commission says medical professionals told them were extracted from the victims / patients. This "double hearsay" is arguably insufficient to meet even the "reasonable grounds" standard of proof. Yet the Commission of Inquiry has determined it does, while this & similar evidence of questionable credibility has been aggregated to reach the conclusion that ๐ฎ๐ฑ has committed genocide. Now, the Court has affirmed that it will "not ascribe any probative value to the legal assessments contained" in third-party fact-finding reports (¶ 100, emphasis added). Even so, the new "totality of the circumstances" & "more liberal recourse" standards, combined with the fact that ๐ฎ๐ฑ has routinely refused to cooperate with the UN CoI, mean the findings of fact developed by the Commission will almost certainly be regarded as far more probative than ever before. Since the UN CoI has already determined, on the basis of the "totality of the circumstances" (which the ICJ adopted for the first time today) that ๐ฎ๐ฑ is responsible for genocide, it is reasonable to expect the ICJ will reach the same conclusion based on the same facts - and now implementing the same standards. 3) The Court's understanding of the relationship between genocide and LOAC. One additional section that warrants particular attention for this initial analysis is the manner in which the judgment today engages with the relationship between genocide & what the Court refers to as international humanitarian law (or, according to one's preference - including mine - the law of armed conflict) (¶¶ 296-305). Given the already rather extensive analysis presented in the two preceding points, for present purposes I will simply raise this issue then defer a full analysis until a later date. At the end of this section, the judgment indicates: "The Court concludes that although compliance with another body of international law, including [IHL], may inform the identification of intent with respect to the actus reus of genocide, as well as genocidal intent, such compliance does not exclude conduct from the scope of the Genocide Convention" (¶ 305, emphasis added). From a doctrinal perspective, this passage is concerning because LOAC compliance is actually fairly compelling evidence that intent is not to destroy a civilian population, in whole or in part, as such. And it is particularly troubling given how incompetent the ICJ has historically been when interpreting & applying LOAC as it exists in doctrine (see, for example, ¶ 304, which adopts an error from the 2015 Croatia genocide judgment by articulating the LOAC proportionality rule on a campaign level based on incidental damage "caused" rather than on the intent of personnel responsible for each attack to be analyzed). ___ Much more to come in the days & weeks ahead. As an initial matter, the intent of the above analysis is to identify & clarify the subtle shifts in existing precedent that can combine to have a profound impact on the merits at the ICJ in ๐ฟ๐ฆ v ๐ฎ๐ฑ in future.
— Dr. Brian L. Cox (@BrianCox_RLTW) November 20, 2026
What is it like to be Jewish and living in Ireland?
Naomi Handler has called Ireland home for two decades.David Collier: Open Response to Free Press Unlimited
She's among the estimated 2,000 Jewish people living in the country - but has questioned her place in it over the past three years.
A mezuzah, a parchment scroll with a prayer from the Torah, common in Jewish homes, hangs by her front door. "Should I remove it?" she asks.
She is one of a number of Jews who say their experiences of life in the Republic of Ireland have changed since the war in Gaza began.
The conflict was triggered by the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on 7 October 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 were taken hostage.
Since then, more than 74,700 people have been killed in Israel's military response in Gaza, according to the territory's Hamas-run health ministry.
The Irish government condemned the 7 October attack - but it has been a sharp critic of Israel and is a firm supporter of a Palestinian state, independent of Israel.
Pro-Palestinian sentiment is common in Irish society too.
A campaign to stop the Irish international football team playing Israel; the country's public service broadcaster boycotting Eurovision due to Israel's participation; and a sell-out "Free Palestine" concert by US rapper Macklemore in Dublin are just a few examples.
'We've considered moving'
Handler says there seems to be a "collective blame" of Jewish people.
"Should I stop wearing my Star of David? Should I not stop wearing the Star of David necklace? Thoughts that I never had prior to 7 October.
"Ireland was always safe. Ireland is safe. And I still feel, technically speaking, physically safe. Mentally, I'm not necessarily there."
The Irish government's response to the war in Gaza has strained diplomatic relations with Israel to breaking point and Israel closed its embassy in Dublin nearly two years ago. A group of several male Jewish leaders, each wearing formal suits or coats, gather next to a stone monument in Herzog Park in Dublin. One of the men, Maurice Cohen, the President of the Jewish Representative Council of Ireland, who has short, grey hair and a short, grey beard and wears glasses and a grey suit jacket over a white shirt, stands at the front of the group as he reads from a page.
Handler, who was born in Poland, says she has discussed leaving Ireland with her husband "many times".
"My husband has an American citizenship. We considered that. We considered moving to Israel.
"I think that the big conversation was: where is safe? And that's the trick question. It doesn't feel safe anywhere."
I have just received a “right to reply” email from an organisation called Free Press Unlimited.Tikvah: Ted Cruz on Jews and the Future of American Conservatism
Reading it, I get the impression that another heavily government-funded NGO is preparing a report about a shadowy network of Jews, and those who defend them, supposedly working together in a sinister campaign to corrupt the world’s morals and get away with murder.
It is an ancient antisemitic trope repackaged for modern consumption. Once upon a time, Jews were accused of murdering Jesus. In the modern version, Jesus has been replaced by Palestinian children, medical workers or, in this particular case, journalists.
The underlying narrative remains depressingly familiar: Jews operating through a coordinated network, manipulating information, concealing wrongdoing and conspiring to escape accountability for terrible crimes.
The accusers also remain familiar: a group of morally superior people in Europe, afforded power by the state, who believe they belong to a “community of the good” and seek to ostracise all non-believers. That their targets just happen to be mostly Jews – representing just 0.2% of the world’s population – is pure coincidence, of course.
Free Press Unlimited is a Dutch organisation that claims to defend press freedom. And apparently, because of my work exposing the terror ties of some people wearing press jackets in Gaza, I am among those Jews it has decided to smear.
What appears to be taking shape is an attempt to demonise Jews and those who defend Israel, portray independent investigations as part of a coordinated Israeli campaign – because apparently Jews cannot possess independent agency – and whitewash Gazans wearing press jackets whose documented ties to terrorist organisations deserve serious scrutiny.
Rather than confront the evidence, or actually defend “press freedom”, the apparent objective of Free Press Unlimited is to discredit journalists who are working to discover the truth.
I have published FPU’s email in full for anyone interested in reading it.
As is my style, I have absolutely no intention of responding to their half-baked, inconsistent and, in places, truly absurd allegations in a manner that allows them to cherry-pick my words, butcher my arguments or strip my response of context.
So I am responding publicly, where everyone can read their questions, my answers and the supporting evidence in full – and judge for themselves.
I hope you enjoy the ride.
Anti-Semitism is rising on the left, Senator Ted Cruz says. He's even more worried about what he sees on the right.
Two weeks after the midterm elections, Cruz joined Jonathan Silver at the Jewish Leadership Conference in New York for a wide-ranging conversation about where American conservatism goes next. He explains why he stands with Israel, as a matter of faith and, he argues, of American national security. He calls anti-Semitism on the right an existential threat to the country, and outlines how's seeking to counter it. He also lays out the newly-enacted school choice provision he says will fund tens of billions of dollars in scholarships, among much else.
This conversation was held in New York City at Tikvah's Jewish Leadership Conference on November 15, 2026.
00:00—Why Cruz Stands With Israel
02:03—Anti-Semitism on the Left and the Right
07:02—After the Midterms: The Red-State Model
10:26—The Frontline: Fighting Anti-Semitism in the GOP
15:27—School Choice: The $1,700 Tax Credit
23:36—Islam, Islamism, and Religious Liberty
28:14— “Politics Is a Pendulum”: A Hopeful Message
Democrats label any examination of Islamist politics ‘Islamophobic’
Independent Women’s Forum Senior Fellow Dr Qanta Ahmed says investigating Islamist politics in the United States has been difficult due to Democrats considering it as Islamophobic.
She’s absolutely right! Zionism is for ‘builders’, anti-Zionism is for’whiners’, says @EinatWilf, speaking at the Jerusalem Post summit in Sydney. https://t.co/yPGx5Dztk3
— Arsen Ostrovsky (@Ostrov_A) November 20, 2026
Fetterman Challenger Ahmed Moor Called for ‘Upending the Jewish State,’ Likened Israeli Children to ‘Hitler Youth’
Ahmed Moor, a progressive who recently launched a U.S. Senate bid in Pennsylvania, repeatedly called for upending the Jewish state, compared Israeli children to “Hitler youth,” and floated an “ethnic cleanse” of Zionists to liberate Palestinians, according to a National Review analysis of over a decade of Moor’s writings.
While Senator John Fetterman has yet to say whether he will seek reelection in 2028, Moor announced his bid for the seat last week, launching his insurgent campaign just days after Democrats secured historic victories in the midterms.
Appearing on Fox News shortly after launching his campaign, Moor, a 42-year-old dues-paying democratic socialist from Philadelphia, was asked whether he would condemn Hamas, the terrorist group that has governed Gaza since 2006 and launched the October 7, 2023, attacks that killed over 1,200 Israelis.
“It’s a bad faith question,” Moor told Fox’s Martha MacCallum. “I’m not going to engage with that. I’m going to focus on the American national interest. I think we need an independent foreign policy. Americans on [the] left and right are done with Israel. We’re done with the tail wagging the dog.”
Moor’s writing through the years tells a story of not just apathy towards Hamas, but hedged support for the terrorist group and others like it.
Regina Spektor was just 9 years old when her family fled the Soviet Union to escape Jewish persecution. She came to America without knowing a single word of English. Her family left behind everything they owned for a chance to live free as Jews. Regina, a musical prodigy, spent years practicing on the piano at her local synagogue because her family could not afford one of their own. And in five seconds, Bowen Yang - a barely talented hack - reduced this extraordinary woman’s entire life, her family’s sacrifices, and her accomplishments to a single word: “Zio.” A slur rooted in the same Soviet antisemitic propaganda Regina’s family fled. Imagine being so indoctrinated that you casually recycle Soviet antisemitism to mock a woman who actually survived it. What an arrogant, ignorant little prick. https://t.co/k4p6tfc9lZ
— The Persian Jewess (@persianjewess) November 20, 2026
These little hypocrites spend HOURS crying about the homophobia they’ve experienced, yet have ZERO problem being openly hostile, judgmental and dismissive toward JEWS. Watch Bowen Yang, Matt Rogers & some dump truck lady go after the ICONIC Regina Spektor because she supports the Jewish State of ISRAEL. LQBTQ members demand tolerance, acceptance & respect for themselves but apparently JEWS don’t deserve the same. Bowen,Matt & this dump truck lady would be tossed off buildings in Gaza while Disco music played. The HYPOCRISY is DISGUSTING.
— MichaelRapaport (@MichaelRapaport) November 19, 2026
And right after Bowen Yang’s “apology,” he posted “At the same time, Free Palestine. ๐ต๐ธ” He thinks that apologizing for antisemitism requires him to say the mantra… which essentially means he is an antisemite who was just forced to apologize, but of course he doesn’t mean it. https://t.co/yiJH20NtR1
— Michael Elgort (@just_whatever) November 20, 2026
US should strip visa from Jew-hating, British Christian preacher in Michigan, Jewish legal group says
The American Association of Jewish Lawyers and Jurists wrote to Yehuda Kaploun, a rabbi and U.S. special envoy to monitor and combat antisemitism at the State Department, urging the federal government to review the visa status of Calvin Robinson, a British cleric who is rector at St. Paul’s Church in Grand Rapids, Mich.
St. Paul’s which was founded in the 19th century as part of the Episcopal Church, seceded from that church in 1980 and after subsequently joining the Anglican Catholic Church, it voted to leave that body too in 2025. It is now part of the Christian Episcopal Church, according to its website.
Robinson, who joined the church as priest-in-charge in 2024 and became rector in 2025, has advocated for “driving out the Jews” from the United States.
JNS viewed the letter that the Jewish legal association sent to Kaploun. “Robinson’s remarks betray not only a disturbing hostility toward Jews but a breathtaking ignorance of American history and the principles upon which this republic was founded,” states the letter, which Robert Garson, president of the association, signed.
Garson has represented U.S. President Donald Trump in litigation and was appointed by Trump to the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Council.
“His vision is not merely antisemitic. It is fundamentally un-American,” the letter states.
On Nov. 13, Robinson was a guest on the podcast of white nationalist Joe Enders. “We can talk about mass deportation of Mohammedans,” meaning Muslims, “and other peoples that are contradictory to our own way of life in Christendom, but we can’t discuss it in terms of the Jews,” Robinson said on the podcast. “I think driving out the Jews is the answer.”
In the letter, Garson wrote at length about the long history of Jewish contributions to the United States and to the country’s early roots in Judaism and the importance that George Washington placed on religious freedom.
This girl was an Elizabeth Warren staffer Now doing 2016 alt right posting but as a leftie.
— Drew Pavlou ๐ฆ๐บ๐บ๐ธ๐ซ๐ท๐บ๐ฆ๐น๐ผ (@DrewPavlou) November 20, 2026
A few years ago Calla wrote for the Irish Times decrying Irish-American neo-Nazis. Now she is espousing neo-Nazi falsehoods herself. Unbelievable, yet eminently believable. https://t.co/Fl8Yk0Rib6
— Rachel Moiselle (@RachelMoiselle) November 20, 2026
Danny Burmawi explains: "I keep hearing that Israel wants to destroy all the neighboring countries because Israel wants to be the greatest country. So I wonder why they are helping the economy of the United Arab Emirates. It doesn't make sense to me. I wonder why they are trying to make peace with Saudi Arabia, not destroy Saudi Arabia. I wonder why they give Jordan, my country, water. My mother today, this morning, when she drank water, she drank water because of Israel. So I wonder why they never attacked Egypt after 1979." Ana Kasparian articulately responds: "Get the fuck out of my country. Seriously, this disgusting Zionist garbage."
— Max ๐ (@MaxNordau) November 20, 2026
Spanish court frees pro-Palestine donor, millionaire James Cox Chamber Jr. over FBI translation
Spain's High Court has released pro-Palestinian donor and US media heir James Cox Chambers Jr. on conditional bail, while it considers an extradition request by the United States, according to a court ruling released on Friday.‘Extremist propagandist’ jailed after planning militant pro-Palestinian group
The court said it had decided to release Chambers after US authorities acknowledged what they described as substantial and unintentional errors in the Spanish translation of an FBI agent's sworn statement submitted in support of the extradition request.
Chambers, whose family owns Cox Enterprises, was arrested at the request of US authorities on July 10 while on holiday in Ibiza. He has been held in custody on accusations including riot, conspiracy to commit riot and international money laundering. Chambers, known as Fergie, denies wrongdoing.
After a hearing last week, the court had been expected to rule on the extradition request in the coming weeks, but it said on Friday that the translation errors could delay a final decision.
Judges said the issue could be relevant to the outcome of the proceedings because it raised questions about the accuracy of documents provided by US authorities and could weaken, at least temporarily, the basis for the extradition request.
Must report weekly to court, surrender passport, remain in Spain
Chambers must report weekly to a local court, surrender his passport, remain in Spain, provide an address and appear before the High Court whenever summoned.
The case is politically sensitive for Spain's Socialist-led government, whose strong pro-Palestinian stance has drawn criticism from the administration of US President Donald Trump and added to wider tensions with Washington.
If the court approves the extradition, Spain's cabinet will make the final decision.
Separately, Chambers' lawyers said they were challenging a raid by Irish police on his family home in Dublin, which they said was conducted at the request of US authorities and involved the seizure of electronic devices and other property. His legal team said it would seek judicial review unless authorities clarify the legal basis for the operation.
A man who has been jailed for a terrorism offence after making plans to set up a militant pro-Palestinian organisation has been described as a “propagandist for an extremist ideology”.Palestine protest at Manchester Maccabi ‘smacks of anti-Jewish racism,’ says former FA chair
Sean Grant was jailed for four years and six months after admitting collecting information likely to be useful to a person preparing an act of terrorism.
A judge said his plans for attacks on police and British Army targets could have had “catastrophic” consequences had they been realised.
Grant was first arrested in August 2025 after police visited his flat in Musselburgh, East Lothian on another matter and found reading material related to terrorist organisations.
Further searches found 10 Airsoft smoke grenades and five boxes of ‘flashbang’ pyrotechnics, as well as handwritten plans to set up a militant pro-Palestine group which detailed various types of action to be taken against police officers.
Police found other publications useful to people preparing acts of terrorism.
At the High Court in Glasgow, Lord Arthurson imposed a nine-year sentence, with the 22-year-old ordered to spend four and a half years of this in custody.
Lord Arthurson noted that Grant’s notes contained “plans for a new pro-Palestinian militant organisation utilising a cell structure, listing among other matters ‘weapons for street fighting’”.
It also described a campaign of attacks against police targets and British Army recruitment centres.
The judge said: “It goes without saying that had your plans been realised, the potential consequences could have been catastrophic.”
Former Football Association chairman David Bernstein has condemned a protest outside a Maccabi youth sports centre in Manchester, saying the demonstration “smacks of anti-Jewish racism”.
The shadow sports minister has echoed the condemnation, saying the demonstration was “disgraceful”.
Bernstein, also former chairman of Manchester City, spoke out after pro-Palestinian demonstrators gathered outside Maccabi Community and Sports Club in Prestwich on Sunday evening.
Members of the Jewish community, including children, were playing football at the grounds.
The protest involving around 12 to 20 people carrying Palestinian flags and placards.
Greater Manchester Police (GMP) attended the scene following reports of the demonstration and moved protesters away from the immediate area. No arrests were made.
However, the force has since classified the protest as a non-crime hate incident following concerns raised by members of the Jewish community.
Bernstein, who was the FA’s first Jewish chairman and led the organisation between 2011 and 2013, described the demonstration as part of a wider pattern of intimidation against British Jewish institutions.
On the eve of Kristallnacht, a group of anti-Israel activists organised a protest targeting Jewish-owned businesses in Philadelphia. NBC covered the demonstration… but left out some crucial context. @jessisajew has the real story: https://t.co/1EljPwSjZG
— CAMERA (@CAMERA4Truth) November 20, 2026
They did a spontaneous march that caused chaos in the city centre and police were utterly unable to stop it. Here they are chanting for “demilitarisation”. Whatever that means. https://t.co/t2qSImaxeL
— Heidi Bachram (@HeidiBachram) November 20, 2026
Meanwhile in London the ‘youth’ are chanting “All cops are b*stards” at police. I can’t imagine anyone else getting away with this. https://t.co/drdeNlhXEF
— Heidi Bachram (@HeidiBachram) November 20, 2026
This ‘youth striker’ compared the London police to Nazis in the Holocaust and a Jewish man called him out for it. Watch the protester get aggressive and try to attack him. Scary. ๐ฅ @fatdafevy https://t.co/gIC6ulz5Fe
— Heidi Bachram (@HeidiBachram) November 20, 2026
Anti-Israel law student group sues Berkeley for denying it official recognition
Law Students for Justice in Palestine and three of its members sued the regents of the University of California and four university officials on Wednesday, claiming that the University of California, Berkeley School of Law violated their First Amendment rights by denying the group official recognition over a bylaw barring Zionist speakers.Palestinian Authority co-opts Jerusalem bagel to claim Israel’s capital
In the complaint, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, the group said it sought official recognition on Aug. 24, but the law school required its bylaws to “contain no restriction on who may speak at the organization’s events.”
In 2022, the group adopted bylaws excluding Zionist speakers. The Louis D. Brandeis Center for Human Rights Under Law sued in November 2023. It reached a settlement with the school in March.
Berkeley and the center were divided on what they agreed to in a settlement. Berkeley said that it will prevent student groups from banning speakers and limiting “officers, board members or speakers based on a category that is protected under federal or state law.” The agreement text made clear that “Zionist” doesn’t constitute a protected class but adds that “Zionist” can often be a code word used to discriminate against “Jews” or “Israelis,” both of which are protected groups.
Law Students for Justice in Palestine states in its bylaws that, as an expression of its “political commitment to Palestinian liberation and anti-Zionism, and consistent with its commitment to BDS, LSJP will not invite speakers that have expressed and continued to hold views or host/sponsor/promote events in support of Zionism, the apartheid state of Israel and the occupation of Palestine.”
The group stated in the complaint that it tried to register as a recognized student organization in August 2026, but “for the first time in LSJP’s 20-year existence,” the law school required it to confirm its bylaws “contain no restriction on who may speak at the organization’s event.”
UNESCO’s Intangible Heritage Committee will meet in China for its 21st session at the end of the month (Nov. 30-Dec. 5). Among the decisions it will make is whether to accept the Jerusalem bagel as the unique cultural property of “Palestine.”
On Sept. 23, 2025, the Palestinian Authority nominated ka’ak al-Quds, or Jerusalem sesame bread, better known as the Jerusalem bagel, as part of the “State of Palestine’s” cultural heritage.
In its UNESCO submission, the P.A. described ka’ak al-Quds as “a popular, light, and delicious bakery item for which the city of Jerusalem is famous. It is considered a symbol of the city’s heritage and religious identity.”
It added that Palestinians from Jerusalem are considered the main group who are “bearers of this craft.”
Asaf Rosset, vice president of Preserving the Eternal, an Israeli NGO that focuses on protecting and developing heritage sites in Judea and Samaria, told JNS: “The Palestinian attempt to appropriate the Jerusalem bagel, a pastry whose various versions are widespread throughout the Middle East, and whose origins date back much earlier than the invention of Palestinian nationalism, may seem amusing at first glance, but behind it lies a much more dangerous and broader strategy.”
The P.A. has already laid claim to ancient Jewish sites as “Palestinian,” something that UNESCO (the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization) has accepted despite the ahistorical nature of those claims given the recent provenance of Palestinians as a people in the mid-20th century.
Most recently, the P.A. registered “Sebastia (State of Palestine),” as a UNESCO World Heritage Site. Sebastia served as the capital of the northern Kingdom of Israel in the Iron Age.
“The Palestinian Authority systematically works to turn UNESCO into a tool for promoting a one-sided historical narrative that erases the Jewish connection to the Land of Israel and Jerusalem,” Rosset said.
Children deserve to dream of a future, not to be indoctrinated into hate, terror, and martyrdom by the Palestinian Authority’s schools. On #WorldChildrensDay, the world must confront the PA’s relentless glorification of violence and death, and demand an immediate end to its hate education ๐ธ: @palwatch
— Israel Foreign Ministry (@IsraelMFA) November 20, 2026
Do you see it? https://t.co/zHRliULxoP
— GAZAWOOD - The Pallywood Saga - Official (@GAZAWOOD2) November 20, 2026
Not just swim meets and bodybuilding contests: On the beach in Gaza, food is being wasted in games just for fun—flour, eggs, ketchup, tahini, water, and more—all despite the nonstop claims of famine and catastrophe. https://t.co/H3GItOmCcF
— GAZAWOOD - The Pallywood Saga - Official (@GAZAWOOD2) November 20, 2026
Canadian Jews appeal to UN over Belgian circumcision trial
A Jewish organization in Canada appealed to the United Nations to intervene in a Belgian criminal case against two mohels, Jews who perform nonmedical circumcision of boys, the group said on Friday.Tory frontbenchers demand answers over barrister’s ‘shockingly lenient’ antisemitism sanction
The Jewish Hasidic Council of Quebec (CJHQ) announced that it had sent an urgent appeal to Nazila Ghanea, the U.N. special rapporteur on freedom of religion or belief, asking her to examine whether Belgium’s treatment of brit milah, or ritual circumcision, violates religious freedom.
U.N. special rapporteurs have no authority to compel a country to change its laws, policies or administrative practices.
“The situation in Belgium is intolerable for thousands of Jewish parents who have been left completely in the dark about a sacred rite that affects the entire basis of their lives in the country,” Sam Muller, CJHQ’s executive director, wrote in a statement.
“The Belgian government is covertly seeking to criminalize Brit Milah, a practice that has been authorized in Belgium since the 19th Century,” he added. “A country that bans Brit Milah—or renders it impossible through a physician-only monopoly—forces the Jewish community to leave,” he added.
Belgian prosecutors in May decided to indict Jewish circumcisers for allegedly unlawfully conducting the Jewish ritual circumcision of boys, typically performed on eight-day-old infants.
Before the criminal investigation of the mohels, which began last year, brit milah was tolerated in Belgium, though it might violate the legal requirement that any surgery be performed by licensed medical staff.
Two senior Conservatives have challenged the Bar Standards Board (BSB) over its decision to suspend a barrister who called for the global eradication of “Zios” for just four months, demanding to know whether it will appeal the ruling.Alabama man who threatened to kill rabbi sentenced to 30 months
Shadow justice secretary Nick Timothy and shadow attorney general Lord Wolfson of Tredegar KC accused the legal regulator of failing in its duty to tackle anti-Jewish racism in a joint letter to its chairman, Professor Christopher Bones, on Friday.
The pair described the sanction handed to Forz Khan, a barrister of almost 40 years, as “shockingly lenient”.
As previously reported by Jewish News, Khan was suspended this week after a disciplinary tribunal found a series of LinkedIn posts he made in March and April 2025 to be “antisemitic and/or seriously offensive”.
Among the comments were calls for “a complete global cleansing” and references to a “final solution” to Israel. In another post, Khan wrote: “Scum like this should be in a gas chamber”.
The Conservative frontbenchers also asked whether the regulator had considered a separate post about the Israeli prime minister in which Khan allegedly wrote: “I would pay to be that blessed soul that puts a bullet through this savages (sic) eyes.”
“We, and many others, regard Mr Khan’s sanction as falling somewhere between astonishing and bizarre,” they wrote.
“To be clear: we do not believe that the sanction would have been the same had Mr Khan attacked other racial groups in similar terms.”
The letter also raised concerns about the regulator’s handling of a previous complaint against another barrister who had called one of its signatories a “racist apologist for genocide and apartheid” on X.
The complaint was dismissed and the decision upheld on appeal because, although the BSB accepted the language was offensive, it did not consider it “seriously offensive”.
Jeremy Wayne Shoemaker, 35, was sentenced to 30 months in prison, followed by three years of supervised release, for “threats of death, killing and stalking” against an Alabama rabbi, the U.S. Department of Justice said on Thursday.Georgia man charged with sending funds to ISIS, destroying evidence
Shoemaker was arrested in Needham, Ala., on Oct. 27, 2025, with “multiple firearms and hundreds of rounds of ammunition” in a suitcase after threatening to attack synagogues in the state.
“I could have easily snatched you up,” Shoemaker told a Mountain Brook rabbi, whose name is redacted in court filings, in a voicemail. He also said in a message, “I hate rabbinic Judaism with everything that I have within me.”
In another voicemail, Shoemaker accused “you Talmudic Rabbis” of committing “terroristic acts” and told the rabbi, “You think you are invincible. All you Talmudic Rabbis. You think that you are f***ing gods.”
Investigators found guns and ammunition stored in a suitcase in his home and papers with contact information for religious leaders and prominent figures.
Shoemaker told investigators that he wanted to intimidate the rabbi but claimed his voicemails were satire.
Christopher Flowers, special agent in charge of the FBI Mobile Field Office, stated that law enforcement responded with “urgency.”
“Within eight hours of receiving information about a potential attack, FBI Mobile and our partners executed a search warrant and took Shoemaker into custody,” he said. “Today’s sentence reflects the consequences of his actions and the importance of identifying threats before they become acts of violence.”
Shoemaker pleaded guilty in July to interstate threatening communications and stalking.
Younes Moustafa Younes, of Lavonia, Ga., was arrested and charged with money laundering and destroying evidence after allegedly sending more than $26,000 to people and groups affiliated with the terrorist organization ISIS, the U.S. Department of Justice said on Thursday.NFL suspends star wide receiver Puka Nacua following allegations of antisemitism, assault
The 34-year-old sent $16,807 in cryptocurrency via multiple phone numbers and accounts “intended to conceal his identity” between December 2025 and June, and sent $9,206 in cryptocurrency, for which he used “an alias to conceal his support,” to addresses connected to ISIS between December 2021 and 2022, prosecutors said.
The Justice Department said that Younes intended to send the funds to support ISIS in Syria. He faces up to 40 years in prison and $750,000 in fines on each charge. That would be followed by up to six years of supervised release on both counts.
When FBI agents executed a search warrant at his apartment, they found three cell phones “submerged in an unknown solution,” one of which “was smashed and another with its identification number removed,” according to court filings.
The FBI also found “shredded documents submerged in an unknown solution in a bathtub.”
In 2020, Younes allegedly began viewing ISIS propaganda online. “When interviewed by law enforcement, Younes acknowledged viewing the material but denied supporting extremist ideologies,” the Justice Department said.
According to the bureau, he was radicalized over time and expressed “support for ISIS and other terrorist figures and organizations through encrypted communications with associates.”
The NFL suspended Los Angeles Rams star wide receiver Puka Nacua for three games on Thursday, months after he faced a lawsuit from a woman who alleged that he had made an “unprovoked antisemitic statement.”
But Nacua - who led the league in receptions last season - won’t miss any additional games, as the league is allowing him to serve the suspension while he recovers from an injury.
Madison Atiabi, who is Jewish, alleged that Nacua, 25, said “f- all the Jews” at a dinner in LA last New Year’s Eve. According to the lawsuit, Atiabi said she “immediately felt uncomfortable and emotionally distressed.”
Atiabi also alleged that Nacua “forcibly” bit her on the left shoulder, “leaving a circular imprint of his teeth on her body,” and that he bit her friend’s thumb “with such force that her companion screamed in acute pain.”
Nacua’s attorney, Levi McCathern, said in a statement at the time that Nacua denied the antisemitism allegations “in the strongest possible terms.” McCathern characterized the biting as “horseplay.” No charges were filed, and the civil case is ongoing.
NYC Port Authority station last night 8:45pm - this man allegedly directed antisemitic slurs at a Jewish man. Listen as the victim follows him, camera rolling. The perpetrator initially runs away, but eventually breaks his silence with yet another bigoted remark Recognize him? Send us a DM.
— StopAntisemitism (@StopAntisemites) November 20, 2026
Jonny Greenwood and Dudu Tassa release new song in Arabic music project
Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood and Israeli rocker Dudu Tassa will release “Jalsa,” their new collaborative album on December 4, and on Tuesday unveiled the lead single “Ya Hala Bid-Dayf.”
“Jalsa” is the second installment in the pair’s “Jarak Qaribak” project, launched in 2023, which celebrates Middle Eastern music and artists. Loosely translated, the project’s title means “your neighbor is your friend.”
Tassa and Greenwood recently opened the Jerusalem International Oud Festival performing songs from “Jarak Qaribak,” with a band of local Arabic- and Hebrew-speaking musicians and singers including two guest singers, Karrar Alsaadi from Baghdad and Jianna Nadaf from Nazareth.
“Ya Hala Bid-Dayf” is a classic Lebanese folk song reimagined with vocals from Zeina, a singer from the United Arab Emirates.
“Singing this song was a special honor for me,” she said in a statement. “I feel that bringing such a timeless melody to a new generation is a beautiful way of keeping our musical heritage alive. Music has no borders, and this project is a wonderful celebration of that.”
“Jarak Qaribak” brings together vocalists and musicians from across the Middle East, creating collaborations with its covers of Arabic songs from throughout the region.
“I’ve loved this music for 30 years, and I am happy to be finally working with people devoted to it,” Greenwood noted in a Rolling Stone item. “When music crosses borders, it reminds us that love and longing sound alike in every language.”
Thank you Rebecca De Mornay๐ https://t.co/UNxHUJC1CI
— Mor Edge Insight (@MorEdge_Insight) November 20, 2026
New book honours lives and legacies of 440 Holocaust survivors and refugees
The lives and legacies of 440 Holocaust survivors and refugees who made Britain their home is being celebrated with the publication of a new book by the Association of Jewish Refugees.Australian leaders warn of growing antisemitism across academia, arts, and politics
Uprooted Lives: Obituaries of Refugees and Survivors of the Holocaust from the AJR Journal 1955–2025 is a collection of personal histories and around 350 photos, documenting how those who fled Nazi persecution rebuilt their lives, with many going on to make remarkable contributions to Britain.
The coffee-table book, edited by Andrew Kaufman MBE, AJR honorary life president, and Dr Bea Lewkowicz OBE, director of the AJR Refugee Voices Testimony Archive, has been published to mark the 80th anniversary of the AJR Journal, which originally published the obituaries.
There are many recognisable names among the obituaries – selected from around 1,400 – including children's author Judith Kerr OBE, psychoanalyst Anna Freud CBE and five Nobel Prize winners.
But alongside these are hundreds of lesser-known individuals, including educators, doctors, artists, and entrepreneurs, whose obituaries illustrate how they too helped shape modern Britain.
Andrew Kaufman MBE said editing the book had been a “deeply personal” project for him. “As the son of refugees, whose own father's story is among those featured, I know how important it is that these extraordinary lives are remembered.
“What began as an idea to preserve the obituaries published in the AJR Journal has become a tribute to a community of remarkable individuals who, having experienced persecution and displacement, rebuilt their lives and contributed so much to Britain. Their stories deserve to be remembered, not only for what they endured, but for everything they achieved.”
Dr Bea Lewkowicz OBE said: “Behind every obituary is a remarkable human story – of lives uprooted by persecution, families torn apart and the courage to begin again. Together, these 440 accounts form a unique record of a generation whose experiences might otherwise be lost.
“As the number of those who can share their stories firsthand diminishes, preserving these histories becomes ever more urgent. This book ensures that their voices, experiences and contributions will continue to inform and inspire future generations.”
Dr Lewkowicz, a leading oral historian, said the book was also an important record of how the refugee community remembered its own history, as many of the earliest obituaries included details of individuals who died before oral history testimony projects became widespread.
The book launch at JW3, attended by members of the refugee and survivor community and their descendants, featured discussions led by Kaufman and Lewkowicz.
Australian academics, artists, and community leaders warned of the growing impact of antisemitism across Australian society during a panel discussion at The Jerusalem Post Australia Summit in Sydney on Thursday, calling for greater action from political and institutional leaders.
Professor Catharine Lumby of the University of Sydney described the experiences of Jewish students and colleagues following the October 7 massacre and the subsequent establishment of anti-Israel encampments on campus.
Lumby recalled finding a young woman wearing a Star of David crying outside her lecture theater and encountering antisemitic graffiti on university grounds. Advertisement
“I feel I'm an ally to the Jewish community in this time of rising antisemitism. I'm appalled by it,” she said.
Lumby said one Jewish colleague had taken 11 months of stress leave and warned that the Jewish community was increasingly caught between extremists on the far Right and far Left.
She acknowledged that some demonstrators were simply protesting against the war but warned of the use of anti-Zionism as a means of expressing antisemitism.
“The word Zionism has become interchangeable with Jew in some contexts,” she said. “It's a polite way of being antisemitic.”
Lumby also called for more non-Jewish Australians to speak out against antisemitism and warned of the role social media algorithms and artificial intelligence played in increasing polarization.
Ben Adler, director of SHIR, the Australian Jewish Music Festival, described how a concert in Melbourne last year was forced to relocate after receiving threats, including one involving Molotov cocktails.
Adler said the festival had sold 1,000 tickets when the venue canceled the performance eight days before the event. The organizers eventually secured an alternative venue.
The musician said Jewish artists had faced bullying, intimidation, and professional exclusion, with many cultural institutions unwilling to stand up to anti-Israel activists.
Former Waverley Council mayor Will Nemesh criticized the response of Australian authorities to rising antisemitism, describing the deterioration of social cohesion following October 7.
Nemesh said governments at the local, state, and federal levels had failed to respond sufficiently, allowing hatred to become normalized.
He recalled the series of firebombings and targeted assaults across Sydney's eastern suburbs that preceded the massacre at Bondi Beach, the consequences of which, he said, continued to be felt by the community.
Australian Jewish musician says answer to antisemitism is to live Jewish life openly and proudly
The answer to antisemitism is not for Jews to retreat from public life, but to make their culture, identity and traditions more visible, Australian musician and festival director Ben Adler told The Jerusalem Post.Centre for Independent Studies: Arsen Ostrovsky on Surviving Terror and Fighting Antisemitism
"We believe the answer to antisemitism is not retreating from Jewish life. It's living Jewish life openly, proudly, and confidently," Adler said at The Jerusalem Post Australia Summit in Sydney on Thursday.
As director of Shir, Australia's national Jewish music festival, and a violinist who leads the band Chutney, Adler has spent his career bringing Jewish music to wider audiences. Since October 7, however, he says that mission has become increasingly challenging, with Jewish artists facing growing reluctance from cultural institutions to give them a platform.
Adler described a growing reluctance among festival directors, radio stations, grants panels, award committees and arts administrators to associate themselves with Jewish artists and openly Zionist performers.
About a month after October 7, a festival director who had previously offered his band a major platform called to withdraw the invitation.
"I'm really sorry, but things are awkward now," she told him, citing the "complicated situation overseas."
Adler said it became clear that the concern was not the music itself, but the possibility of protests or criticism from anti-Zionist activists. Following several conversations, the festival ultimately reinstated the performance.
"What I've found is that much of the cancellation comes not from people who personally believe Israel is evil, but from people who fear the consequences of being associated with Jewish artists," he said.
In this episode of Liberalism in Question, Robert Forsyth speaks with Arsen Ostrovsky, head of the Sydney office of the Australia/Israel & Jewish Affairs Council. Weeks after returning to Australia from Israel with his family, Ostrovsky was shot in the head at a Hanukkah celebration on Bondi Beach—the first time he had ever experienced antisemitism in the country where he grew up after his family fled the Soviet Union as refugees.
The conversation explores one of the sharpest challenges facing liberal societies today: political and ethnic violence, imported foreign conflicts, and the rise of antisemitism. Ostrovsky discusses what it means to be both a proud Australian and a Zionist, why the denial of Jewish self-determination is not ordinary political disagreement, and how a liberal democracy can remain open without tolerating intolerance. He also reflects on survival as a responsibility to tell the truth and defend the civic culture that once made Australia a beacon of freedom.
An incredible love story, born from one of the worst days in Australian history, reached a special milestone today. Two first responders who crossed paths in the moments after the Bondi Beach terror attack revisited the site to tie the knot. https://t.co/lZrrBxFavi
— 7NEWS Sydney (@7NewsSydney) November 20, 2026
May love always prevail! I am so overjoyed for this beautiful couple, Lexi and Jimmy! https://t.co/QXZ9TNeJPW
— Arsen Ostrovsky (@Ostrov_A) November 20, 2026
